Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Gardening

Find tips and tricks to make your garden or allotment flourish on our Gardening forum.

Calling all heavy clay gardeners! Which plants worked (and which didn't)?

34 replies

chickpea1982 · 04/05/2024 19:25

My garden is on heavy clay,which gets very waterlogged during the winter (ok, late autumn and winter through to early spring). I've been here a few years now and seen several plants die because they can't cope with being so waterlogged for part of the year. I've resolved this year to only plant things which can tolerate soggy ground and heavy clay soil.

Something I find a bit frustrating is that, when you look up what soil a plant likes, it almost always says 'free draining'. But it's harder to find out what plants will tolerate soggy soil,band which definitely won't. I thought a thread on the topic would be a good idea so we can share our experiences.

Currently thriving in my garden:

Camelia
Cornus (the one with red stems)
Philadelphus
Weigela
Cherry tree
Malus Rudolph (tree)
Viburnum tinus
Spirea
Acer (tree)
Pittosporum
Osmanthus burkwoodii
Enkianthus campanulatus
Leucothoe fontanesiana
Escallonia iveyi
Hydrangea
Berberis
Viburnum plucatum mariesii
Nandina domestica

It's hard to remember everything which has died, but off the top of my head:

Eucalyptus gunni (I should have seen that one coming!)
Delphinium
Choisya ternata Sundance (didn't die, but really struggled)
Syringa vulgaris (lilac) - again, didn't die, but struggled and has never flowered
Convulvus cneorum
Hebe (almost but not quite dead)
Dicentra spectabilis
Pretty much every bulb I've ever planted

I'd be interested to hear from anyone else with similar soil to see what's worked for you and what hasn't.

OP posts:
Bibnle636 · 04/05/2024 22:21

Thriving

roses, roses and more roses
climbing hydrangea
verbena bonariensis
blackcurrant
star jasmine
echinacea( weirdly)
honeysuckle
a couple of clematis ( sugar sweet and alba luxurians)
buddleia
viburnum opulus
Russian sage
geranium Roxanne
aliums
ladies mantle
Nepeta
Wisteria
crocosmia
peony

Dead
2 x clematis montana
1x clematis aramandii
a couple of salvias

Ok but I’d like better
geranium
hebe

Orangemangogrape · 04/05/2024 23:55

UnaOfStormhold · 04/05/2024 19:48

For most spring bulbs I find the only way is to plant them in pots in the autumn and then plant them out in the spring as the ground dries out a bit. I do have a few stubborn ones that come up year after year but I don't know how they manage to avoid rotting!

Have you tried planting them on a layer of gravel?

jiskoot · 05/05/2024 00:02

I would second the Astilbe vote, I've got very clay soil, although slightly improved over the last couple of years and I planted some astilbe last year and left them to it and they're doing great

Catname · 05/05/2024 00:28

Has anyone mentioned Persicaria, Lysimachia (Ephemerum or Clethroides and maybe others) Symphyotrichum laeve 'Glow in the Dark', and Physostegia? They do remarkably well (virtually thugs) sitting in my border which has been waterlogged since October.

Plants that have failed? Too many to remember. I appear to have lost three Agapanthus Poppin Purple that I was so pleased to find last year - but several other varieties are OK. Osteospermum, some Echinaceas, some Heleniums, Leucanthemums, Perovskia.

colouringindoors · 05/05/2024 00:48

Great thread OP thanks! Seriously brick-making heavy clay here..

What's happy:
Roses
Clematis montana
Various perennial Geraniums
Japanese Anemone
Alchemilla mollis
Cornus
Cotinus
Crocosmia various
Centaurea
Forsythia
Astrantia
Bluebells
Narcissi Tete a Tete
Hellebores
Forget me nots
Primrose
Hardy Fuschia
Privet
Lonicera nitida
Aquilegia
Muscari
Sedum Autumn Joy

MereDintofPandiculation · 05/05/2024 09:50

GertrudeJekyllAndHyde · 04/05/2024 21:27

My list of successful plants is pretty much as above.

Clematis montana and viticella do well; all others sink without trace.

Clematis alpina also does well for me, but I don’t grow it in the waterlogged bit

GertrudeJekyllAndHyde · 05/05/2024 09:58

Ah, I’d forgotten clematis cirrhosa Wisley Cream, which is so content it self-seeds and layers itself.

Geneticsbunny · 05/05/2024 10:09

GertrudeJekyllAndHyde · 04/05/2024 21:27

My list of successful plants is pretty much as above.

Clematis montana and viticella do well; all others sink without trace.

I have managed to keep the clematis cirrhosa alive too and it is thriving. Flowers December through to march roughly.

CatherinedeBourgh · 06/05/2024 12:57

Bookmarking this thread, as am currently gardening on heavy clay for the first time in my life. Surprisingly, lilacs do well in my garden, I suspect because there is an evil leylandii hedge on one side that dries out the ground in a fairly large area.

I've also created a bank on which I am doing much of my more ornamental planting, so that at least drains fairly well, which may explain why the hebes I've put in are doing very well.

I've put in lots of trees that I am peering at anxiously all winter. So far only a pawlonia and a quercus coccineus have died. Another pawlonia was doing great (closer to the hedge) but has been eaten down to the stem by slugs this year, I hope it comes back, as I have another two to put in the ground when I figure out where to put them!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page