PadDad, this is where the nerd bit comes in.
I am happy to admit that I am a card carrying member of the RedSox Nation and that I own all of these books and when I'm feeling nostalgic or usually around this time of the year with the start of the baseball season about a month or so away....I get them out and leaf through them.
Faithful I found relatively difficult, for the reasons that you suggest - even as a diehard Sox fan, I found a day by day diary account of the season "too much". Certainly compared to all of Shaughnessy's books it was quite difficult, very much a dip into type book, once you "understand" more.
Yes, you are quite right, certain people are sniffy about Dan's writing and some of it can seem a bit twee at times, but to be honest, an awful lot of it tells it like it is.
Don't know if you have had the chance to live in the States, if you have, you'll know just how ingrained baseball is in their lives... everyone, not just males, not just sporty males...it really is part of the social fabric and with the 86 year drought (or "Curse" if you prefer), it really WAS a huge thing for New England when they DIDN'T blow it this time. (Reversing...)
I was in Shea Stadium on the night of Game 6 of the World Series in 1986... like many others I still don't understand why MacNamara left Bill Buckner out there....
(Sorry, you haven't read "One Strike Away" yet, you absolutely must, at least the first and last chapters....)
At Fenway is a book of good stories, it's a Sox book, but I'm sure similar stories could be written about other teams, it's a good collection of stories.
Peter Gammons book is quite a good read and for me, as a newbie in 1986, gave a bit of an insight into what had gone before and why 1986 was such a big deal.
I have read one or two others, particularly with regard to 67, if I can think of them, I'll drop you a note.
But... you've got plenty to be going on with.
Cheers