Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

She's asking that question...no, not THAT one...

66 replies

motherinferior · 13/11/2003 08:35

Why is the sky blue?

PLEASE can anyone tell me? I know about sex, dammit. But when it comes to the sky all I can say, vaguely, is 'because there are blue bits in it'. There's more to it than that, isn't there?

OP posts:
WideWebWitch · 13/11/2003 10:47

Haven't looked at hmb's link but we once made a volcano with a papier mache volcano, red paint and bicarb, I think. It's a fairly impressive experiment and well worth doing! Fairymum at which prize to aim for!

Frenchgirl · 13/11/2003 10:57

yes water is blue, at least according to Stephen Fry on QI (v informative programme )

hmb · 13/11/2003 11:02

Same deal WWW, bicarb, red food colour and vinegar, and off she goes. Fun but messy.

For those with a mild obscession for 'modeling' physical science, I can recommend the following for an explanation of plate tectonics.

Get a baking tray and pour a tin of tomato soup into it. Toast some bread and float this of the surface of the soup. The soup is the molten magma and the toast is the solid tectonic plate that floats on top of it. Gently heat the soup. The soup will move (convection) and so the plates will move as well. You might also get bubbles of soup (magma) bubbling up in the edges of the 'plates' explaining why volcanis/eathquake activity tends to be located on the edges of the tectonic plates.

I'm suffereing withdrawal symptoms, I'm off sick today and I am stll driven to explain things.....how sad is that???

motherinferior · 13/11/2003 12:55

I want to go somewhere with a volcano.

But without small people, I suspect.

OP posts:
aloha · 13/11/2003 14:33

I'm quite afraid of volcanoes. I just want to go somewhere with hot weather and a swimming pool and 24 hour nannies...

Tinker · 13/11/2003 14:42

hmb - so glad you can answer all these science questions. I always say we are made of star dust as well cos I just like saying it. Don't we all have atoms that could have been in dinosaurs as well?

Would love to study physics if I could tailor-make the syllabus.

Was absolutely terrified of volcanoes as a child - my dad said that they had them in Ireland, just to tease me (we were going there on holiday)

hmb · 13/11/2003 14:51

Well, the atoms that made up the dianosaurs would have been re-cycled many, many times, so yes!

I love the conservation of matter and energy, nothing can ever be created or destroyed, just changes from one form into another.

And I love the fact that the equations for respiration and photosynthesis are mirror images of each other....good thing for us too!

But I can't answer all the questions you know!

M2T · 13/11/2003 14:52

Doesn't the sky appear to be blue because the composition of gases in our atmosphere filters out certain wavelengths of light?

The sea appears blue in large volumes due to its mineral content and again the wavelength of light that the minerals absorb and reflect?

Dunno how you exlain it to a 2 yr old though!! I'd just tell my ds that it's blue coz it's a nive colour for it to be and explain the science part a few years down the line.

hmb · 13/11/2003 15:01

I found this on the web and thought it might interest

LIGHT IN THE AIR
Light travels through space in a straight line as long as nothing disturbs it. As light moves through the atmosphere, it continues to go straight until it bumps into a bit of dust or a gas molecule. Then what happens to the light depends on its wave length and the size of the thing it hits.

Dust particles and water droplets are much larger than the wavelength of visible light. When light hits these large particles, it gets reflected, or bounced off, in different directions. The different colors of light are all reflected by the particle in the same way. The reflected light appears white because it still contains all of the same colors.

Gas molecules are smaller than the wavelength of visible light. If light bumps into them, it acts differently. When light hits a gas molecule, some of it may get absorbed. After awhile, the molecule radiates (releases, or gives off) the light in a different direction. The color that is radiated is the same color that was absorbed. The different colors of light are affected differently. All of the colors can be absorbed. But the higher frequencies (blues) are absorbed more often than the lower frequencies (reds). This process is called Rayleigh scattering. (It is named after Lord John Rayleigh, an English physicist, who first described it in the 1870's.)

WHY IS THE SKY BLUE?
The blue color of the sky is due to Rayleigh scattering. As light moves through the atmosphere, most of the longer wavelengths pass straight through. Little of the red, orange and yellow light is affected by the air.

However, much of the shorter wavelength light is absorbed by the gas molecules. The absorbed blue light is then radiated in different directions. It gets scattered all around the sky. Whichever direction you look, some of this scattered blue light reaches you. Since you see the blue light from everywhere overhead, the sky looks blue.

motherinferior · 13/11/2003 16:26

OK. I'm sticking to 'blue bits in it' for now, but am going to be WONDERFUL at this question when she's bigger.

OP posts:
Ghosty · 13/11/2003 22:56

Motherinferior ... you can come and see us and our volcano!
No need to be scared of our volcanoes ... they have been dead for thousands of years although Rangitoto Island rose out of the sea 600 years ago ... I think that is the youngest ...
I once camped in the crater of a live volcano ... in Italy - Naples ... not Vesuvius but not far ... one half of the crater was a campsite and the other was on show for visitors to see the bubbling sulphur and steam coming up through the cracks in the rocks ... cool!
Was a bit smelly though ....

sis · 14/11/2003 10:09

I got one from ds this morning that totally stumped me - "how can our little eyes see big things?" - all I could come up with was that eyes were made to be very clever. I know it is pathetic but I did not really know the answer so couldn't do any better. can anyone help me? BTW, ds is five years old.

hmb · 14/11/2003 10:47

Now that is a very good question.

We can see because light passes into our eyes that is reflected from objects (unless the object is giving out light, for example the sun or a lightbulb). Our eyes have a hole in the front, the pupil. The rays of light come into our eye from all the areas in front of us (think of it as a half sphere extending from our eyes forwards). Light will come from the top of an object and pass into our eye, at an angle, downwards. Light will pass into our eye from the bottom of an object, at an angle, upwards (it will help if you draw a stick man, with lines going from it into the eye!). The lens in our eye focuses this on the back of the eye (the retina). The nerves will pass this information to our brain, which then 'reconstructs' this image for us, turning it the right way up.

The eye just records the incidence of light rays entering the eye, it is the brain that 'makes' the picture for us.

To be honest, this is best explained using pictures, have a look at

library.thinkquest.org/26111/howitworks.html

But a very good question!

sis · 14/11/2003 12:10

thanks hmb - if he asks again I will try and give a proper answer instead of fudging but I know it will lead to more questions that I won't be able to answer such as what is refraction (or wefwaction - with his cute inability to pronounce the 'r' sound), so I may be bback with more. Have to say that I am not sure that i can actually answer the 'little eye vs big thing' part of the question other than illustrating how big things get smaller at a distance and can therefore be reflected into the back of the eye. yes, will use reflected instead of refracted, I think.

hmb · 14/11/2003 12:17

Try making a pin hole camera. lightproof box, pin hole at one end, and a transparent back plate (grease proof paper?). He will be able to see the picture. Tell him that the same thing happens in the eye, with the retina taking the place of the screen at the back

www.kodak.com/global/en/consumer/education/lessonPlans/pinholeCamera/

For details on how to do this

sis · 14/11/2003 13:06

great idea, thanks, will do it!

Tinker · 14/11/2003 14:34

What a fantastic question from your little boy sis. Liked that one . My daughter once asked "why do we have necks?". Just said we'd look funny if we didn't!

hmb · 14/11/2003 14:41

I was very fond of 'When God made the world, what did he make it from?'

These questions make you realise how much we just take for granted, as Adults. It takes a kid to ask important questions.

One of my class of year 10s asked me why we blush when we are embarassed about something. Great question, never did find a 100% answer, but we had a good discussion about it.

motherinferior · 15/11/2003 11:49

Well, I am now completely distracted from science by the thought of Ghosty's volcano. This wanderlust is quite uncharacteristic, I have to say. No doubt it's a midlife crisis and I am ready for ten dwarves and a wizard to turn up at my door and take me off on a quest. Mind you with my luck they'd probably take me to a cottage in the woods and make me do housework while they went off every day singing Hi Ho

OP posts:
Beetroot · 15/11/2003 12:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

kmg1 · 15/11/2003 13:31

What an odd question Beetroot! The 'protestant religion' is a very odd phrase. Are they after something historical do you think? The Reformation, Henry VIII, etc.? Do you have any more details as to what the teacher wants?

If they want some sort of details of the current beliefs of non-Roman Catholic, Christian religions it's quite tricky, as there is such a wide variety.

Beetroot · 15/11/2003 14:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

popsycal · 15/11/2003 14:59

is it to do with the tudors topic....
i may be able to help you.....teach tudors...to primary kids...

Beetroot · 15/11/2003 15:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

popsycal · 15/11/2003 15:06

oooh thats the stuarts then...tudors up to 1685!
didnt think the stuarts was on the key stage two curriculum any more!
if he needs to know about religion around that time - may not be totally accurate as it is the stuarts - i could help a bit
what does he need to know!?
just checking out some websites that i use with kids for you too....

Swipe left for the next trending thread