Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

He left me and I don’t really understand why

15 replies

OmegaAlpha · 01/10/2018 00:12

Sorry for long thread. Also reposted with name change. My ex DP left me very suddenly 18 months ago. We had been arguing a lot, I had made threats and ultimatums that I now regret, that he took me up on. After several days rowing with us each staying away different nights I woke up one sat morn with our 7yr old DD and 2yr old DS to an email saying that something in him had snapped and he needed some time apart to think. I was devastated, felt guilty and responsible for my part in the situation and tried to contact him to talk to him but he wouldn’t speak to me. I was left to manage the two children alone while my world was falling apart. I tracked him down at work (he runs his own business) on Sunday and he said he would meet me in the pub the next night to talk. We met for 45mins y. during which he told me how awful I had been, constantly criticising him and making his life hell. I cried and told him how sorry I was and begged for him to come home. He then left to stay I don’t know where. Friends came and helped hold me together while I tried to look after our children. My DD was especially upset, she was as shocked and as devastated as I was. (I had told her he was away working but eventually had to tell her that daddy was staying away for a little while because we hadn’t been getting on). It was awful. I tried not to contact him in the hope he would come back but sent one email again grovelling and begging for him to come home. Two weeks later I got an email at work saying he had got himself a flat and wanted the children to come and stay with him as soon as possible. I said we had to talk first, and persuaded him to come to two sessions of therapy where he said categorically he didn’t want to try, that his feelings for me had gone. We had been together 9 years, I knew things had been bad in recent months but put it down to no sleep (our 2yr old had never slept through the night, we were both exhausted, and both have ad v stressful jobs. The strange thing is he had always told me he loved me, the week before he had bought me a £3k diamond ring (I had been nagging him to get married, and I suppose he felt he should, but why spend £3k if he didn’t love me?) and had talked of our retirement together, etc). We had a connection above and beyond our children, ‘got’ each other, were attracted to each other (we had sex the week before we left) and made each other laugh, when we got the chance to have fun, which I admit wasn’t so often. Now, 18 months on, he is living in a flat a mile away, working all the hours he can, putting cash in the account, doing his share of childcare, sharing pics of kids, it’s all v civil (we both want to put childrn first so ensure that it is always civil). There is no other woman. I know because his family, mutual friends, etc tell me so. I just don’t understand why he would leave everything we built together to live a lonely life, be a part-time Dad, pay out maintenance etc. It makes no sense to me. Was I really so awful? I’m not proud of how I behaved but I was just exhausted, stressed and unhappy. I miss him still, despite everything, and miss our family. So do my children. My DD said she didn’t understand, because we ‘loved each other so much’. I believe we did. I just don’t understand why he left. Any help or insight appreciated.

OP posts:
Justgivemeasoddingname · 01/10/2018 00:27

Could it be that he just doesn't love you? With whichbthete is nothing wrong....it doesn't mean he dislikes you.
I thought re the £3k ring....maybe just to please you as you had nagged him so much? Itsxrsther a shame it has come to that but that's how I read it.
Sorry you're finding it so hard OP but it sounds like the two of you are doing a great job of being amicable for the kids sake.

Ningnang2000 · 01/10/2018 00:29

So sorry. No insight to offer. Has he been to see a doctor? Sounds like a bit of a breakdown? Is he depressed?

Oddcat · 01/10/2018 00:32

What were the arguments about Op ? Sorry you're having a hard time .

OmegaAlpha · 01/10/2018 09:39

Thanks for the messages. The arguments were mainly about (from my POV) how much he worked (he is a workaholic, runs own company and often would leave at 5am, come back in middle of night, work weekends at drop of hat, go away for weeks, which I wouldn’t have minded if I had got some time back as a break. I think you’re right justgive, he did stop loving me, it’s just sad he kept telling me the opposite. The week before he left we were in Brighton visiting his sister (I thought we had a great time) and he pointed at an elderly couple holding hands and said ‘that will be us in a few years’. It’s just v confusing. A bit of background is he had a difficult childhood, his mother left when he was small and he was brought up by workaholic Dad and stepmum, who he said was abusive but who his dad is still with. So my counsellor says maybe the birth of our son triggered something in him. I just wish I had treated him better when we were together. I just felt resentful because of his work, and mine being sidelined. Oh well, I suppose you learn from your mistakes and move on. It just feels like a tragedy (for our children esp) that didn’t need to happen.

OP posts:
Scrumptiousbears · 01/10/2018 09:46

A few days before I broke it off with a long term .org we i was also telling him I loved him. Mainly because it tripped of the tongue and it's what we said. It was just the norm. I would look to much into that part.

