Small, Midwest (and somewhat northerly) town life as portrayed in those Hallmark movies - the community potlucks, the church events, the local diner being the centre of the universe where everyone congregates, and there is time for everyone to bake cookies and pies and meet each other in the middle of the day.....that would be lovely (for Christmas).
The reality of life there, even if it was like the movies, would probably pall after a couple of weeks. Everyone would know everyone else's business. Limited shopping generally and probably food shopping too (yes, plenty of food, but limited range so far less choice). Lots more driving, of quite long distances, and no or more limited public transport (which American outside cities are far less likely to use anyway).
Some one of these years, we will get snow here, and enough time off to prep properly, and actually relax over the holidays, and see some movies etc. But still have things like spiced beef, proper roast potatoes, Christmas cake and mince pies, and continental favourites like mulled wine.