Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Edgbaston High School for Girls and St Georges School - Birmingham

10 replies

milliec · 30/03/2008 14:17

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
CaptainNancy · 10/04/2008 00:59

Depends on your child.

EHSG puts them on the academic treadmill very early. 3 classes per year, so quite large. They mix the forms around each year though- so girls get to mix with all of the others, which I thought was a good idea.
Excellent facilities- kindergarten was fabulous! Purpose built, gorgeous setting. Swimming pool, art theatre etc.
What concerned us was segregating girls at such an early age.

St G's very small- 1 form per year. Very friendly and felt less pressurised- ie there were acceptable alternatives to being highly academic. Children encouraged to develop at their own pace a little more. Kindergarten not so fabulous. Boys :girls ratio about 7:3.

Both are all age schools, so dd could stay throughout her academic career.

Are you thinking of starting her this september?

Go to the open days, and go and see them in school time. Will give you a feel, and give you chance to ask loads of questions. Both places held open days which were very well organised which is always a good thing!

Are you considering having more dcs? That may swing you away from EHSG simply to keep them in the same school if you had a boy next

What are you hoping for secondary? Because lets face it, in Birmingham that is the real issue isn't it?

Alternatives....
Blue Coat- v good for music and drama
Hallfield
Priory School
Norfolk House
Highclare
Ruckleigh
All of which are co-ed.

HTH

TinkerbellesMum · 10/04/2008 01:26

Tink goes to Sunday School in the nursery at EHSG and it's beautiful - sorry to anyone who's LO's go there, it's probably her rearranging their drawerer at the weekend

Sorry, that's probably not much help. Have a look at the open day, I've said I would send her to EHSG if I could afford to because it does seem very nice from what I can see on a Sunday.

nappyaddict · 10/04/2008 07:15

blue coat is nice. EHSG fine for prep school but ime the secondary school produces a load of jumped up, i think i'm better than you, will do anything to get what i want, bitchy, nasty girls as is common with many girls only high schools. (i went to one)

fembear · 10/04/2008 09:28

Blue Coat is fab!!

milliec · 13/04/2008 17:29

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
milliec · 13/04/2008 17:33

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
CaptainNancy · 13/04/2008 21:28

Millie- I wouldn't worry too much about the waiting list, as long as you reserve a place soon. There are bound to be some people who cannot take up their place due to moving for work/business etc. If I read you correctly and you mean Sept 2009, you have a while yet.

IME tutoring children from a young age to pass the 11+ is a waste of time and money.

Those tutored to pass the exam cannot cope at the grammar schools, as they are not actually bright enough to keep up. They become incredibly unhappy, and require tuition through secondary school too. In some cases they are asked to leave.

If you're spending in the region of 6.5k on tuition at a bare minimum (1 hr per week, from age 6, assuming £25 per hour)- why not just save it for fees at an independent school if your child does not get in to the grammar? Of course, tuition for 11+ is still a great deal cheaper than moving into the catchment area of a good secondary school (don't know which part of B'ham you're in). Tuition fees for the whole of Primary however, are not.

That said, many of the independent schools select on performance too (KEHSG and EHSG in particular).
How bright does your daughter seem? (bearing in mind her tender age )

At EHSG we were told that girls who were not performing well enough to be kept on into the secondary department would be informed of that by the end of year 4, so that their parents had time to make alternative arrangements for Y7. I was a little surprised, so pushed further, and was told that some choose to wait until Y6, then leave at a normal transition time, others choose to leave immediately after Y4.

milliec · 13/04/2008 21:47

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
fembear · 14/04/2008 09:30

I would recommend that you look at Blue Coat again- it's a lovely school. They get the academic results but, along the way, they do loads of other stuff. They really do live up to their motto of "Grow in Grace". There are some Yummy Mummies but most parents are normal people.

Can I suggest another plan? How about going to your state Infant school (so your DD makes / keeps local friends) and then think about joining B/C in Y3. As Captain Nancy said, there is a certain amount of movement in all schools around the end of KS1 as teachers/parents recognise that certain DC are not ubergeeks, will not get into selective schools and have to think realistically about alternate plans (ie jump at Y2 before they are pushed, in a panic, at Y6). As these children leave, they open up gaps for newbies; if your DD is up to scratch then she can get in to B/C (or where-ever) on merit through entrance exams.

milliec · 15/04/2008 15:27

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread