Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Food/recipes

For related content, visit our food content hub.

Boring or downright horrible soups - tell me your soup secrets.

64 replies

Giggorata · 19/09/2025 10:57

I am on a mission to use up all my veggies and/or to make good use of the vegetable boxes that DH brings home from the supermarket.

How can I avoid that sour smell that some soups acquire the next day?
How can I make them a bit tasty and interesting?

I have tried with and without the broth mix, with and without cabbage, lots of garlic or none, even veg stock cubes. Also the Polish seasoning stuff, soy sauce and/or Worcestershire sauce. With or without potatoes..

I don't really want to fill them full of UPF stuff, or salt. What is the secret?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bideo · 19/09/2025 15:22

KimHwn · 19/09/2025 15:14

I love soup and make it all the time. But the one soup I have never mastered, and have never tasted a decent one whilst dining out, is anything with parsnips. Just a tiny bit makes the whole thing taste like sweaty farts. Keep away from the parsnips.

Parsnips (and any sweet veg) need something spicy imo. I love parnsip and ginger soup, although don't like parsnips themselves much at all.

GripGetter · 19/09/2025 15:31

Onion soup with beef and chicken stock, red and white martini (or wine). In for a penny...

Cauliflower cheese soup

Fennel bulb / fennel bulb and tinned tomato. Needs very little else.

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 19/09/2025 15:48

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 19/09/2025 15:20

Me too - I think it's when vegetables ferment slightly. I think the answer is 'refrigerate'.

My favourite soup is courgette; with garlic, Parmesan, cream and a good wodge of basil. It's delicious and the basil makes it summery fresh.

Courgette is one of my favourites too but so often i get that horrible bitter flavour in it.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/09/2025 15:51

I always use Swiss bouillon and to be honest the only homemade soups I’ve donethat I thought were really nice were pumpkin, broccoli and blue cheese and cauliflower and blue cheese

IHateEmptyPockets · 19/09/2025 15:58

OdeToTheNorthWestWind · 19/09/2025 14:13

There was a whole weight-loss diet program based around cabbage soup in the 1980s and it's just coming back into fashion. I think it works on the basis that it puts you off food for weeks at a time😁

Oh I remember that! Was a tad windy too if I recall correctly… (shudder)

UncertainPerson · 19/09/2025 16:08

Mine are not good either 😬. I’m veggie, can anyone recommend a decent veggie stock?

oncemoreuntothebeachdearfriends · 19/09/2025 18:10

I love this book 📧

Seasonal recipes, some of the soups are complete meals, & it's good for inspiration.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2025 20:26

You're going to have to add salt. Unsalted soup is never going to taste ok. Nor is soup with soy sauce or worcestershire sauce added.

And a stock cube isn't going to kill you.

There are lots of good soup recipes online.

Find one, and stick to it. Don't ad lib.

If you make your own stock, just add onion, garlic, and carrots (peeled), plus fresh herbs (parsley, rosemary in a bouquet garni). Celery can make stock taste bitter.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2025 20:42

Lentil soup with potatoes:

1 large onion, diced
12 cloves of garlic, finely chopped
5 ribs of celery plus leaves, finely chopped
3 large carrots, peeled, diced roughly
I large baking style potato, peeled, cubed, or about a dozen small new potatoes, washed, halved
2/3 cup puy lentils (or similar)
Water or stock - one litre at least
Cumin
Paprika
Salt
Pepper
Olive oil
Sliced lemon
Fresh cilantro/ coriander
Fresh parsley (about half a coffee mug of fresh herbs)
Stock cube - veg, beef, chicken, whatever

Rinse puy lentils and remove grit and any other stuff that isn't a lentil.
Add onion and sweat it in olive oil.
Add garlic, stir around for a few minutes.
Add carrots, stir for a few minutes.
Add a heaped soup spoon each of cumin and paprika. Stir.
Add water or stock.
Add lentils, stir.
Add celery and potatoes.
Add stock cube.
Liquid should cover the veg and lentils innthe pot by about 2 inches. Add heated water or stock to cover veg/ lentils.
Stir, bring to boil, then simmer covered for about 45 mins. Lentils should be soft. Stir now and then during simmering.
Add S&P to taste.
Add sliced lemon and fresh herbs. Simmer another ten mins.

