But there have been perfectly sane and reasonable alternative suggestions. Why does it have to be this crackpot idea or zero? Let Employers pay their wages and reclaim it back. For Self employed let them make a declaration in the same way as the grant.
Well, exactly. But now every time someone suggests that very necessary step, someone can pop up with an idiotic strawman "but if you give £500 to people they will be queuing round the block of the testing centre on the off-chance/licking each other in the street", and it shuts down the debate.
I find it disturbing that this government spend more time defending their bad decisions than fixing them, when as you point out, there are clear and obvious ways to fix the problem.