Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

Contact arrangements when ex lives 200 miles away.

3 replies

GeekyGirl42 · 27/10/2019 11:47

When our daughter was 7, we were all living in Bedfordshire, and had done for 5 years. It's in a rural area, terrible for software jobs (my profession) and caught in the middle of a transition from a 3-tier education system to the 2-tier (primary and secondary) that the rest of the country uses.

That year, her father left, moving to Manchester. Now she's 11, and up until now, contact arrangements have been working very smoothly, with him staying at his parents, who still live 5 minutes away, and running his contact from there every other weekend, working from home at their house on the Friday.

He seems recently to have become dissatisfied with this arrangement (has recently set up home with his girlfriend in Manchester). He wanted share of the house equity, so the family home is being sold, and I'm moving 40 minutes away from his parents house so our daughter can go to a stable secondary school (and there are several excellent options), and I'll have a ten minute commute so she gets more from me in the week. She's delighted with this plan.

He is now saying this is unreasonable, because it makes it harder to see his daughter. I understand that and have offered to collect her from him somewhere more convenient for his journey back to Manchester on the Sunday, but Friday arrangements are harder because he's not happy about waiting for me to finish work and drop her off, so he'll have to collect her.

His answer to this (and by the way, I think there is more to this than my move - I think he's fed up with coming down from Manchester) is to expect our 11 year old daughter to take a train from Cambridge to Manchester on her own, arriving in Manchester at 10pm on a Friday evening. I've put my foot down and said that is not happening, but I can work on a plan to get her prepared for that when she's older - at least 14.

He's now saying that this means he might not be able to carry on seeing her so regularly. Am I being unreasonable? I have suggested, so many times, that I look at moving to the Manchester area, but that I would only do that if he perhaps saw more of her and went to parents evenings. He said he didn't want that and his girlfriend wouldn't like it, so I'm not going to do that.

OP posts:
SuperMeerkat · 28/10/2019 10:21

YANBU. You’re not stopping him seeing his daughter, he’s just being stubborn. It’s not as though you’re moving to Mars and even then I hear there’s soon to be a Mars mission so he’d still be able to get there 😉

Nighowl · 28/10/2019 20:37

Sounds like my Dad. Similar distance but he would only have me to stay in the summer hols and at Christmas for a week each time then when I was around 11 had an argument with my mum About which day to bring me back.... he wanted to bring me back after school had re started, my mum said no so he said not at all then. Never saw or heard from him again until I was 28! That didn’t last long either. In my opinion, if he loves her and wants to see her, he will make it happen. Sadly for your daughter that doesnt sound like the case. How could he even suggest she make that journey by her self at night!

poloarpanda123 · 28/10/2019 21:41

I am in a similar situation. Separated 4 years now and 3 children live with me. It's at the point now he hardly sees them. I've offered to take them whenever but recently he is not interested.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page