Serve.

soupyspoon · 19/09/2025 20:51

I think unless it's actually tomato soup then adding tomatoes to soup ruins it. You need lots of fat and seasoning for soup, I've never used a stock cube for soup .

TheLadyIsAVamp · 19/09/2025 20:53

I'm surprised at all the cabbage soup hate! Cabbage roll soup is a regular for me although as it has mince in (mince in soup is another controversial topic 🙈) I guesse it's more of a stew maybe? We love it regardless 😂

Chaosclassic · 19/09/2025 20:55

mindutopia · 19/09/2025 12:42

I’ve never had a soup smell or taste sour the next day. But based on what you’ve described, I think you’re putting too much weird stuff in it. Literally just sauté onions, add garlic, add your veg, add stock powder/water, cook til soft, season with salt and pepper, blend, check for seasoning and season more. I tend to serve every soup with a bit of cream or creme fraiche, possibly some grated cheddar.

Oh and keep it simple. Don’t add every veg in the fridge. Tomatoes, peppers, carrots, or broccoli, courgettes, kale, or carrots and red lentils.

Edited

This. Stop getting creative. Find a veg recipe and stick to it.

SeaToSki · 19/09/2025 20:57

At the end, taste it and add a little salt, then taste, then add a little lemon juice or white wine vinegar, then taste. Repeat and eventually all the other flavours will appear

homeowlly · 19/09/2025 21:00

For any soup leeks help with the flavour and frying them off in some butter. Also if your making any root veg soups roast the veg first before adding to the soup for blending as it intensifies the flavour.

This soup is so basic and so tasty, I also like to add some red onions to it.

Spiced carrot & lentil soup recipe | Good Food

Spiced carrot & lentil soup in a bowl

Spiced carrot & lentil soup

A delicious, spicy blend packed full of iron and low in fat to boot. It's ready in under half an hour, or can be made in a slow cooker

https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/spiced-carrot-lentil-soup

coxesorangepippin · 20/09/2025 02:41

I make great soups, and here's why:

Use plenty of butter (and a couple of tablespoons of oil) to fry the veg in. Perhaps 4 tablespoons of butter.

For the veg, use: 2 onions, 2 carrots, 2 sticks celery, 1/6 of a cabbage, maybe a couple of large cauliflower florets, diced up. Couple of garlic cloves perhaps. Gently fry for ten mins.

Add chicken stock, preferably homemade, about a centimeter above the veg.

Add a big handful of red lentils. Add bay leaves.

Simmer till veg is cooked. Remove bay leaves. Blend.

My main trick with the veg is do not mix red and green veg together to make blended soups. So I'd never do tomato and broccoli, for example. Other than that I'd use a mixture of veggies, but always add at least two onions.

coxesorangepippin · 20/09/2025 02:43

I fins cabbage invaluable in soups, it gives it a such a creamy texture.

sashh · 20/09/2025 04:50

JDM625 · 19/09/2025 11:03

How can I avoid that sour smell that some soups acquire the next day?

The only time I've ever smelt/tasted that was when a soup had been left out of the fridge and gone off! Do you eat meat? I use a smoked ham knuckle/hock to make pea and ham soup. I also add in alot of root veg and its always delicious. No stock cube, no added salt- just the flavour of the veg and smoked meat.

A small amount of smoked bacon can do the same. If its just veg, then roasting them or in the air fryer to get some caramelised bits might add more flavour.

I make this too, and it is always better the next day. I make it in my slow cooker.

Actually I use my slow cooker for other soups. Stem soup is a good one, put the stems of broccoli and cauliflower and the leaves add boiling water salt, pepper and a few dried herbs.

When you are ready use a stick blender to get a smooth soup.

Courgette and coriander (this one I do on the hob). One courgette per person and a bunch of coriander.

Slice the courgette(s) and sweat in a little oil for about 10 mins. Add the coriander and boiling water and a veg stock cube, simmer for 10 mins then blend. It can be eaten hot or cold. I usually add a dollop of crème fraiche or a dribble of cream.

If you have any Indian grocers you can get quite big bunches of coriander, if you wrap in newspaper you can freeze it. When you are ready to add the coriander take it out and crumble it with your hand.

Blingismything · 20/09/2025 09:49

Saute the vegetables in butter for a few minutes before adding the stock.

Poppingby · 20/09/2025 09:57

I love a soup! I never try to make it with cruciferous veg though. I know people do but it always tastes bitter when I try it. My favourite is lentil and butternut squash and it's even better if you roast the squash and just bung it in with veg stock and cooked lentils.

Kallo organic stock cubes are good and perfectly healthy, or I often make my own stock by putting potato/carrot etc peelings in a bag in the freezer and boiling it up with wine and whatever bits of old cheese I might have about.

You do need salt. You can top with seeds and nuts etc too for extra deliciousness.

PaddlingSwan · 23/09/2025 06:10

Really good stock, preferably home-made. If you get caught on the hop, a teaspoonful of Marmite dissolved in 1l of boiling water will solve the issue.
I always use a potato to thicken, but needs to be a floury potato.
Never more than 2 main ingredients, in addition to onion and garlic, if using, or if you are making a minestrone.
Plenty of black pepper, freshly ground. Squeeze of lemon or lime juice at the end to lift the taste.
Favourite soups, leek & potato or curried parsnip & apple.
Never underestimate cold soups such as gazpacho or tarator. I also make chilled fruit soups as a pudding on really hot days, especially when my cherry tree is fruiting.
Turn a substantial suop into a main course by adding chopped meat or sausage, serve with soda bread, butter, cheese anf fruit.

Gastropod · 23/09/2025 06:32

I make pretty good soups, mostly through a lot of past trial and error.
I find that picking a veg “colour” works well as a starting point:
Red soup (peppers, tomatoes, maybe aubergines)
Yellow/orange (carrot, squash, sweet potato)
Green (broccoli, leek, courgette, pea)
Brown (mushroom etc)

I always add plenty of onions - soften first before adding the other veg. Always meat stock (beef or chicken, stock cubes are fine). I always add mascarpone or Philadelphia if I’m going for European flavours or coconut milk/cream if going Asian. Fresh herbs (stems and all) added at the last minute before blending.

Biggest tip is don’t add too much water. You can always thin it out but if you put too much in too soon, it’ll be horrible. I add enough water/stock to make it easy to blend and then add bit by bit after that. Plenty of seasoning too.
I never thicken with flour or use potatoes either. Cream, butter and seasonings are your friends!

Giggorata · 24/09/2025 15:21

This has been been most enlightening.
Thank you all for your recipes and tips.

OP posts:
MedievalNun · 24/09/2025 15:28

PaddlingSwan · 23/09/2025 06:10

Really good stock, preferably home-made. If you get caught on the hop, a teaspoonful of Marmite dissolved in 1l of boiling water will solve the issue.
I always use a potato to thicken, but needs to be a floury potato.
Never more than 2 main ingredients, in addition to onion and garlic, if using, or if you are making a minestrone.
Plenty of black pepper, freshly ground. Squeeze of lemon or lime juice at the end to lift the taste.
Favourite soups, leek & potato or curried parsnip & apple.
Never underestimate cold soups such as gazpacho or tarator. I also make chilled fruit soups as a pudding on really hot days, especially when my cherry tree is fruiting.
Turn a substantial suop into a main course by adding chopped meat or sausage, serve with soda bread, butter, cheese anf fruit.

Edited

Any chance of the recipe for curried parsnip and apple please?

lizziebuck · 24/09/2025 15:29

I add Chinese 5 spice to my bottom-of-the-fridge soup. It lifts boring left over veges wonderfully.