Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chronic pain

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Recovery from Herniated Disc: your success stories, tips and advice would be wonderful

127 replies

NotOutWoods · 15/05/2024 17:37

Hi there everyone,

I'm new here and wanted to share my story. Just after Christmas, I turned what I suspect was a bulging disc in my lumbar spine into a herniated one when I shifted some heavy boxes in the garage. Up until this point, I didn't realise I had a bulging disc. I was seeing a physio for about three or four months and was on ibuprofen daily, functioning and living a normal life, sleeping through the night. I had some mild burning discomfort in my left calf muscle, but apart from that, I was absolutely fine. And I was getting better.

Then, after Christmas, it all went to hell. I woke up the next day in agony, which I now understand is sciatica. I went into the NHS local A&E because I felt like I couldn't feel my bottom or my bits. They had an emergency look at me and scanned me to make sure that it wasn't cauda equina syndrome. After the scan results came back, it transpired that I had what they described as a mild herniation at L4-L5, with a bulging disc in the disc above. The disc above wasn't pressing on any nerves, so it wasn't causing any issues. The herniation was pressing on, I think, my L5, which caused pain to go down from my left knee to my foot. The pain was pretty excruciating, and it took a toll on my daily life. I was prescribed stronger painkillers and given advice to rest and avoid any heavy lifting or strenuous activity.

For the first three months, I tried to stay active by walking every day, sometimes reaching up to twenty thousand steps. Otherwise, I was lying on the floor. Doing some physio. And taking a range of meds. However, I realised that despite my efforts, the pain and discomfort persisted. I decided to take a month off and focus on resting completely. Surprisingly, this seemed to help the disc heal more effectively.

After that month of rest, I began to reintroduce walking into my routine, starting with short, manageable walks. I did ten days of walking for ten minutes in the morning, ten minutes at lunchtime, and sometimes ten minutes in the evening if I felt up to it. While some days were better than others, the pain never became unbearable, just a persistent discomfort that wouldn't go away.

Recently, I decided to test myself by increasing my walking time to half an hour in the morning and half an hour at lunchtime. So far, I've managed to keep up with this routine for the last two days, and although it's not easy, I seem to be doing okay. However, I do have a bit of a limp and a slight foot drop on my left side, which worries me. And the sciatica is a little more than usual. But I can get it to calm again after some rest.

I'm reaching out to this community for advice, success stories, and any tips you might have for herniated disc recovery. How long did it take you to recover fully? What exercises or treatments helped you the most? Any advice on dealing with the discomfort and maintaining a positive mindset would be greatly appreciated.

I should share that I have seen much improvement since Christmas, and I’m having more good days than bad. Even enjoyed some pain-free days or mornings, although pain usually sets in again at some point. Which can be very disheartening. It is not a linear process.

I’ve noticed in the last week the pain has left my foot and is now mostly in my calf, and the type of pain is shifting all the time. Like lately, sharp jolts in the knee, hip and yesterday the glute! I’ve barely had any back pain throughout these last 19 weeks. But just lately, a kind of prickling there. Nothing major.

I am no longer on gabapentin, nor ibuprofen sadly. And using heat and ice when it gets too much. Saving paracetamol for night. I work for myself and have no dependents, so I can rest on the floor when I need to.

I still can’t sit on the sofa, or drive a car (brings on too much sciatic pain). But I am sleeping so much better (seven hours with some waking moments, caused by only being able to sleep on one side).

Reading Dr Stuart McGill’s Back Mechanic massively helped. I know how to lift stuff, move in bed, get out of bed.. all without pain!

Thank you for taking the time to read my story. I'm looking forward to hearing your experiences and suggestions. But I suspect this injury mostly relies on time to heal!

OP posts:
NotOutWoods · 04/01/2025 09:35

Hi everyone! Happy New Year! I hope you're all doing ok. I'm marking an entire year tomorrow since I really injured my back. (Quick recap: L4/L5 disc protrusion, pressing on L5 and S1 nerves and causing sciatica down my left calf and into my left foot. Initial sharp shooting pains, burning, fuzzing, cramping... In May, I also began to have similar but milder symptoms in my right leg and foot, too – apparently quite common and normal).

I refuse to get down about it. Particularly as I'm still recovering. Instead, I'm reminding myself of how far I've come in 12 months. I'm proud of myself. I've kept going, even on very difficult days.

What I'm finding with this injury is that there are certain things you must do to support your healing, but mostly – it's a matter of time. And everyone is different.

If you've just injured your back and you're reading loads of stuff online about it taking 6-12 weeks to recover, I really hope that's the case for you. And for many people, it is. But here's the reality you probably don't want to hear: the average healing time is 18 months. It can often take two years or more.

During the acute phase, I didn't want to hear this fact. I was hoping I'd be in the lucky three-month camp. Alas, I had a pretty nasty disc protrusion and I'm 46, so I suspect it's a long road for me.

What has helped me? Well, in the first three months, I did too much. I was walking too much. Doing pilates. All too much, too soon. Once I allowed myself to rest in the fourth month – as in, just lie on my yoga mat face down or on my back with my legs raised at 90 degrees on my sofa seat – things began to calm down. It's during that initial phase that you need to let things settle. You keep getting up, moving around the house. But you have to let the disc have time to heal in those early days.

And then, you begin walking again. Three times a day, starting at five minutes each time. And you go for your first walk as soon as you wake up. For me, that first month of walking again was excruciating. It was end of April and May, and I would wear sunglasses so people couldn't see me crying. Every step was so difficult. I'd make it home and almost collapse onto the front door, bursting into my home and going straight to my yoga mat on the floor to rest.

I also followed Colin's morning routine during that time (See below). It was a life saver. And really helped me allow the disc to mend itself. During those first four or five months, I had a couple of stints on Gabapentin... maybe three weeks at a time. But I came off that stuff asap. I also stopped taking ibuprofen. I realised whilst it was nice to have a lot of the pain dialled down, a) I needed to get feedback, so I knew what was and wasn't working... and b) I read somewhere that ibuprofen stops your body's natural inflammatory response to the disc injury – a response you need in order for your system to clean up the herniation naturally. Also, I was off my face on that Gabapentin stuff. It was awful. But I used it when I absolutely needed it. Because as anyone who's experienced sciatica will tell you, it's one of the most painful things we can ever endure.

Ice is your friend. I had a wearable ice pack that I'd strap around my waist and leave on for half an hour at a time. Once the inflammation came down and I realised muscles were also involved, tensing to protect the spine, I used heat. A microwavable wheat sack.

Around June, six months post-injury, my walking was vastly improved. I'd slowly and sensibly increased those five minute walks, three times a day, to just one big morning walk. I found my symptoms were the most manageable during those morning walks, so I would trek for up to 9km. I easily did 15-20k steps during those summer months.

In May, after allowing my body to rest for three weeks, I began a daily routine of physio/pilates work. Pelvic tilts, glute bridges, bird dogs, dead bugs, side leg lifts, clams, step ups, standing press ups, squats... every single day.

By August, I was finally able to drive again. Albeit with leg pain. It was at this stage that I ditched a "pain diary" to take the pressure off recovery. And I realised I needed to test my limits and build resilience and tolerance. So I made myself do things that caused pain. I also read The Way Out by Alan Gordon, and this helped me get over the fear of pain. And gave me some cool techniques to calm myself.

It was August when I went out for my first meal (I still was using my sciatica cushion...about £20 off Amazon and an absolute god-send). And things starting to improve further. The driving got easier and easier. It's still not ideal now, but I can really see I'm improving all the time.

I started swimming in September and that really helped calm any flare ups, which – back then – would last for three weeks. Now flare ups can be over in a day or sooner. And in this second half of the year, I had lots of little wins that were huge to me. Like, being able to tie my shoe laces for the first time. Or realising I could put my socks on without putting each foot onto a stool and lunging in. I started doing more and more things. In November, I went to a gig with a friend! My leg was burning the whole time, but I was more than ok.

I'm still walking my ass off. I'm back in the gym and on the elliptical trainer and using the machines rather than free weights. I'm being very careful but I understand I need to build strength. I'm going to pilates classes.

I'm in the "manage chronic pain" phase. My back feels secure. I'm feeling quite fit, given my limitations. I'm the lightest I've been in years. As throughout all of this, I've been very meticulous with nutrition – avoiding foods that cause inflammation. My only vice is alcohol. It isn't recommended as it causes inflammation. However, I've justified having it as it actually calms my muscles and takes the pain down several notches. I probably suffer for it the next day. But I figure, I'm not on the hard meds, so some booze isn't going to kill me. For now. Plus, in a silly way, it's felt like I've still had a life. Even when it's been so limited. Going the pub for a pint with my "special cushion" has been a true joy.

It wasn't until end of October that I finally slept through the night. My god. I cried the next day. Sleep has been very difficult indeed. Last night, I had seven hours of uninterrupted sleep. Bliss. Alcohol will be going on hold now, too.

Anyway, my point is. This has been a long journey for me. But I am feeling optimistic that at some point in the next 12 months, the pain will disappear. The only thing I've got to do is stick to the routine, keep positive and reward my body with all the rest, care and attention it needs. And I'll probably do that for the rest of my life.

Yes, I have omega-three, B12, magnesium... Yes, I walk daily... a lot. Yes, I do all the recommended exercises, and I balance rest in between. But what I'm starting to realise is that this is an injury that mostly takes time.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOIG6UtO0vk

OP posts:
justasking111 · 04/01/2025 09:44

Happy New year. Thanks for the video. Its a slow journey that's for sure, which I didn't realise at the beginning. Keep going.

Purpleandredandyellow · 04/01/2025 11:00

@NotOutWoods - congratulations on your year! Great post and such a help to anyone who suffers from this! Wish I had read it 20 years ago when it all kicked off for me.

I've posted before about my journey but what has struck me for thr last week of my holidays (where I did not have my normal school drop off walk and had a lie in instead most days til 9:30) - that walk first thing in the morning is absolutely critical for me!! Immediately that lower back pain is back and by the end of 5 days I could feel the sciatica starting again.

Luckily the physio exercises, swimming and sauna/jacuzzi and cold plunge has brought the inflammation down a bit but so shocked at the effect of the reduction in walking!

I'm still struggling with driving a manual car though - we can't afford to upgrade to automatic for a few years so my husband ends up doing most of the driving - any tips on how to minimise pain whilst driving manual?

NotOutWoods · 04/01/2025 18:36

Gosh @Purpleandredandyellow! You’ve been suffering for a while haven’t you! I hope it’s only rare moments rather than the norm.

My brother had this injury when he was in his early thirties. Which makes us realise this thing is genetic for us.

He suffered for two years. Did barely anything to get better except rest and try and get on with life. And one day, poof! Gone. He’s had no trouble since and it’s been over a decade. Which is roughly the time it takes for a disc to heal.

That’s not to say some continue to have issues. My brother has not had sciatic since but he gets numb twinges now and again. Nothing to write home about.

That will be the same for me too. I will absolutely recover from this and never suffer again! I’ve done my research and I’m afraid it’s hard work every day to ensure that happens.

Car? Sofa? Mattress? Chair? None of it matters. What is crucial is building a body that is strong, resilient and mobile. Mobility is key.

My advice? Build your core strength. Get strong glutes and legs. Hire a personal trainer. Walk every single day. Stretch. Look after your body. Because no car, sofa or mattress will fix it, only us! You’ve got this! 💪

OP posts:
EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 13:02

Hello back pain people.

My back pain has unfortunately got worse, not better, and I'm feeling very depressed and hopeless.

I'm more complicated because I also have hip arthritis, which is also getting worse.

I had the results of my MRI yesterday, bulging disc at L4&5 pressing on nerves, and herniated disc L1&2 not pressing on nerves.

Back in Sept when it started I was able to walk a lot to make it feel better. Now walking makes it worse.

I'm not sure what to do with my body now, I've no idea how to help myself get better.

justasking111 · 09/01/2025 13:06

EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 13:02

Hello back pain people.

My back pain has unfortunately got worse, not better, and I'm feeling very depressed and hopeless.

I'm more complicated because I also have hip arthritis, which is also getting worse.

I had the results of my MRI yesterday, bulging disc at L4&5 pressing on nerves, and herniated disc L1&2 not pressing on nerves.

Back in Sept when it started I was able to walk a lot to make it feel better. Now walking makes it worse.

I'm not sure what to do with my body now, I've no idea how to help myself get better.

Your MRI showed the same issues as mine in the same place plus arthritis right hip

Are you using a walking stick?

EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 13:50

@justasking111 nice to find another person in the same situation. No I'm not using a walking stick, but as of yesterday I'm in too much pain to walk around my park. Before yesterday I could manage 15-minute walks around the park.

What's your situation, has anyone discussed hip replacement with you? There's a lot of confusion online re whether the hip problem causes the back problem, or the back problem causes the hip problem. Most people seem to think the hip is the cause of the back.

justasking111 · 09/01/2025 14:06

Well my hip is moderate. My back complicated but definitely by far the worst. I know it's throwing my gait out which aggravates the hip.

I use the walking stick in the left hand because of my right hip to realign my body a bit.

This cold weather is crucifying though, so you should consider that.

EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 15:09

Thanks for the link @justasking111 😊 I don't feel I need a stick right now (back in too much pain to walk really), but good to know folding ones exist for the future.

Hope my back settles down again. I'd been enjoying long lunchtime walks that made it feel better when it was niggling.

It's hard not to worry that this is a slippery slope from 'back hurts' to 'back is in agony', I really hope not.

Mentally that's the hard part for me at the moment - I feel like other back hernations are one big injury that people then recover from. Whereas it feels like mine is a gradually worsening problem.

How are you doing at the moment @NotOutWoods ? And anyone else on this thread?

NotOutWoods · 09/01/2025 19:06

Hey @EatingRipeCamembert Thanks for checking in. How you doing?

I am getting there, thank you! I reached a whole year post-injury last weekend. I was a bit down. But soon perked up, remembering how far I’ve come!

I am sleeping! Through the night! Last night, a whole happy eight hours without one waking moment. So good. I can’t tell you how grateful I am.

Things are just generally getting easier. But it’s a slow process. I’m back in the gym. Three times a week. It’s going really well. I’m walking like a maniac. I’m focused on stretching, nerve glides, core. Eating very well. My lightest weight since my teens.

Not on any meds. Less reliant on heat. It’s all gone. No ice for months. Having great days, having awful days. It’s not linear.

But I have every faith, another six months. Another year. And I’ll finally get there. I am determined.

what about you?

OP posts:
NotOutWoods · 09/01/2025 19:09

EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 13:02

Hello back pain people.

My back pain has unfortunately got worse, not better, and I'm feeling very depressed and hopeless.

I'm more complicated because I also have hip arthritis, which is also getting worse.

I had the results of my MRI yesterday, bulging disc at L4&5 pressing on nerves, and herniated disc L1&2 not pressing on nerves.

Back in Sept when it started I was able to walk a lot to make it feel better. Now walking makes it worse.

I'm not sure what to do with my body now, I've no idea how to help myself get better.

Gosh, forgive me. I’m on my phone and I didn’t read this before your last. Sorry to hear it’s got worse. Don’t be depressed. You’re not hopeless.

I would recommend buying Back Mechanic by McGill. And follow his advice to the letter. At least in your early days of recovery. Where is your pain? What are your symptoms?

I hope you’re ok.
You have my every sympathy and support.

OP posts:
EatingRipeCamembert · 09/01/2025 20:04

Great update @NotOutWoods it's so encouraging to read your posts, your positive outlook is encouraging.

I was previously feeling positive - when the back pain started in August I did some research and found this thread and found it super helpful. I bought the Back Mechanic and implemented the walking. I started feeling better, my back pain pretty much disappeared by Nov.

Then late Nov it all came back again, accompanied by other problems, my arthritic hip has got worse and I've now got upper back, neck and shoulder pain too.

I don't know for sure yet, but I suspect at least one hip needs replacing.

I feel like in the last 1.5 months my spine and body have collapsed! There's obviously something at the root of all this, but I don't know how easily I can unpick it or fix it.

I'm in a very dark place today. Hopefully I'll be able to return to feeling more hopeful soon.

justasking111 · 10/01/2025 08:07

I went back to GP who arranged another x-ray on my hip to check for changes. There were none.

I would get checked for osteoporosis if you haven't already though.

user1494050295 · 10/01/2025 08:11

Time. When I herniated mine in 2014 I saw my osteopath a few times and have seen him once a year for maintenance. I am careful with lifting, I don’t stand in one spot for too long. I swim 4 times a week but not breast stroke. I have had a couple of flair ups and a friend does acupuncture on the area which helps. I do t sit on the ground. Good luck.

NotOutWoods · 11/01/2025 15:10

Sorry to hear that @EatingRipeCamembert! I first injured myself in August 2023 and then made it much worse in January 2024.

Don’t be down! Be determined. Get yourself booked in to see the GP. And implement spine hygiene right now. Go easy. And do let us know how you’re doing.

OP posts:
LotusFlower24 · 10/02/2025 21:04

Hi, just wanted to say this is a great thread..glad I came across it!
I haven't read all posts yet but all really interesting and helpful so far. I had a herniated disc and I am still struggling with not being able to walk properly/numbness/daily life etc even with it being removed. Good point about stress..the past couple of days I've been under stress and really been feeling worse (had been relatively stress free for a few weeks there) so I believe stress/tension has a lot to do with flare ups in this area. Edited to say I really wish I'd found this thread last year!!

