Best Amazon Prime Day deals: Mumsnet favourites

Best Amazon Prime Day deals:
Mumsnet favourites

Shop now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Help please! What's the difference between a similie and a metaphor?

19 replies

Carla · 14/09/2005 16:52

Dear friend's round, and we don't know! Could you define it in a 13 year old's understanding?

TIA.

OP posts:
Bethron · 14/09/2005 16:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Bethron · 14/09/2005 16:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ja9 · 14/09/2005 16:56

a simile usually contains 'like' or 'as', eg he ran like the wind, or he was as fast as the wind. a metaphor is more difficult to use and more difficult to explain imo.... it would (in this example) make the boy sound as if he was the wind iyswim...

ja9 · 14/09/2005 16:56

oh, too late!

Celia2 · 14/09/2005 16:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

trefusis · 14/09/2005 16:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Celia2 · 14/09/2005 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Carla · 14/09/2005 20:28

Oh, eff, I know I'm completely thick ....

But how is a bear with a sore head different from children who are monsters?

A bear may have a sore head, but our children aren't monsters. ??????

OP posts:
Cam · 14/09/2005 20:57

Carla, because the children aren't monsters!

Carla · 14/09/2005 21:36

Doh! > but how do you know the bear has a sore head????

OP posts:
beansprout · 14/09/2005 21:40

Because it is taking paracetemol?

Carla · 14/09/2005 21:42

I know I'm missing the point, but I still don't understand.

Glad I left school when I did .... but would still be grateful for all other explanations. Blimey, if I can't grasp it ......

OP posts:
Carla · 14/09/2005 21:43

LOL beansprout!!!

OP posts:
Medea · 14/09/2005 21:46

Carla, I have no idea how you know if a bear has a sore head. I think I'd have to be filled in on more the details of this assignment. (Is it a school assignment?)

But to make you (or the 13-year-old) feel better. . .I'm in my mid 30's and still getting them mixed up. I was at a dinner with a bunch of poets a couple of years ago and I complimented one of them on the rapid-fire metaphors in a poem he read us. . .But a know-it-all & highly competitive woman in the group arched her eyebrows and said, "I believe you mean SIMILES!" (No irony whatever.) FGS.

beansprout · 14/09/2005 21:47

So what is an analogy then?

Medea · 14/09/2005 21:48

Oh, I see, you were referring to Trefussis's simile/metaphor pair.

The bear having a sore head is beside the point. The reason it's a simile is because Trefussis used the word "like." I am LIKE a bear with a sore head.

There is no use of the word "like" or "as" in her second example, a METAPHOR. My children ARE monsters. Note she didn't say My children are LIKE monsters. If she had, that would have been a simile and not a metaphor.

Similes use "like" or "as." Metaphors do not. Simple.

Carla · 14/09/2005 21:49

Cam, I think what I meant to say is that I don't know any bears, and I especially wouldn't know if they had a sore head.

Now, my children are monsters, sometimes, but not literally. But who meets a bear with a sore head in Sainsbury's? ... Is it the literal thing? God, I'm losing my brain .... or even my brians ...... but I still don't understand the difference

OP posts:
Carla · 14/09/2005 21:51

Medea, x posts. Thank you!! I think I've got it now!

OP posts:
Cam · 15/09/2005 08:54

Yes, Medea's wonderfully clear explanation hits the spot

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread