Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Cycling

Join the cycle chat on our Cycling forum.

Cycling with baby - seat or trailer?

16 replies

INeedNewShoes · 07/01/2018 11:51

I wonder if anyone can advise me on this?

DD is currently 8 months old so maybe a little young yet, but once she's big enough, there are two things I want to be able to cycle with her for:

  1. The mile long trip to the childminder's house which means 20 minutes each way twice a day for me taking her and picking her up, so an hour and 20 minutes traveling a day! There is a cycle path for the vast majority of this so we would only be mixing with traffic in our estate.

  2. For fun bike rides out, where we would go in the car to somewhere with traffic-free cycling like paths on disused railways etc.

Any thoughts?

I have two bikes to choose from for this, one is a Giant Hybrid bike that I've ridden loads (including doing things like the C2C on it) and the other a bit of a heap of junk, but possibly better for the task is a Dawes Duchess sit up and beg.

OP posts:
noodlmcdoodl · 08/01/2018 22:33

I only have a trailer - burley solo. It's awesome! I picked it over a seat because it gives my son more protection from the elements. He can also have stuff in it to entertain him, snacks and a drink, so it seemed more suitable for the longer rides we wanted to do with him.

I picked the model I chose because of its weight (obviously the lighter the better), ease to pack flat/ store and internal space (it has bowed out sides so gives more shoulder space for an older child and has good storage space behind the seat).

He's been in it since 5 months - i have an additional attachment called a 'snuggler' which turns the seat into more of a hammock. All rides have been over 90 minutes in length. He absolutely loves it (he's now 12 months).

The trailer has handled well off road (rough gravelly cycle paths, canal towpaths and disused railway lines) and it's never tipped... despite inadvertently being cornered on one wheel. It also handles very well on the road.

The hitch is very simple to use (uses the quick release).

We've towed using a carbon cyclo cross bike, touring bike and our race bikes. Race bikes aren't ideal because of the gearing. You'd just use what you are comfy on (the hybrid?). It's best to go for the lightest bike you have as it'll make towing a bit less tiring. It's also worth going for the one with the lowest gears (unless you live somewhere super flat).

If I was doing the regular short commuter trips you plan to do I'd probably look at a seat for that... and keep the trailer for the longer rides. My reasoning there would be that the seat would be attached to my bike and ready to go, whereas I'd have to unfold the trailer and hitch it.

There's a great site called two wheeling tots, they have a Facebook group too. I found both really good sources of advice - there's a lot of scaremongering online about taking babies cycling.

noodlmcdoodl · 08/01/2018 22:40

www.twowheelingtots.com/

LivininaBox · 08/01/2018 22:50

I've used both and would recommend a seat. Trailers are fun but they are so vulnerable on the road. A reversing car cant see your trailer.

SunnyL · 08/01/2018 22:53

I use my seat for getting my girl to nursery but the challenge is all her bags of stuff and mine. The bike seat means I can't put panniers on the back so I've got a little old lady basket for the front to put our bags in.

I also have a trailer but that's mostly just for off road bike rides on the weekend. It makes me nervous using it on the road because she's so far away - I'm a very experienced cyclist I just don't trust other drivers

CyclingFanGirl · 08/01/2018 23:03

We have a Burley honey bee, used daily for nursery commutes, on and off road, and heavily used on holidays too. Daughter loves it, warmer and drier than the seat. My husband also found that it affected bike handling less, especially on hills where the weight on the back with the seat could cause the front wheel to lift. The other advantage of the trailer is that it doubles as a buggy and had space for luggage such as a balance bike. See if you can find a local bike hire place where you can try the options out, it's a really personal decision and I don't think one option is inherently better than the other.

INeedNewShoes · 09/01/2018 00:05

Thank you so much for your responses.

It hadn't occurred to me to hire kit to try it out which sounds like a brilliant idea.

I agree that it probably makes sense for me to have a seat for the short cycle to the childminder and a trailer for the fun rides.

Burley obviously comes highly recommended so I'll have a look at those!

If any of you happen to be in the Chilterns area I'd love a chat about where you go for rides. I'm wary of the roads around here as there is such a lot of traffic on them.

An additional question I need to tackle is transporting my bike and the trailer in/on the car. Before DD was born I could fit my bike in the back of my Honda Jazz with just one of the back seats folded down but this seems a bit risky with DD in the back. I'm only 5ft 4 so can't imagine getting my bike onto roof bars!

OP posts:
SunnyL · 09/01/2018 10:50

Have you got a towbar? We got a towbar bike rack which is seriously quick to fit and takes minutes to lift my bike onto it. Previously I had one of those cheapy jobs from Halfords which involved a lot of swearing to fit and then lift my bike onto (I'm 5ft 5 so similar to you). The bike trailer I've got folds flat and can go in the boot easily.

GemmaB78 · 09/01/2018 10:53

I've come off my bike 4 times this week (strong crosswinds and ice). Each time I've had the trailer attached and it's remained upright. Had I been using the seat that is on my husband's bike, I don't know what would have happened.....

CyclingFanGirl · 09/01/2018 17:09

Trailer folds flat to about the size of a large pram, the bikes go on a towbar mounted bike rack which is ridiculously easy to use. Not close to the Chilterns I'm afraid.
I agree, a big upside of the trailer is it stays upright even if you don't.

NorthernLurker · 09/01/2018 17:23

In most accidents Trailers are likely to be safer than seats because less far for the child to fall, greater stability, protection from the frame etc. They still need to wear a helmet. If a car actually drives in to you then you're going to be in trouble whether it's a seat or a trailer. That said I used a seat for years without issue for a short trip as you describe.

GreyCloudsToday · 09/01/2018 17:28

I can recommend Yepp seats which we have enjoyed using and seem both comfortable and indestructible! I switched from a hybrid to a Dutch style bike, which I much prefer when cycling with the seat on.

notdaddycool · 10/06/2018 09:06

Very late to this but if you get a yelpp mini which is a front seat you can also get a windscreen!

helmettoday · 12/08/2018 20:17

I think the seat is perfect for biking. If you think about fun and safety, the tailor is best. helmettoday.com/best-todller-bike-helmet/

BenRiddle · 15/04/2020 15:48

great post. check my new blog post gearbikesreview.com/best-bmx-bikes/

EasterBuns · 31/05/2020 20:58

I was a decent cyclist before I had children but after a few years off tried cycling with a child seat. Absolute disaster as it makes the bike much more difficult to balance. I would only recommend it to really fit, strong avid cyclists. If you get a trailer put a colourful flag on top so cars can see it in their rear view mirror.

ColinKint · 12/12/2020 08:39

Hi there, I check your blogs regularly. Your humoristic style is awesome, keep doing what you're doing! Here is my new blog post scooterlay.com/how-to-barspin-on-a-scooter/

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread