Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

UAE plans to bankroll first ‘planned community’ in south Gaza

213 replies

Twiglets1 · 24/01/2026 06:00

Guardian Exclusive: Blueprints describe a ‘case study’ community where residents submit biometric data to gain entry:

The United Arab Emirates plans to fund “Gaza’s first planned community” on the ruined outskirts of Rafah. Palestinian residents there will have access to basic services like education, healthcare and running water, as long as they submit to biometric data collection and security vetting, according to planning documents and people familiar with the latest round of talks at the US-led Civil Military Coordination Center in Israel.

The planned city would mark the UAE’s first investment in a postwar reconstruction project located in the part of Gaza currently held by Israel. The wealthy Gulf state has contributed more than $1.8bn of humanitarian assistance to Gaza since 7 October 2023, according to UAE state media, making it Gaza’s largest humanitarian donor.

Blueprints for the Emirati-backed endeavor are laid out in an unclassified slide deck obtained by the Guardian and first reported by Dropsite, but the UAE’s role as its planned financier has not previously been reported. The presentation was prepared for a cohort of European donors who visited the CMCC on 14 January, according to an aid official who shared details about the briefing on the condition of anonymity. Israeli military planners have given the plans their stamp of approval.

The United Arab Emirates did not comment on its decision to endorse the Board of Peace, or its plans to fund one of the first US- and Israeli-backed reconstruction projects in Gaza.

One US official said that the first Emirati-backed compound could “become a model” for a string of residential camps that US and Israeli officials have described as “alternative safe communities”.

Within the first Rafah community, billed as a “case study”, planners envision several efforts to prevent the influence of Hamas, including the introduction of electronic shekel wallets “to mitigate the diversion of goods and funds to the Hamas financial channels”, and a school curriculum that will “not be Hamas-based”, but supplied by the UAE. Planners also specify that residents will be permitted to “enter and exit the neighborhood freely, subject to security checks to prevent the introduction of weapons and hostile elements”.

A White House spokesperson said that the Emirati-backed compound would be built during the board’s initial reconstruction push.

Land-clearing efforts for the Rafah site are already under way, an Israel Defense Forces spokesperson told the Guardian.

“Israel’s mission on the east side of the yellow line is to clear the infrastructure in that territory, including tunnels, booby-trapped houses – all of the infrastructure left on our side,” the IDF spokesperson said.

They also said that Israel would not participate in building or running the Emirati compound. “When construction begins, that’s when the ISF participates with boots on the ground.”

A project timeline obtained by the Guardian indicates that site planning began with a “land deed” review in late October and will entail at least four to six months of preparations before construction begins.

www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jan/23/uae-funds-gaza-community

OP posts:
Carla786 · 26/01/2026 19:43

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 18:09

If you haven’t read Avi’s book, you should. He explains how his family, a prominent Iraqi family, had to leave Iraq and why. It basically finished his father who was a respected businessman in Baghdad. It is very sad but he doesn’t lay the blame purely on Pan Arabism. It was far more complicated than that.

I read Samantha Ellis' Iraqi Jewish memoir Chopping Onions On My Heart recently. It was extremely good - she did mention something which made me think Shlaim's account may not be wholly reliable.

Part of the conflict was triggered by a claim that a bomb had exploded in a cafe. Iraqi Jews were wrongly blamed for this. Shlaim recently claimed this bomb was set off by Zionists who wanted to trigger an Iraqi Jewish aliyah. Now, that is possible : extreme groups like Lehi did do some awful things : that, though? Shlaim's basis was a claim from an admittedly unreliable older relative and an Iraqi document, which would have obvious reasons to blame Zionists. Even if Zionists did set the bomb, there was already anti Semitism and that is obviously no excuse

dairydebris · 26/01/2026 19:49

Anyahyacinth · 26/01/2026 17:00

Are you oblivious that they are fighting for self determination ...they don't have choices and are crushed by oppression

Come on. Killing Jews has always been the priority over self determination.
You think Hamas planned October 7th to achieve self determination? You think bombing buses is about self determination? You think running over elderly folk and stabbing teenagers is about self determination? You think spending millions of dollars of aid on tunnels and rockets is about self determination? You think the refusal of Palestinian leadership to declare a state back in 1948 and instead attempt a war of annihilation against the Jews was about self determination?
A lot of wilful looking away on here.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 20:11

dairydebris · 26/01/2026 19:49

Come on. Killing Jews has always been the priority over self determination.
You think Hamas planned October 7th to achieve self determination? You think bombing buses is about self determination? You think running over elderly folk and stabbing teenagers is about self determination? You think spending millions of dollars of aid on tunnels and rockets is about self determination? You think the refusal of Palestinian leadership to declare a state back in 1948 and instead attempt a war of annihilation against the Jews was about self determination?
A lot of wilful looking away on here.

I honestly wondered if that post was being sarcastic...but maybe not! Terrorism is obviously never excused by self-determination.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 20:33

dairydebris · 26/01/2026 19:49

Come on. Killing Jews has always been the priority over self determination.
You think Hamas planned October 7th to achieve self determination? You think bombing buses is about self determination? You think running over elderly folk and stabbing teenagers is about self determination? You think spending millions of dollars of aid on tunnels and rockets is about self determination? You think the refusal of Palestinian leadership to declare a state back in 1948 and instead attempt a war of annihilation against the Jews was about self determination?
A lot of wilful looking away on here.

How many did the Irgun, Lehi and even Haganah kill/murder in the name of self determination or was that different?

Ihatetomatoes · 26/01/2026 20:59

GeneralPeter · 26/01/2026 14:58

@RedSongBird

The Palestinians have been persecuted, treated worse than dirt with no self determination for decades and not one of the world’s leaders have done anything to help them.

Not done anything to help them? Arab and Israeli leaders have tried again and again and had their hand bitten almost every time. I’d guess the only regime below whose treatment you’d approve of below would be Saddam Husseins.

Jordan. Accepted the most refugees and granted most citizenship. Palestinian groups tried to overthrow govt, sparking civil war (1970-71).

Lebanon. Hosted 200k+ refugees. Armed Palestinian groups a major driver of civil war (1975-90).

Kuwait. Gave 400k employment rights. PLO supported Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, leading to most Palestinians being expelled (1990-91).

Iraq. Saddam hosted many Palestinians right up until he was toppled.

Syria. Hosted 500k refugees. Palestinians took up arms in civil war (2011+).

Israel: granted 150,000 Palestinians citizenship after the 1948 war, now making up about 20% of Israel’s pop, many very well integrated. Pre-2023, 150,000 Palestinians had Israel worker permits including 20,000 Gazans. Evidence that some of those guest workers abetted the Oct 7 massacre.

Edited

Totally agree with what you say here. As well as being given all this tgey have been given billions in aid and their very own aid agency to make sure they had education, health care and billions spent on them (unlike apparently less deserving countries...) Hamas fucked up the gravy train of funding though.

Ihatetomatoes · 26/01/2026 21:03

dairydebris · 26/01/2026 15:08

You've ignored all the decisions made over the years by their own leaders, that have bought them to this place.

I don't agree with your dark assessment of the situation. I think there are Palestinians out there who could provide decent leadership and a 2SS is possible. Don't you think?

It requires the shit leaders to get out of the way first, and that's what everyone should be marching for.

It almost sounds as if you want them to be eternal victims. But I can't imagine why that would be hmmmm?

Exactly.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:26

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 20:33

How many did the Irgun, Lehi and even Haganah kill/murder in the name of self determination or was that different?

Most Zionists now condemn Irgun & Lehi, and yes, they were terrorists. Most condemned them at the time too.

I agree re Haganah also doing some morally dubious things but they also stayed on thr straight & narrow Most of the time.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:28

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 16:55

In fairness, most of these examples date from 30-50 years ago, when about half of Palestinians weren't born, but I agree the situation would likely be similar now.

Re civil war, it is disgraceful many Palestinians fought for Assad. I've seen many Arab rights campaigners criticise the West for being too soft on Assad but Arabs who suopprted him should be held accountable too.

I would also note that a lot of Arabs who suppprted Palestine opposed Arafat backing Saddam in the Kuwait war. This was one of the points when he began to lose a lot of suppprt from his own side.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 21:48

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:26

Most Zionists now condemn Irgun & Lehi, and yes, they were terrorists. Most condemned them at the time too.

I agree re Haganah also doing some morally dubious things but they also stayed on thr straight & narrow Most of the time.

Really?? Each of those groups leaders became Prime Ministers of Israel. When Begin was asked how he felt about being called the father of terrorism in the Middle East. His answer was, the Middle East? The world! That doesn’t sound like condemning to me.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:52

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 21:48

Really?? Each of those groups leaders became Prime Ministers of Israel. When Begin was asked how he felt about being called the father of terrorism in the Middle East. His answer was, the Middle East? The world! That doesn’t sound like condemning to me.

