For us the Elf isn’t a “traditional” Elf on a Shelf, I think they are creepy. I used plush ones, sadly the company I bought them from no longer exists. The first elf came in a lovely box on Dec 1st addressed to my DDs 4 & 2 at the time. He had a check list passport and report card, but we didn’t really use these. He got up to a few silly things the first year, Next year another elf joined him, a girl elf. We used a little plush elf from home bargains for #3 but by the time I went to buy an “official” one the company had stopped making them. I did manage to find a girl elf in home bargains a couple of years later.
Ours turn up with the advent calendars. They don’t do “naughty” things but mischievous. I wouldn’t make them do anything I’d tell my DDs off for, but they have fun. Sometimes they bring extra treats, for example we are going to see Elf the musical so they are bringing Elf T-shirts on the day. They may bring Christmas craft things to do or a little extra toy. One year I wrapped them in paper chains, they started them and my DDs had to finish putting them together. For the most part the extras are things I want my DDs to use during December, hair scrunchies, headbands etc…
We now have a bit of a collection, including the dreaded creepy one. I gave in last year as my DD was desperate, he turned up halfway through December. She’s actually bought her own one already, she keeps with her because she’s worried I will get rid of him slight lol but slightly ahh I wouldn’t do that.
A lot get over the Elf’s but DH and I love them and enjoy thinking of ideas for them.
If your going to do this think about how you will manage the tired days and days you can’t find the bloody things. One of my DDs use to hide hers to stop him getting up to things, fingers crossed 🤞 I’ve always eventually managed to find him.