Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Pronouns and why they do/don't matter

3 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 12/06/2023 08:29

Has anyone got any good reading material on this. I'm feeling a little behind on the main issues surrounding this.
I think I'm a bit simplistic, if someone asks me my pronouns I will tell them, if they don't then I won't. If someone tells me their pronouns I will use them, if they don't then I will tend to avoid using anything other than you or their name.
I feel like I'm missing the wider picture but I don't want to just believe one side of the argument for/against without understanding in full.

OP posts:
kelsaycobbles · 12/06/2023 08:45

How do you know what your pronouns are ?

If you use sex based pronouns are you happy that the person asking does not mean what is your sex ?

but is instead asking what is your identity/ are you comfortable with your sexed body /do you expect people to treat to according to their assumptions about your gender ?

That last point - do you have anything about yourself that you have in common with all women apart from biology ? How do you think "women" and "men" should be treated differently apart from respect for different biology ?

Given this is in education

Girls when reminded of their sex perform less well than when they are not differentiated from the boys - given that do you think it wise to reinforce messages about gender to children

Beamur · 12/06/2023 09:08

You might find the feminist boards helpful for why some people don't want to use or offer pronouns.
Basically, it's a bit like having to state what religion you are when you don't believe in God.
Pronouns come from a place where you can be any identity you choose and pick a pronoun that fits. All well and good. Except when you insist other people use them, or face negative consequences - then it's looking a lot like coerced speech
Preferred pronouns can also be the thin end of the wedge in terms of affirmation. Whilst many current policies and guidance support this as a good approach, it's not unanimously agreed - experts in pediatric care especially have flagged it up as not a neutral approach. Whilst validation may be appealing and reassuring in the short term, not all identities persist and it can be harder for a person to revert if their identity has become entrenched - especially by peers and society.
Personally I don't have or use preferred pronouns but would respect someone asking me to use theirs.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread