Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Operation Christmas Child - what information has your school given you?

53 replies

exexpat · 13/10/2014 17:39

This is not an attempt to start another debate on the pros and cons of the Operation Christmas Child shoebox scheme - that has been done to death on MN before (see last year's two long threads here and here), and as we now know, Samaritan's Purse, who run the scheme, are trying to get threads deleted and threatening legal action against some Mumsnetters (see current thread here) so I don't want to encourage anyone to get into trouble.

However, in the course of last year's threads, when the head of PR of Samaritan's Purse popped up to engage with some of the criticism, he acknowledged that in the past the information SP had provided to schools had not made clear the evangelical aspects of Operation Christmas Child, which has always been my main objection to the scheme. He therefore wrote a new information leaflet for teachers and parents which went some way towards addressing those criticisms.

It was produced too late to reach many people last year (and was hidden away in an obscure corner of the OCC website, and you needed to register even to read it) but the plan was apparently to circulate it more widely this year. In a DM to me, Brian Bennett (the head of PR) promised: "Next year expect a major revamp and unparalleled transparency - you'll have nothing to talk about!"

The leaflet is indeed now available to download from the website without having to register - it is on this page of their website, entitled "OCC - Parent and Teacher Guide".

What I would really like to know is whether this 'unparalleled transparency' is actually happening in practice. So, my question is:

If your school is still participating in the Operation Christmas Child scheme this year, what information have they given to parents (and indeed teachers) to help them make an informed choice about whether to participate? Have you been given a copy of (or sent a link to) the explanatory leaflet?

OP posts:
edamsavestheday · 03/11/2014 16:22

And Greengrow, Christians are taught that lying is wrong - and Jesus was particularly firm about people who harm children. I think manipulating children falls into that category, don't you?

OCC and Samaritan's Purse have lied to and manipulated children for years. It is one thing to try and convert Muslim children (although still dishonest, why not talk to the adults? Hmm?) but quite another to exploit children in this country and other Western nations to fund the conversion of Muslim children in the developing world.

Honest missionaries who are clear that they are 'spreading the good news' are one thing. OCC and SP are quite another.

edamsavestheday · 03/11/2014 16:24

"Every shoebox gift delivered by Operation Christmas Child is a tangible expression of God’s amazing love. But a shoebox is just the beginning. It also presents an opportunity in nearly 100 countries for our church partners to invite children into a deeper relationship with Jesus Christ through The Greatest Journey. The Greatest Journey consists of 12 engaging Bible lessons that local trained teachers are using to instruct the next generation of believers on how to become devoted followers of Christ and boldly share their faith with others."

From the SP website. Clearly states that shoeboxes are used to convert children.

Pennybe · 11/11/2014 18:25

A little book of Bible stories? www.samaritans-purse.org.uk/what-we-do/operation-christmas-child/the-greatest-gift/

From The Greatest Gift: "Sin is our biggest problem. We all need to be rescued from sin. Sin is when we disobey God. Sin is when we don't live the way we are designed to live. You can see sin all around us......Sin must be punished. The right punishment for sin is death and to be separated from God and everything good forever. This is called Hell.....Can you Believe and Follow Jesus? Anyone who believes him will not die but will have eternal life.......Do you want to be a friend and follower of Jesus. If you do, you can speak to Him right now by praying the prayer below........"

How would vulnerable children receiving shoeboxes feel on reading The Greatest Gift: That they are sinful and God will be punish them unless they become followers of Jesus? No emotional or psychological pressure then?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page