Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Food/recipes

For related content, visit our food content hub.

APPLES or BANANAS for FIRST SOLIDS...?

23 replies

Emjay · 16/09/2003 04:28

Just wondering what type of apples (granny smith, pink lady, red delicious etc)I should use for first solids and how do I prepare/cook them? Also how long do they freeze for?
I've heard you try out introducing puree apples first, then go onto bananas and then carrots and cauliflower etc...is this rubbish???
We've started on rice cereal for past week and my five-month-old milk guzzler has taken well to it (3-4 teaspoons, twice daily) but now I want to introduce some flavour and this first time mum don't know what to do first.

OP posts:
TalkingTree · 16/09/2003 06:22

I don't think it matters whether you give apples or bananas, or carrots first. I have always given mine banana first simply because it is so easy to prepare - choose a nice ripe one (probably riper than you'd like to eat yourself), put about a third of it in a bowl and mash it thoroughly until it is virtually runny. It is rather slimy, which helps it slide down easily! But beware, any clothes it gets on get stained black, so use a really ample bib (or have your baby naked if its warm enough!)

As for apples, choose any sweetish ones - pink lady are very sweet, and I just cooked up some braeburn which didn't strike me as sweet, but the resulting mush was very sweet. Just don't use cooking apples!

I peel and core the apples and then steam them, but they can be boiled, too. To begin with they need to be cooked lots, until they are very soft, but after a couple of months they can be cooked less (cooking destroys some of the goodness). I mash them with a hand held blender, but they could also be passed through a sieve. I use the steamer and the blender for most veg - carrots, cauliflower, broccoli etc.

Some things can be baked, which preserves more goodness - butternut squash, sweet potato, regular potato. After baking for an hour or so, they get mashed with the blender, or get put through a mouli (my new baby food toy!).

As for freezing, they last a few months in the freezer (depending on the freezer) by which time your baby will be eating different foods and consistancies. I always freeze it in ice cube trays.

I find it rewarding and easy making all my babies' foods. My older two (4.5 and 2.5) are big eaters who like most foods, and it is probably luck, but I like to think it is partly to do with having eaten lots of different foods from a young age. When you prepare food at home the consistancy varies from batch to batch, so they get used to that, too, which helps when starting on more lumpy food later.

Hope this helps!

robinw · 16/09/2003 06:39

message withdrawn

pupuce · 16/09/2003 07:14

It's the season for pears.... cooked pears are loved by babies and easy to digest

Banana are very easy but much harder to digest

Ghosty · 16/09/2003 07:30

I did carrots for first food. I think I read somewhere to start with vegetables otherwise the baby will only like sweet things ... but I don't know how true that is ... my ds still prefers sweet stuff!
I think we started with carrots, moved on to sweet potato and then went on to pears.
DS never did like mashed potato as a small baby and still doesn't like it although he loves boiled potatoes.
I steamed all of DS first foods rather than boil ... no real reason ... just did.
I used a hand blender ... to puree everything but I do think I pureed for too long as it took ages for DS to like lumpy food!
Oh what fun ... I loved this bit of babyhood!

doormat · 16/09/2003 09:04

I dont know whether anyone has posted this but introduce apples, bananas ,carrots etc purreed and mix it in the baby rice or even rusks just to give it a different taste.Then gradually add more and more until baby rice disappears.
This is making me all broody.

prufrock · 16/09/2003 09:32

Not bananas - they are very difficult for babies to digest. And apples can be a little acidic for tiny tummys. If you want a "how to" book on weaning, Gina Ford is very good - gives exact amounts and order to introduce things. If you don't like being told what to do in such detail just try lots of different fruits/veggies. Make up big batches, steam them then puree, and freeze in ice cube trays. Then when you want to be more adventourous you can mix cubes of different flavours

Welshmum · 16/09/2003 09:35

I vote for pears. Mine loved those. Sweet potato also went down very well. Annabel Karmel guided me through all the weaning stuff - I was clueless.

lucy123 · 16/09/2003 10:07

I vote carrots too. I think apples are too acidic, but dd also found pears a little on the acidic side.

maomao · 16/09/2003 11:05

I just started this 2 weeks ago, and my DD has a sweet tooth---she loves the pears! And they make a fine mushy consistency. As for cooking: I chop the fruit or veg into reasonably smallish pieces, plunk them in a microwaveable container with a little water, put the lid partially on, and cook on high for two minutes or so. Then I mush them w/ a fork. It's actually much easier than I'd thought it would be.

Now if only I could tackle those banana and carrot stains.... any suggestions?

Ghosty · 16/09/2003 11:09

I hope my next baby likes pears ... we have an ENORMOUS pear tree in our garden ... last year we couldn't keep up with them ...

maomao · 16/09/2003 11:48

oooh, Ghostie---send some pears my way, please!!!

Jenie · 16/09/2003 11:50

Mango Puree (sometimes from a tin) sold at Sainsburys - although ds now doesn't like it and I have 2 lrg tins of the stuff gathering dust in a cupboard. Oh well it was his favorite for about 6 months,he ate it at every meal.

nursie · 16/09/2003 12:11

My 5 month old ds is at the same stage. He's had baby rice for a couple of weeks, and loves it. I tried him on pureed carrot, and pureed apple, but it didn't go down too well, in fact it came back up!
Yesterday I tried mixing the pureed carrot with some formula and baby rice, and he loved it.
I second the recommendation for the Annabel Karmel book - Baby and Toddler Cookbook - it has a really useful guide for when to introduce what foods, and some lovely recipes. Very useful for us first time mums!

AussieSim · 16/09/2003 20:40

Another vote for Baby Carrots (@4.5mths before any cereals) - although I didn't cook my own (well I did but he didn't like them as much). Second food was Pumpking with Rice (a Hipp brand). Now @7.5mths, my DS likes all foods equally (except fromage frais - that he likes above all else - not given till 7mths). Good Luck!

littlerach · 16/09/2003 20:55

Bananas also made my dd constipated frequently.
Apples are great, eventually you can add sultanas and cinnamon to them. Sweet potato was popular, and cauli. I tended to use any red apples for dd and still do now. Pears were easy to mash when really ripe, no cooking involved. I used to boil up huge amounts and freeze in icecube trays, then as she got bigger, I'd save yoghurt pots etc, and use these to freeze larger portions in (by which time dd had changed her taste, more than likely!!)

percy · 16/09/2003 21:10

hi emjay
i would start with a vegetable first - either carrot or sweet potato and concentrate on vegetables first. then once introducing an evening feed then have some fruit at this feed - pears are a good place to start as very hypoallergenic and then apples etc.
a really good book which details a good order for weaning and what to avoid until each next stage IYKWIM is Suzannah Olivier's book "what should i feed my baby' - a little strict and coming from a strong nutritional background rather than a sort of annabel carmel type thing, but really informative and clear.

pupuce · 16/09/2003 21:50

Suzannah Olivier is indeed an excellent book - I have recommended it many times

Emjay · 17/09/2003 00:25

THANKS SO MUCH everyone!!
I feel much more confident now. Your advice is wonderful. It's made me keen to start instead of being worried and apprehensive.

OP posts:
throckenholt · 17/09/2003 08:17

all 3 of mine prefer mixed things rather than one flavour on its own. This is contrary to all advice I have seen in books, but they wouldn't eat apple on its own, but loved apple and pear mixed. Same for carrots/potatoes. I also mix in a bit of rice to make it the right consistency.

wobblymum · 18/09/2003 14:15

Just out of interest - generally how long does shop bought food last? I want to get my Bounty weaning pack even though dd is only 3 months old, because I want a while to read everything and get prepared bu obviously I don't want everything going off!!

Melly · 18/09/2003 21:02

Wobblymum, the jars of baby food usually have a very long shelf life, much like tins of soup etc, probably a couple of years, so I wouldn't worry about it going off. Obviously once opened they only keep in the fridge for 48 hours.

Paula71 · 18/09/2003 23:13

Just a tip but although my twin ds' are now 21 months old I still puree some fruit and add it to their morning cereal.

Especially good for porridge or Ready Brek!

wobblymum · 19/09/2003 11:48

Thanks melly!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread