Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Children's health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Has your child ever broken a wrist, can you tell me about it please?

41 replies

HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 16:05

Just picked up ds1 from school, and he is quite tearful and pale and holding his wrist. He says it hurts a lot and keeps crying - not really like him except he will often be tired after school, so I'm not sure how much of it is that iyswim.

It's not swollen, looks the same as the other one if a bit limp, but he can't use it properly. He did it by falling over at morning break apparently - he said he cried a lot and has been crying all day 'in between' so not all the time (thank goodness).

Teachers haven't commented. Do I take him up for an x ray or would it be more swollen and so on?

TIA.

OP posts:
HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 16:06

He's 5 btw.

OP posts:
sarah293 · 14/01/2009 16:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

AmIOdetteOrOdile · 14/01/2009 16:14

Take him for an x-ray. My DS had a broken wrist for 5 days before we realised. It only started swelling after about 4 days. (he mentioned it hurt after falling over on the first day, but nothing after that)

AmIOdetteOrOdile · 14/01/2009 16:14

He was 5 as well.

princessmel · 14/01/2009 16:16

Dd did when she was about 19 m. She fell off our bed.

It wasn't particularly swollen. Or bruised. But I knew she was in a lot of pain. And she couldn't/wouldn't use that arm/hand.

We went to A and E for an x ray.

They didnt put anything on it. Just told us to use pain relief.

I'd go to A and E.

HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 16:17

Really? Oh b*gger, thanks - we're only about 5 mins walk from l'hopital, but ds2 likes to go walkabout so will be a struggle to keep him occupied.

OP posts:
MadreInglese · 14/01/2009 16:18

Take him. DD broke her wrist when she was 7 falling over at school, we thought it was just bruised as there was no swelling. We we to A&E as she'd fallen in the morning but it was still hurting by the evening and she wasn't using that arm. Even the doctor at A&E told us she didn't think it was broken but would xray just in case, and she expressed her surprise when it showed up as a fracture.

If it is broken he should be a lot more comfortable once they set it and maybe give him some painkillers. Hope he is ok.

retiredgoth2 · 14/01/2009 16:18

...children quite frequently have buckle (also known as 'torus') fractures of the radius which are not immediately obvious.

Child + fall on outstretched hand + wrist tenderness = torus fracture until proven otherwise, so yes it needs investigation.

...that said, I imagine there must be a significant number of children who have such injuries and never get them treated (as they are not always obvious) yet no real harm seems to occur....

Olihan · 14/01/2009 16:19

Ds broke his elbow last year (aged 4) and it didn't swell. He was the same wrt not using it and being very tearful. I realised it was serious when he didn't stop crying after a dose of calpol but was making less fuss than he normally would with a minor bump iyswim? He was more quietly upset which made me think 'Hmm'.

Personally I'd take him to A&E and get it checked. If he's not the sort of child to fuss for this long over an injury then it must be pretty painful.

boredveryverybored · 14/01/2009 16:20

I broke my wrist when I was around 7 and it wasn't obvious, was days before my mum believed me and took me to the hospital!
Bet she felt bad

princessmel · 14/01/2009 16:21

Yes doctor said dd prbably hadn't broken hers aswell, becauses she was sucking her thumb of the bad hand. But that is the thumb she sucks. Plus she'd had neurofen by then. So the pain was lessened I'd imagine.

mummyhill · 14/01/2009 16:22

DD fell off a trampoline and broke her elbow. It didn't look swollen but she was obviously in a lot of pain. She was in cast for 6 weeks.

Take to A&E and get it checked out for your own piece of mind. The staff there would rather you had it looked at now than leaving it overnight incase it is broken and the bone shifts which will mean they have more fun setting it! If it is broken then you need to be having words with the school. Actually I would ask the school why you weren't notified that he had hurt himself full stop if he is in that much pain, surely someone would of noticed him crying and asked what was up?

HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 16:25

Ok, will wander up there now. I might ask how long the wait will be, then if it's going to be 3 hours just come home and ring the OOH for an appointment there later. Then we might get to have an X ray anyway and minimise the wait iyswim.

Thanks for all your help x

OP posts:
Idrankthechristmasspirits · 14/01/2009 16:25

I fell on ice and got a greenstick fracture in mky wrist, it didn't swell untill the next day but was more blue than swollen.

I think a greenstick fracture is the same thing that retired goth is posting about.

HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 16:26

Yes he said he asked for his mummy, but nobody rang. I shall have words if he's busted it!

OP posts:
cikecaka · 14/01/2009 16:28

Is he able to move his fingers? Usually a sure sign if he cant

MadreInglese · 14/01/2009 16:32

Kids usually get seen fairly quickly IME

BlueSapphire77 · 14/01/2009 16:37

Idrankthechristmasspirits

I fell on ice and got a greenstick fracture in mky wrist, it didn't swell untill the next day but was more blue than swollen.

I think a greenstick fracture is the same thing that retired goth is posting about.

sunnygirl1412 · 14/01/2009 16:52

Ds1 is currently hors de combat with a broken wrist - he's 15 and did it by falling about 10 feet (doing stunts on his bike). His wrist was swollen and sore, but the first aider at the skate park said they thought it was sprained, not broken - we disagreed and took him to casualty. Sure enough, he's in a cast now.

Ds2 has broken both wrists - on seperate occasions. Once playing 'Prison Rules Football' at senior school (apparently that's football with NO rules.

The other time he was mucking round at home and fell over - and as others have said here, we didn't think it was broken that time - there was a little swelling but no deformity, and though he did whinge about it, the pain seemed to settle with calpol, and he slept fine that night. It wasn't 'til the next day, after he'd been out playing football, when he tried to boost himself up onto the worktop and collapsed with pain, that we took him to casualty.

Actually it was dh who took him - I was up to my eyes in emulsion, redecorating our bedroom, when dh came in and said, "Ds2 is still whinging about his wrist - I'm going to take him up to casualty so THEY can tell him it's not broken." Half an hour later he rang to say he'd be back when ds2 had had a cast applied.

If it is broken and he needs a cast, you might find that they won't put a full cast on it at once, because they might be concerned about further swelling. Each time one of mine has broken a wrist, they've put on what's called a back slab - basically a slab of plaster under the arm, bandaged onto it, to stabilise the fracture. Then a day or two later, they put on the full cast.

This was done as an outpatient in the Fracture Clinic for ds2 both times but ds1 had to have an anaesthetic because he'd displaced the fracture and it needed manipulation under anaesthetic, but this was a very quick process, and he was so alert and well on his return from theatre that he spotted the dinner trolley and ordered his sunday lunch on the way past on the theatre trolley!! Roast lamb, roast and mashed potatoes, gravy, sweetcorn and trifle to follow!

If I remember right, ds2 had his plaster on for 3-4 weeks each time, and ds1 is expecting to have his taken off in 6 weeks (because he did a proper job of it, I assume). Neither of them seemed to be in agony afterwards - ds1 has used neurofen for pain relief and went back to school on monday - two days after the accident and one day after the op. He did wonder if he'd be able to do his paper round, provided he switched his brake to his right handlebar (he's broken the left wrist) but we didn't think that was a terribly good idea!

I hope your ds feels better soon.

sunnygirl1412 · 14/01/2009 16:55

And contrary to what cikecaka says, ability to move the fingers isn't necessarily a sign of no fracture. Ds1 could use his on saturday evening - in fact he had ridden from the skate park to the station (as the first aider had told him it wasn't broken); and ds2 was using his hand normally the time he fell at home.

His was a greenstick fracture that time, so I can understand why the mobility was still there.

And sorry for going on so much - I'd started, so I was going to finish, iyswim.

cikecaka · 14/01/2009 17:04

Apologies but when DS broke his arm twice that what they looked for. I will keep my opinion to myself in future

sunnygirl1412 · 14/01/2009 17:56

Sorry if that came over as too terse, cikecaka - like you, I was speaking from our experience, and at least two times out of three, my ds's have been able to move their fingers.

On our latest visit to casualty, ds1 tried to argue with the casualty doctor that his wrist couldn't be broken because he could still move his fingers - and just got an amused look from the doctor.

I assume that it's the opposite that applies, if you see what I mean - inability to move the fingers probably is a good indication of a fracture.

NorthernNell · 14/01/2009 18:39

Between 4 children have had 7 broken wrists - sure fire test for me is can they turn 'bad' hand over without moving elbow, if no and lots of eye rolling grunting and tears off we go back to A+E!

HelenBurns · 14/01/2009 18:52

Thankyou ALL for your support and help, I really appreciate it - I know more about broken wrists now than I hope ever to need to know!

It's not broken, thankfully. They did an x ray and said it is probably just a sprain. We were seen really quickly in triage but then had to wait about an hour to go into the ward bit.

They were lovely to us all and it was quite nice in a way...!

I'll probably ask school what their usual policy is about injuries because I would have preferred to know he was crying and in pain all day - but I think as it isn't broken they just made the best call they could at the time.

thanks again - off to make him something to eat!

OP posts:
AmIOdetteOrOdile · 14/01/2009 18:53

Glad it's not broken Helen - would definitely say something to the school. And also make sure he, they and you are careful of that arm for a week or so.