Well, terrorists like Martin mc Guiness took part in Irish politics after laying down their arms. That doesn't mean their actions were supported.

Plenty of prominent Israelis & Jews elsewhere where highly critical of Begin and Shamir. Primo Levi, for one, called him a Fascist (fair enough, esp since Irgun founder Jabotinsky praised Mussolini and Begin funded the Argentine junta during the Falklands War)

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 21:55

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:52

Well, terrorists like Martin mc Guiness took part in Irish politics after laying down their arms. That doesn't mean their actions were supported.

Plenty of prominent Israelis & Jews elsewhere where highly critical of Begin and Shamir. Primo Levi, for one, called him a Fascist (fair enough, esp since Irgun founder Jabotinsky praised Mussolini and Begin funded the Argentine junta during the Falklands War)

Edited

Actually if you talk to a lot of Northern Irish Catholics they were.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:56

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 21:55

Actually if you talk to a lot of Northern Irish Catholics they were.

Well that's vile. Surely MOST N Irish Catholics did not support IRA terrorism though?

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:59

I'd also add one reason Begin got voted in was the horrible way many of the Ashkhenazi secular socialists who dominated the left wing parties treated Mizrahi Jews. Several of them opposed them coming at all & the language & actions used was often shockingly awful.

Begin called Mizrahis his 'brothers' and offered support. If the left wing parties hadn't been frankly racist often, it would probably have lessened the appeal of someone like Begin.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:02

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:56

Well that's vile. Surely MOST N Irish Catholics did not support IRA terrorism though?

You’d be surprised then. I actually know a Catholic man from Belfast who’s life was saved when he was a child by a British soldier in a gun fight. The soldier, while saving him, was killed and his blood was all over him. You can tell the man is traumatised by it but when I asked him don’t you feel some gratitude to the soldier his answer was no, he shouldn’t have been there in the first place.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:04

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 21:59

I'd also add one reason Begin got voted in was the horrible way many of the Ashkhenazi secular socialists who dominated the left wing parties treated Mizrahi Jews. Several of them opposed them coming at all & the language & actions used was often shockingly awful.

Begin called Mizrahis his 'brothers' and offered support. If the left wing parties hadn't been frankly racist often, it would probably have lessened the appeal of someone like Begin.

That is all in Avi’s book. You have to read it. He was called an oriental Jew and was a strong follower of Begin in his youth because of that exact reason.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 22:08

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:02

You’d be surprised then. I actually know a Catholic man from Belfast who’s life was saved when he was a child by a British soldier in a gun fight. The soldier, while saving him, was killed and his blood was all over him. You can tell the man is traumatised by it but when I asked him don’t you feel some gratitude to the soldier his answer was no, he shouldn’t have been there in the first place.

He didn't feel any gratitude to the man who saved his life??

That's really disturbing...

If the man was in the army, that wasn't necessarily due to wanting to fight the IRA in particular, anyway. There'd have been less need for armed presence if the IRA hadn't been committing terror attacks!

I know UK and army committed wrongs to Ireland, but that's still no excuse.

I wonder if some of this mentality feeds in to Republic Irish protestors' attitudes to the Hamas, which according to some evidence I've seen, are often more extreme than in UK.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 22:09

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:04

That is all in Avi’s book. You have to read it. He was called an oriental Jew and was a strong follower of Begin in his youth because of that exact reason.

Thank you, I will definitely read it. That makes a lot of sense.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:32

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 22:08

He didn't feel any gratitude to the man who saved his life??

That's really disturbing...

If the man was in the army, that wasn't necessarily due to wanting to fight the IRA in particular, anyway. There'd have been less need for armed presence if the IRA hadn't been committing terror attacks!

I know UK and army committed wrongs to Ireland, but that's still no excuse.

I wonder if some of this mentality feeds in to Republic Irish protestors' attitudes to the Hamas, which according to some evidence I've seen, are often more extreme than in UK.

I think that is more about the years of British oppression in Ireland in general which is why they have empathy for what the Palestinians are going through. I think it is the same with the South Africans. The Apartheid years are still fairly fresh in their minds.

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 22:52

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 22:32

I think that is more about the years of British oppression in Ireland in general which is why they have empathy for what the Palestinians are going through. I think it is the same with the South Africans. The Apartheid years are still fairly fresh in their minds.

Right...yes. I have a strong interest also in Native American tribes and they have received similar support, I believe.

However, drawing comparisons is always risky. The Irish who do that should be aware that Israel is not a simple parallel for Britain when it ruled Ireland or apartheid South Africa. Israeli actions certainly have included oppressive ones to Palestinians. But Palestinian Arabs don't live in apartheid within Israel, Israeli Jews have their own history of oppression (including from Arabs), and there are other facts etc which makes these parallels risky.

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 23:20

Carla786 · 26/01/2026 22:52

Right...yes. I have a strong interest also in Native American tribes and they have received similar support, I believe.

However, drawing comparisons is always risky. The Irish who do that should be aware that Israel is not a simple parallel for Britain when it ruled Ireland or apartheid South Africa. Israeli actions certainly have included oppressive ones to Palestinians. But Palestinian Arabs don't live in apartheid within Israel, Israeli Jews have their own history of oppression (including from Arabs), and there are other facts etc which makes these parallels risky.

The question about apartheid in Israel for Arab Israeli citizens is dubious. Never mind the lack of public bomb shelters in Arab neighbourhoods or the disparity in school funding, the JNF’s influence over the ILA makes it questionable. It’s not the Arab/Israeli’s that are the issue though. It’s the stateless Palestinians that I’m concerned about. I’ve just realised you said Palestinian Arabs are not living in an Apartheid state. I’m sorry, but even South Africans have said it is more Apartheid than South Africa ever was.

Carla786 · 27/01/2026 00:36

RedSongBird · 26/01/2026 23:20

The question about apartheid in Israel for Arab Israeli citizens is dubious. Never mind the lack of public bomb shelters in Arab neighbourhoods or the disparity in school funding, the JNF’s influence over the ILA makes it questionable. It’s not the Arab/Israeli’s that are the issue though. It’s the stateless Palestinians that I’m concerned about. I’ve just realised you said Palestinian Arabs are not living in an Apartheid state. I’m sorry, but even South Africans have said it is more Apartheid than South Africa ever was.

I was just reading about the school funding disparity- shocking. I mean, even if Likud etc are prejudiced against Arabs, don't they see how unhelpful it is to underfund their school in purely practical terms?

Lack of public bomb shelters in Arab neighbourhoods? Let me look up, that's awful if so.

Sorry, what are the JLF and the ILA?

Re to clarify: I meant Palestinian Arabs living within Israel. I wasn't commenting on the West Bank and Gaza.

RedSongBird · 27/01/2026 06:18

Carla786 · 27/01/2026 00:36

I was just reading about the school funding disparity- shocking. I mean, even if Likud etc are prejudiced against Arabs, don't they see how unhelpful it is to underfund their school in purely practical terms?

Lack of public bomb shelters in Arab neighbourhoods? Let me look up, that's awful if so.

Sorry, what are the JLF and the ILA?

Re to clarify: I meant Palestinian Arabs living within Israel. I wasn't commenting on the West Bank and Gaza.

Edited

Sorry, I mean’t JNF, Jewish National Fund, which acquires land exclusively for settlements by Jewish citizens whereas the ILA is the Israeli Land Authority which is supposed to show equality. Problem is many of the board members of the JNF sit on the ILA board which can make it very difficult for non Jewish Israeli citizens to lease land.

Carla786 · 27/01/2026 18:08

RedSongBird · 27/01/2026 06:18

Sorry, I mean’t JNF, Jewish National Fund, which acquires land exclusively for settlements by Jewish citizens whereas the ILA is the Israeli Land Authority which is supposed to show equality. Problem is many of the board members of the JNF sit on the ILA board which can make it very difficult for non Jewish Israeli citizens to lease land.

This must change too - thank you for explaining. The illegal settlements situation is awful.

Carla786 · 27/01/2026 21:38

Incidentally, I hope UAE can nurture a more positive sense of Arab identity by their curriculum. They should teach about the Arab journalists etc who spoke against Fascism & anti Semitism in that era.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Arab-Responses-Fascism-Nazism-Attraction/dp/029275745X

Amazon

Amazon

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Arab-Responses-Fascism-Nazism-Attraction/dp/029275745X?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-conflict-in-the-middle-east-5480468-uae-plans-to-bankroll-first-planned-community-in-south-gaza