NotOutWoods · 11/02/2025 08:03

Hey everyone! Hope you’re all ok! I’m back in the gym. Have been since December. Slowly does it. I’m doing all sorts of things. Wood chops, planks, captain knee raises, lat pull downs, Bulgarian split squats, squats, around the worlds, gorilla lifts… face pulls, halos, leg presses, hip extensions, hip abductors and adductors… you name it, I’m doing it! I was even doing weighted ball slams the other day. Up and over side to side.

I’m working with a personal trainer who is well versed in helping people recover and all the evidence and research now points to building a strong body all over. And that bending is good for us. I’m slowly working on flexion. No weights yet in that regard. And certainly no dead lifts or anything like that. But I’ll get there. We’re being careful.

The nerve pain is slowly fading too. I’m having much better days. I realised I could stretch out my left leg again the other week. And my left foot is back to rolling normally as I walk! Happy times!

Bit by bit I am healing. I am so grateful to be at this stage. Where I can do most things again. And I can be in the gym. Walk 20k steps a day if I want. And sleep through most nights. So grateful.

Yes, I’d love that no pain feeling again. It’s coming. It’s on the horizon. I will work on my strength and mobility until my dying days. It’s down to me! I’ve totally got this! 💪

OP posts:
NotOutWoods · 18/02/2025 21:34

A quick update! I am so much better. Barely any pain now. Just fuzzing and a few pulls but the nerve pain is pretty much gone.

I am really making progress every week. It’s been a long road so far but I am now very optimistic for a full recovery either this year or next. But until then, it’s business as usual. And I’ve just booked my first holiday since August 2023 😭

OP posts:
EatingRipeCamembert · 18/02/2025 21:39

It's so good to read your updates OP. It gives me hope.

My situation has felt (and still feels) a bit bleak because it's complicated by a lot of stuff going wrong at once. I'm now due to have a hip replacement very soon, and I'm hoping that after that is done and I've recovered, I will then be in a fit state to do walking and physio to help my bulging disc recover. Though I do worry that now the other hip is starting to go too. Arthritic hips are not great for back health, unfortunately. I also have a shoulder freezing (I think) which is not going to do my back good either.

Though it's difficult to remain optimistic I must remind myself that I did get my back mostly better by end of Nov last year by walking (before my hip got too bad and the back pain came back). And my back pain is probably not as bad as some people on this thread.

lovemycbf · 18/02/2025 21:51

I'm six years in from rupturing my L5 and herniating the two discs above
Probably not what you want to hear but I'm still on strong painkillers,the sciatica lasted about 18 months and my whole life has had to change
I can't bend down easily and I have foot problems now as my giat has changed
Everything is hard work and painful
Sorry probably not what you wanted me to say

Wasvular · 18/02/2025 22:32

Hi I’m a physio with herniated discs. Walking lots helps, as does swimming but I haven’t reacted well to the chlorine. Reduce sitting as much as possible, for a long as possible. It will take a year or two to recover fully. Some may need surgery but it really is a last resort.

I will have long lasting effects and permanent nerve damage. It’s not a big deal now the pain has gone.

I go to the gym and do single leg strength work. With upper body I avoid anything compressing the spine. The step machine and cross trainers are also good. No running for the foreseeable. No heavy lifting….perhaps ever.

justasking111 · 19/02/2025 07:40

Hospital appointment yesterday miles of corridors from one area to another. They kept offering me a wheelchair which I refused. Baby steps. I realised last week that the back spasms have gone so it's time to start at a gym I think.

PersephonePitstop · 19/02/2025 17:39

I’m at the early stages having started with sciatica just before Christmas, it’s been agony and I’ve been off sick all the year!

I was expecting to be better within a couple of weeks but certainly within 6 weeks. I’ve had to revise my expectations considerably.

Have been to physio today and am certainly improving so now plan a phased return to my very stressful job.

Meant to start Mounjaro to help with weight loss in January but was too depressed with the pain. That’s a decision I regret now and that needs to be next on the agenda.

justasking111 · 19/02/2025 20:14

Mounjaro. Can you get to the loo fast if needed. Only asking because you might get side effects requiring a quick dash.

Swipe left for the next trending thread