Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Geeky stuff

Smart TV - which one do we want??

14 replies

mistressploppy · 14/04/2012 21:18

DH has decided the time has come to get a proper slim internetty fabby tv. We are CLUELESS. DH's usual strategy is to buy the most expensive one, assuming that that will be the best Hmm

Following a quick chat, I think these are the important things for us:

40" or thereabouts
Smart - does iPlayer, LoveFilm etc
Built-in wifi
Picture quality (my FIL's tv makes everything look like a cheap eastern European soap opera)
Easy to use/intuitive navigation

We have Sky+
We rarely watch dvds
We never play computer games

DH is concerned that it be future proof as far as possible, so even though we don't really want social networking gumf, 3D tv etc at the moment, we might do one day(??)

Any ideas? We've heard that Samsung and Panasonic are good...

OP posts:
ThePieSmuggler · 14/04/2012 21:23

We've recently bought a samsung one that does all the things you want, we decided that although we aren't that bothered about having 3d we opted for it because it meant we had a better quality picture overall. I'd agree that Samsung and Panasonic are the best brands, along with Sony (but Sony is more expensive). We went for an LED one and we're really pleased with it.

mistressploppy · 14/04/2012 21:31

Thanks Pie - which one did you get? DH wants this one...

OP posts:
niceguy2 · 15/04/2012 09:43

OMG Mistrssploppy, I think I just came in my pants!

Tell your DH to get that TV NOW! If he doesn't like it, I'll take it! (cough)

WMittens · 15/04/2012 10:45

If you're wanting to use LoveFilm's streaming service, you will need to get a Sony, Samsung, LG or Cello TV (never heard of Cello before), or a Sony, Samsung or LG blu ray player - I wish I'd known that before I got my Panasonic TV and BR player.

It doesn't sound like you're going to be using any Full HD sources (blu ray, games console) or 3D for a while, so I would suggest don't spend too much. A 720p screen will be sufficient - the limiting factor is going to be the signal going into the TV, rather than the screen resolution. If you were using LoveFilm to rent BR discs, then I would say get a 1080p screen.

Don't worry about future proofing, prices on consumer goods only ever go down so by the time you want Full HD or 3D you will be able to get a better deal anyway (unless you're talking in the next few months).

I quite like Samsung screens, I think they give a good quality picture at a decent price point, LG aren't too bad either.

NetworkGuy · 15/04/2012 14:11

"A 720p screen will be sufficient - the limiting factor is going to be the signal going into the TV, rather than the screen resolution. If you were using LoveFilm to rent BR discs, then I would say get a 1080p screen."

At this stage, I think there's still some way to go regarding dropping prices on the LED TVs, and I'm not convinced a "smart" TV is guaranteed to be the best option. I see it might be nice to have everything in one box, for neatness, but (assuming it doesn't include a DVD player) wonder what else will be plugged into it.

In my case, I bought a low cost (290 quid) 42" TV late last year. It's not a well-known brand (Hannspree, AKA Hanns-G, which is a firm that's made displays for computers for years, and has moved on to TV / bigger screens).

I also bought a PS3 (which plays Blu-Ray and ordinary DVDs). The PS3 can handle Netflix (though I am not a customer yet), LoveFilm, and iPlayer, plus 4oD and ITV player (no cost, though I think I needed to register for PlayStation Network, after which it could download the necessary software via an ethernet cable into my ADSL router... PS3 can use wireless but I prefer cables for streaming as I have a number of Wi-Fi items in use already, and LoveFilm needs around 3 Mbps by itself, so could hog quite a bit of the Wi-Fi traffic).

No "3D" or anything like that (basic entertainment channels on Sky, though I have a FreeSat HD box for another room), but I have another set if anything went wrong with the TV, and if the PS3 was faulty, I'd still have my TV and Sky box to entertain even if the "online" features from the PS3 (and Blu-Ray of course) were not available while PS3 is away for repair.

I can see how a super-slim LED TV might be a very attractive option (one with integrated FreeSat HD and Freeview HD, perhaps, so no separate satellite box would be needed), but my angle is that separate boxes can be replaced or repaired without losing all functionality, and maybe in 5-10 years I would be ready to consider 3D.

Right now even Full HD isn't something I find 'essential' but I would still go for a 1920 x 1080 screen, partly because that's now the expected standard for BR and most of my PCs can output that, but also because I don't see the point of buying a 720p screen now and then buying newer boxes which will make it the "incompatible" well before it is due for replacement.

I'm just about to hunt down another 40"/42" TV with 4 HDMI inputs (whereas the set I bought only has 2 and cannot cope with Freeview+ box, Sky+ HD, PS3, and my Toshiba laptop very well). Whatever I get will likely have Freeview and be 1080p but the more important choices for me will be price and 4 inputs than whether it is Plasma, LCD, or LED.

ThePieSmuggler · 17/04/2012 12:09

Sorry, only just came back to this thread, we got the samsung ue46d6100, which actually now I look at your list again doesn't have wifi included and is nowhere near as fancy as the one your DH wants Grin

NetworkGuy · 18/04/2012 02:40

Being nosey, OP, but is FiL's TV from Loewe, by any chance?

mistressploppy · 18/04/2012 03:58

Hi, thanks for all the replies! We pinched my mum's Which login and checked things out and the bloody Samsung one came out top, so think we might be going for that anyway Grin, but maybe the older model which is still available but cheaper.

No idea what make FIL's tv is, but it's in his house in Portugal so probably some crappy Portuguese brand. Come to think of it, maybe I WAS just watching a cheap European soap opera....Wink

If/when we get the new telly I shall update with news!

OP posts:
mistressploppy · 05/06/2012 21:31

We bought the Samsung one in my link at the weekend - it gets delivered on Friday Smile.

Just reviving the thread as I'll probably need some help setting the damn thing up....

OP posts:
Housewifefromheaven · 05/06/2012 21:43

I can't believe it! Just deciding myself which tv to buy, we are thinking this one however does anyone know about voice control element? I like the idea of it, but also I liked the idea of siri on my iPhone too and what a load of crap that is :o

mistressploppy · 05/06/2012 22:41

I'll let you know what it's like when ours arrives! I think it has voice control ....

OP posts:
Housewifefromheaven · 05/06/2012 22:53

Cheers mistress am excited on your behalf :o

Housewifefromheaven · 08/06/2012 20:39

How's the tv? :o

mistressploppy · 11/06/2012 07:18

Forgot to post, sorry! It's GREAT! Haven't really explored voice control yet but the picture is fab and it's got lots of bells and whistles; great fun to have Facebook etc on there. We got a free keyboard with it. Highly recommend!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page