Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Gardening

Find tips and tricks to make your garden or allotment flourish on our Gardening forum.

Right now it would be cheaper to go to the supermarket and just buy the slugs some vegetables. Thoughts?

43 replies

fillyjonk · 31/08/2007 08:53

Here is the thing

We have had pretty much nothing off the allotment this year. This is entirely the work of slugs.

I have really tried everything that is not slug pellets. If you go to the HDRA and CAT sites and scroll down the suggestions-have done pretty much all of them. Short list of what we've done: slug pubs, bran, salt, marigolds, sacrificial crops, "non-toxic" pellets, copper. Probably more stuff.

I haven't done a pond-we seem to need planning permission , plus we have young kids and another on the way and there is nowhere to site the pond in plain view. Am not allowed livestock so ducks etc are out

This has been a really bad year in that they even ate the tomatoes and most of the potatoes. But we NEVER have anything except tomatoes, potatoes, and berries. Am getting fed up tbh. We do grow a small number of courgettes, lettuce etc in the back garden where slugs aren't so bad, we are reasonably good at actually growing stuff, but the slugs on this plot are very bad.

The soil is poor, though we've improved it a lot in the last few years. In particular it is so clayey that there is no point using nematodes. Also, there don't seem to be many natural predators-birds, frogs etc-about, possibly because everyone ELSE is using slug pellets.

Thoughts? How bad ARE slug pellets? My kids won't touch them, they are pretty good, but am worried about effect on wildlife.

OP posts:
fillyjonk · 31/08/2007 19:25

YES FMV

So have I.

I have bloody worked my ar$e off, and am FED UP

is this a bad year, do you reckon? I've always had at least tomatoes and courgettes-I mean, I wouldn't try lettuce or anything fancy but TOMATOES and COURGETTES?

OP posts:
filthymindedvixen · 31/08/2007 19:27

last year I was drowning in courgettes. This year NOT ONE Ooooh I dream of drowning in courgettes.... And feck a ll beans too
And My potates were blighted. And my shallots rotted in the ground

Roskva · 31/08/2007 19:28

The slugs have even eaten my lemon thyme and the flowers on the lavender!!! I read somewhere that there is more of them than usual this year because we haven't had a warm dry spell to kill the little s*ds off - apparently there is around 60 slugs per square metre this year, eeewwwww.

fillyjonk · 31/08/2007 19:29

YES I have blight too. Really bad. Its odd.

I've been breeding some blight resistant tomatoes, and even they have all been wiped out.

Its just been a crap year and that makes me really sad, as we will have a 6 mo next summer and I find gardening with babies aged around 4-18 months to be bloody hard work.

OP posts:
fillyjonk · 31/08/2007 19:30

ok I do have one theory

is there not a chance that because of the increased slug population, there will be an increased predator population next year?

so hopefully we WILL get the dry spell but also an increase in predators?

OP posts:
filthymindedvixen · 31/08/2007 19:30

oh I know, I've been there.
And I will be working 4 days a week from september, so won't have half as much free time as this year. Sigh.

filthymindedvixen · 31/08/2007 19:31

Oh gods, a plague of frogs!!???

Kathyis6incheshigh · 31/08/2007 19:33

I am hugely pissed off because I have been on maternity leave this year and thus had the leisure to grow tomatoes. Next year I'll be away from home half the week and can't expect poor dh to look after both dcs single-handed and do my watering.

What are the predators? hedgehogs? birds?

Slubberdegullion · 31/08/2007 19:35

pointydog, that is a good point. The hedgehogs will be having a field day, I bet the UK hedgehog population will be facing it's first obesity crisis this year.

fillyjonk · 31/08/2007 19:35

predators are birds, hedgehogs and I THOUGHT frogs though no one seems to be confirming that

The thing is, this year I did find organic gardening utterly impossible.

I really don't know what to do, tbh.

The slugs even went for a load of pumpkins on my window sills (outside).

NO PUMPKINS FOR HALLOWEEN

OP posts:
OrmIrian · 31/08/2007 19:35

Plague of frogs wouldn't be so bad. I would get more upset at the rain of blood ....

Slubberdegullion · 31/08/2007 19:37

There you are the toad is the slug's worst enemy.

Ugly noisy buggers mind.

Kathyis6incheshigh · 31/08/2007 19:39

LOL Slubber.

Slubberdegullion · 31/08/2007 19:41

God the Cane Toad plague in Queensland

filthymindedvixen · 01/09/2007 10:43

right that's it. I'm going to dig me a pond!

Hallgerda · 04/09/2007 08:23

Slug pellets are the work of the devil, and you are doing the right thing in avoiding them. However, I've had about as much success as you with the alternatives - I think one of our slugs was quite enjoying the electric shock from the copper strip, as it had been traversed several times by the same trail. As for predators, I have observed blackbirds in my garden starting to tackle slugs which I hadn't seen them doing before this year, so they could be worth encouraging with food and water (though they also love berries, which could give you a different problem).

If your children are sensible enough not to eat slug pellets, would they enjoy a "who can catch the most slugs" competition? I hesitate to suggest the use of child labour to one of MN's more ethical folk, but it might just work...

snorkle · 06/09/2007 18:48

Went out to pick a lettuce last night and found a fat frog in the veg patch which appeared to be eating a small slug . We've had several frogs since dd filled her sandpit with water & raised tadpoles (though this one was FAR too big to be one of those) and not too bad a slug problem, so I think that frogs probably do help with slugs.

FairyBasslet · 15/09/2007 21:50

I had pretty much written this year off completely. The slugs ate all my courgettes, carrots, lettuce, onions (well, I had to dig them up shallot-sized as the blighters had munched all of the leaves, so I suppose not a total write off), and everything else but we now have a hedgehog nesting in our garden and lo and behold, I haven't seen a slug for a couple of weeks.

We sat and watched the little hedgehog collect bits of bamboo to make its nest one morning a few weeks ago, making me late for work as I just couldn't bear to drag the DC away. I mean, it's not often you see a hedgehog in daytime.

Bit too late for this year now, but I'm really hoping the whole family stick around for next year to keep the slug population down.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page