Before this thread started, I had never heard of, let alone eaten or made, a watermelon and feta salad..... I have just made two for lunch!!
I did the Nigella one, and an Ottolenghi one from Plenty - he doesn't use olives, and uses basil instead of parsley & mint. Oh, and no lime juice either, so definitely a simpler recipe.
And I must admit, I preferred Ottolengi's. I enjoyed Nigella's, but found it quite "savoury" (which maybe is the point of a salad?), the olives+feta+herbs+lime all made it a bit heavy - perfectly pleasant on its own, but I'm not sure how well it would complement another dish. The Ottolenghi one was much lighter, fresher and zingy, and I can imagine it going well with e.g. barbecued food. Despite fewer ingredients, it still felt savoury, not like a fruit salad gone wrong, which I was rather nervous about..... I think the basil, red onion, feta and olive oil perfectly balance out the sweetness of the melon
Also made the MNTB rice pudding the other day - as expected, and in agreement with madamecake, it was too sweet for me. But I loved the flavour - I have never put vanilla in rice pudding before, only ever nutmeg, but this has converted me! The cream made it really luxurious. Think maybe the liquid volumes were a bit off though? I did mine in the oven; in the book it says you may need more milk when cooking it this way. But despite me not covering the dish, and not putting enough liquid in in the first place (dish was too small!) , it still had a good consistency, I think if I'd followed the recipe to the letter it would have been very runny