I agree, non edible stuff is the way forward. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but I've appeared utterly thrilled with homemade truffles, rhubarb gin, wild strawberry gin, chutney...and it's always been binned. In reality, no one is ever going to tell you this, but a lot of people don't want edibles that we have no idea if they've sat on the side in your kitchen for a bit too long, or that kind of thing. The gin, both times, we tried, winced and poured away. Frustratingly, for politeness sake, when the bearers of these gifts have asked if we enjoyed them, we of course say how lovely they were and we get more of the same every year. Neither of us have ever given any prior indication we even like gin, pickles, chutneys, yet this is what we get.
Please, gift/make what people would actually like...not what you've decided you want to make. Would you buy twenty pots of jam and give them generically to everyone you know? Bit like the blanket christmas gift that everyone gets handed out in a workplace.
We've had crocheted things for the babies, which were a lovely and personal gift. We've had photo collages, also really personal and much appreciated.
I haven't really thought it through, just thinking out loud, but could you gift a kit of the thing you are planning on making? In a pretty hamper, with the ingredients still sealed, make the instructions look beautiful with your cricut, for the person to then make themselves?