A happy SL parent here. Slightly perturbed to see such negative comments about what's considered by many as one of the best schools in the area, with a recent outstanding OFSTED, and a huge waiting list for next year's reception year. If it, and indeed the Head was that bad surely the parents would vote with their feet, no?
Go along and judge for yourself, give Mrs Hope a chance. She knows every child, and understands how they tick. Yes, she may not be able to tell every parent with real conviction which future school will suit their 4 year old child in 2 years times, but her actions are dictated by Shrewsbury House's guaranteed place scheme. As you go through year 1 she is far better placed to make an informed recommendation and indeed does so.
Fiona - I'm glad you (and your sons!) loved the school, and if you're after a well balanced educational experience, and not high octane academics then SL is a great school. I have no doubt that my son will be able to get into any of the schools we select for him, and he is being well-prepared for success, and in the meantime he's enjoying some great facilities and activities all wrapped up in a nurturing environment.
Every school isn't for every family, or child, and when you're lucky enough to be able to choose where to educate your child, maybe that choice should be exercised.