Sometimes things build up and something snaps. Maybe that last argument was the final straw.

OmegaAlpha · 01/10/2018 10:13

Yes you’re right. I am shocked that he would just leave the way he did. It was so sudden and so shocking for us all. If only he had told me how he was feeling. Or given us another chance. When he first told me how he felt, even though it was awful, I was pleased he was being honest at last, as it always felt as if he was holding something back. I thought now we have the chance to sort stuff out. But instead it was too late. Thanks for your answers. It makes me feel sure I have to just move on. We both made mistakes and while I would do anything to try and resolve things, for him it’s too late. Which means it is for me too, I suppose

OP posts:
elliemillie · 03/10/2018 06:04

Sorry you are having a hard time OP but you need to move on. I know its hard.

My STBXH could have written your post. We were arguing all the time. Everything was my fault etc etc. One morning in the middle of an argument he said he wanted a divorce so I agreed. He didnt mean it. He has come back several times confused I agreed. I told him I loved him the night before. I was planning time away from the kids for just us two etc. But something in me broke. I didnt want to live that way anymore.

Its hard on my own somedays with three kids. I still love DH but I am not going back. I am happier without him living here. I used to dread coming home. Now without him here home is pleasant. A refuge from the horrible world. Not a war zone. I won't give that up.

Relationships need care. Sometimes the two people in it, beat it down till there is nothing left of it. You will both find someone else. Hopefully you wont argue much and you will have learned from this how to build a relationship not tear it down. Sometimes we have to lose things to see their value

Blackoutblinds · 03/10/2018 06:09

I’m sorry but you do know why he left. You were rowing all the time, and he just doesn’t love you any more.

My ex and I rowed all the time. I made a lot of threats and ultimatums too. Which we never followed up on. Until one day I looked at him after we had had another row (about how much he worked and how disengaged he was) and I just thought I don’t love you any more and I don’t want to be with you.

We had sex the weekend before. I’d told him I loved him the day before I think. I used to say it just because it was what we said. Bye. Have a good day. Love you.

But I just didn’t any more. It was literally like a switch went in my head.

Sorry you’re struggling xx

Blackoutblinds · 03/10/2018 06:11

Sometimes two people just bring out the worst in each other.

I’ve dated since and never had the level of row or angst. And I’ve a boyfriend now and I have never ever laughed as much as since I’ve been with him. And I realise how supportive he is and how much he CARES about ME and me about him in a way my ex didn’t and I didn’t about him.

Rednaxela · 03/10/2018 06:16

Being married isn't a licence to verbally abuse someone for months on end.

It is tragic he didn't communicate earlier how badly he felt treated, as evidently you didn't realise how bad it was from his perspective.

hatemeIhatemyself · 03/10/2018 06:24

Days before I left my husband we bought me a £700 eternity ring... I never wanted it at that point it was just he kept pushing and how can you say no without simply saying I don't love you?

I also told him I loved him even after i left because he used to say it and I just couldn't deal with not placating him and saying it back.

It sounds like he just grew apart from you, that's not to say he doesn't still love you etc but you only have one life and so there is no point in staying where you are unhappy growing more resentful of the other person.

I'm sorry it's do hard though OP ❤️

LusaCole · 03/10/2018 06:41

I agree with other posters. My ex boyfriend and I argued a lot - nearly every day. I just couldn’t go on living like that. DH and I hardly ever argue - it’s much calmer.

OP, I hope you can move on and find peace Flowers

MaybeDoctor · 03/10/2018 07:12

I think the problem is that as soon as you set an ultimatum, you open up the possibility that the other person will say no.

I have recently been on the receiving end of an ultimatum and it is a horrible feeling. It did affect my view of the other person.

SandyY2K · 03/10/2018 08:31

Once you move on and start dating, he may surprisingly become jealous.

I don't see why he's splash out on a ring like that either tbh...knowing how he felt.

Perhaps something inside did just snap. Constant arguments are horrible.

I'd move on and get an active social life.

OmegaAlpha · 04/10/2018 00:33

Thank you everyone. It’s helpful to see your answers even though it’s painful. I realise that I acted the way I did because he had disengaged so much, that I was just trying to get through to him. I don’t think I was abusive, just upset a lot. It is tragic but hopefully we can be good parents apart. I am mostly sad for our children, and our family life. We did laugh a lot when we got the chance. That’s how we got together in the first place - I had never met someone who made me laugh so much, and vice versa. But even if I don’t ever meet someone else (and I’m nearly 50 with two young children so not sure if I want to) I am glad that we met and made our children, and I have them. I was lucky, if careless with what I had.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page