@bumbletub I’m a bit confused by your last post. Could you show me where I said it was “detrimental” to go in Year 7?
What I actually said was that these schools are still selective at 11+, and that joining in Year 7 isn’t a universal “easy route”, which the earlier post seemed to imply. I’ve already quoted Hurst’s admissions policy, so I won’t repeat it, but many schools do set formal entry criteria even for their own Year 7–8 pupils. A Head may well reassure parents that it’s usually smoother internally, but that doesn’t remove the underlying assessed entry process at 11+.
On The Mead, I’m literally just going by their own published leavers’ data:
www.meadschool.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/2019-2023-Data-11-and-Leavers-Copy-4.pdf
The Mead’s 2023 destinations show most pupils going to grammars or local state schools, or smaller local independents (Bethany, KC, Battle Abbey). There aren’t any listed moving to Ardingly, Worth or Sevenoaks. The previous year also notes pupils leaving at Year 7 to join Holmewood because they were aiming for Tonbridge at 13. That’s all I meant when I said Years 7–8 at 3–13 preps serve a purpose... they provide access to the 13+ schools that simply aren’t available from an 11+ school.
Similarly, families choose 3–13 preps because they want the 13+ independent route (Tonbridge, Bede’s, Eastbourne, etc.). None of this is a value judgement. Different school structures support different pathways, and parents naturally prepare according to their preferred destination, and I was offering this as a potential explanation for why Kent Test results may differ between schools, rather than them being "less academic".
On the 11+ point, the 2024 FOI Kent Test data really illustrates why I’m cautious about using raw pass rates as a proxy for “how academic” a school is. Several local primaries come out ahead of The Mead on percentages alone:
The Mead: 15 out of 21 = 71.4%
St Peter’s (TW): 15–20 out of 20 = 75%–100%
Bidborough: 14–19 out of 19 = 74%–100%
Claremont: 38 out of 49 = 77.5%
If we treated these pass rates as the sole indicator of academic strength, we would have to conclude St Peter’s, Bidborough and Claremont are all “more academic” than The Mead which clearly isn’t a fair or complete picture. It just shows how much these numbers are shaped by tutoring, who is entered (and who isn’t), and family priorities, rather than teaching alone.
FOI link for reference:
www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/2019_2024_kent_test_11_data#incoming-2670062
Ultimately, parents choose schools according to their own priorities. For some that’s 11+ and grammars; for others it’s 13+ independents; and for others it’s a more holistic, lower-pressure environment. There isn’t one single “right” model, and the OP is lucky to have several decent options to visit.
But I’ll leave it there, as I think we’re simply approaching this from different angles.