Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

General health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Moving PND article in todays Observer

29 replies

fisil · 18/01/2004 16:55

Did any of you read this in today's Observer magazine?

It had me in tears.

OP posts:
tamum · 18/01/2004 17:01

Written by a fellow mumsnetter if I'm not very much mistaken- if you scroll through the lost strawberry thread here , skie mentions being an Observer journalist and having written a PND article. If only we had a proud smiley emoticon!

pie · 18/01/2004 17:04

Wow...that was quite harrowing But such a good article.

fisil · 18/01/2004 17:06

Oh yes. What a fanastic week for Skie - a brilliant article and a strawberry reunion! )(

(do you like my grinning from ear to ear similey - does that do "proud" well enough?)

OP posts:
tamum · 18/01/2004 17:07

God, sorry, I just read it all the way through, and my post sounded hideously flippant, sorry. It is a fantastic article, but so very sad.

katierocket · 18/01/2004 17:14

brilliant article - makes you really think

ks · 18/01/2004 18:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

suedonim · 18/01/2004 18:36

An incredibly moving article. Having btdt, I think it caught the essence of pnd. My good news is that it didn't recur with subsequent pg's.

tigermoth · 18/01/2004 19:45

agree, a very sobering read.

jac34 · 18/01/2004 20:09

Just sat here crying as well, it brought back some awful memories.

kizzie · 19/01/2004 11:52

Skie - I specifically bought the Observer because I read on the other thread about your article. (Im also a journo - though broadcast rather than print.)
I found it very upsetting to read but only because it was so well written and brought back all the terror and horror.
Although I think I recovered from the PND Im still caught up in it because I became addicted to seroxat and now in a long drawn out process to get off it.
It was very worrying to read about the mums who just didnt recover but I suppose we just have to try and not dwell on those terrible tragedies.
Anyway Im sure it will have encouraged some women who are suffering in silence to seek some help.
Kizziex

M2T · 19/01/2004 12:19

My goodness. What a brilliantly written article. Moving and disturbing!
It definitely brought back memories for me. And something that really gave me an eerie feeling is the fact that the woman made up terrible financial scenarios and eventually would refuse to go to a cash point.... since ds was born I won't use one either. I hadn't thought of it before now. Hmmm.

1 in 5 is a scary statistic. I am definitely going to print this off for DH to read. And hopefully if it happens again with this baby DH and I will be more prepared.

Well done Skie.

skie · 19/01/2004 12:30

thanks - glad you liked it! nice to get feedback (which freelancers never usually do)

susanmt · 19/01/2004 12:39

A brilliant article - totally captures what pnd is about. It makes me realise how lucky I have been to get treatment and help the last times - and that I need to do so again.

dinosaur · 19/01/2004 12:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Batters · 19/01/2004 12:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Blu · 19/01/2004 12:50

Well Done! Horrifying, but lots of brilliant information.
A big than you to all our MN journalists who are getting these things aired...it has been of great personal help to me.

FairyMum · 19/01/2004 13:52

Very informative and good article. Very upsetting too

Enid · 19/01/2004 13:56

I thought it was a really frightening article. Although well written, it has really upset my sister who is planning a baby this year. My mother suffered with pnd and my sister is now terrified it might happen to her.

I think it would have been less scary if Skie had dwelt on the fact the most pnd doesnt get that bad...my sister is now really scared that she is going to become suicidal after her baby is born!

M2T · 19/01/2004 14:01

Enid - I think the point of the article was to deal with the harsh reality of PND. And although (thankfully!) most women do not commit suicide, many feel like they want to or feel that it is the only way out. I know I did.
And the information about help/support for partners too is wonderful.

Enid · 19/01/2004 14:12

I know, I can see and understand that it does get that bad. It was a good article but it really upset her, poor lamb.

ks · 19/01/2004 14:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

FairyMum · 19/01/2004 14:44

I agree with KS. I suffered from PND after having my DD and less after DS because I knew more what to expect. I think it is so important to inform people what PND is and how many women it affects. I also think men get a form PND and hardly anything is written about it.

melsy · 19/01/2004 19:48

Very good article Skie, I got more disturbed by it with every paragraph and by the end I couldnt read anymore as I was crying. It is a horrible horrible condition which I am still being treated for , but hopefully through the worst. It seems not surprising that the statitics are higher than recorded, as I always wondered how many women dont tell anyone. How terrible is that for a women who could so easily be treated.

Twink · 19/01/2004 21:32

Good article, I knew I'd be vulnerable as did dh and thanks to him I've made it through so far, although there have been VERY low points (not least because I hadn't found Mumsnet)

Off to find out about Strawberry now..

Twink · 19/01/2004 21:36

Oh Susan, really sorry to hear you're going through it again, I know there's nothing I can say to make 'it' go away but I hope you get the help you need and come through it well.

Thinking of you, xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread