"When I was little she made me a miniature Victorian style fruit and veg stall, with tiny clay fruits and veggies. Also a NewYork deli counter with little sandwiches and desserts, amazing amount of detail."
Your Mum sounded awesome, MangoSalsa.
I honestly enjoy any hand-made gift, as shows time, thought and effort.
Doesn't matter how amateur the end result, if it comes from someone you care about.
If tight budgets leave no other option anyway, it must be pretty disheartening knowing ahead certain cynical recipients will mock or dismiss your efforts.
One of my favourite childhood memories is of the annual family puzzlement over an elderly aunt's...um...characterful pottery gifts.
She stuck it out at evening classes for over 9 years, never improved, cheerfully admitted to her total lack of skill, yet using her wonky 'mug' 20plus years later never fails to make me smile.
So uniquely her.
I think kids' home-made presents generally get viewed more leniently anyway (or should do, surely).
Our Xmas decorations box still contains many weird and wonderful ornaments, proudly given by youngsters I worked with/friends' kids.
(Especially nice if parents add full names/dates).
Favourite home-made items I've received from adults:
-felt/ribbon/wooden tree decorations
-mulled wine spice mix, in pretty glass jar, ribboned cinnamon stick attached
-crocheted hanging plant holder
-freshly baked bread
-stovetop house fragrancer blend
(cloves/cinnamon stick/cranberries/orange/nutmeg etc., ready to simmer in a pan for instant festive scent.
Alternative to candles).