Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Geeky stuff

Home cinema surround sound advice

6 replies

secretsantasquirrels · 08/12/2013 13:14

DS1 has asked for this for his 18th birthday. It's for watching films in the living room rather than listening to music but I don't know where to start? Does it mean miles more wires around the room or are they wi-fi?
The room is 26' x 15' with the tv in one corner.

OP posts:
MinnesotaNice · 08/12/2013 13:25

What's your budget? I don't know a lot about complicated surround sound systems, but when we were in a house and I knew we were only going to be there a few years, we bought an older version of this: www.bose.co.uk/GB/en/home-and-personal-audio/home-cinema-and-sound-for-tv/sound-for-tv/bose-solo-tv-sound-system/

Saves you from having wires everywhere, which I can't stand. In a later house we had the surround speakers built into the ceiling and all the wire run behind the walls, but I'm guessing this isn't an option now.

secretsantasquirrels · 08/12/2013 15:10

MinnesotaNice thanks,a bit above what I wanted to pay, I was thinking up to £200. It's only one speaker though, does it really do surround sound?
Ironically when we had this house built in the 1980s we had state of the art sound wiring done which is all now obsolete Grin.

OP posts:
Ferguson · 08/12/2013 23:35

Hi -
No, the Bose will only give 'simulated' effects, and some TVs or other audio equipment also has a 'wide' feature, but only achieves it by messing about with 'phase' effects I assume, and can sound grim and very unrealistic!

Why is your state of the art wiring obsolete? 'Wireless' isn't essential is it, and can introduce it's own problems?

What sound systems do you already have, for CD, radio, etc, as could some of that not be integrated into a surround system?

26'X15' is a good size, but ideally the TV should be roughly in the middle of the 15' side, so you can sit well back down the length of the room.

A surround amplifier has controls to balance each of the four 'corner' speakers, plus a centre channel (to avoid the 'hole in the middle' effect), and a sub-bass speaker, which can be placed almost anywhere I think.

Don't want deflate ambition, but I don't think you will get much for £200. My stereo system was around £5K, and that's only just above 'entry level'. A serious enthusiast would add another 'nought' to that.

Another factor that has a huge effect on sound quality is the size of a room, particularly the height. My system can't really 'communicate' in our low ceilinged bungalow, but twenty years ago I used my previous system in a large hall for a social club 'record recital' and it was sensational. Normally, speakers shouldn't be placed too near any walls, as reflections will cloud the spacial 'image'. But conversely, people who really know what they are doing, can use walls to their advantage.

So, weigh up what you already HAVE in the way of amps, speakers etc, then go online to specialist surround sites, and glean more information (even though you aren't considering their prices.)

I guess, if you go for the multi-channel amplifier/control unit first, then add the speakers and sub as you go along, might give better results than doing it all in one go.

Also, at 18 if DS is creative he could possibly make some of the speakers (from on-line plans) only needing to buy the 'drivers'. And creating an ultra-low 'sub' could be a real achievement!

secretsantasquirrels · 09/12/2013 09:33

Ferguson Thanks for that it's really helpful. I need to do some homework now.
Relocating the tv is not an option due to fireplace and existing wiring.
As I said it's for film viewing not music. I'm tone deaf so it's of no real interest to me but the rest of the family would benefit I guess.

an ultra-low 'sub hmm, that's a phrase I've only ever heard from my 17 year old. Actually his first idea for an 18th was for some kind of ultra low speakers to be fitted in my car. I said no to that Smile

OP posts:
ChillyChillyIcebat · 10/12/2013 00:59

www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B004MY4PU6/?tag=ho01f-21

Something like this would be on budget, the price fluctuates and does drop below £200. You will have to hide / live with the wires though.

caroldecker · 10/12/2013 01:31

I used Richer sounds, great advice and value. www.richersounds.com/products/home-cinema/home-cinema-separates/home-cinema-systems

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread