Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Children's books

Join in for children's book recommendations.

Censorship? Old attitudes v modern values

2 replies

PrettyCandles · 21/02/2009 23:09

Ds1 absolutely loved 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, and I want to give him other classics to read. I thought Around the World in 80 Days might be a good one, but on skimming it I realised that a lot of the attitudes and terminology would be considered unacceptable nowadays. Racist, sexist, class-ist, and imperialist. TBH, the only one I have any concerns with is the racism. IMO it is necessary to understand class-division and imperialism in order to have a proper understanding of our British heritage. And the book is not, of itself, racist - it simply reflects what was the normal language of the time.

But ds is very impressionable. He knows that not everything he reads in a book is fact, but he doesn't know when it is and when it isn't. He's only 8. I want him to have the freedom to read by himself, without having me looking over his shoulder and telling him what to think. I also want him to read well-written texts. Sometimes, when I read modern childrens' books, I cringe at the sloppy grammar and pathetic use of language.

So what do I do? Give him books which are wonderful stories wonderfully written, and accept that he may make bizarre and dated assumptions about our world, or shift those books to the top shelf and hope that, by the time he is tall enough to read them, he will be old enough to understand what is and isn't acceptable?

OP posts:
Thunderduck · 21/02/2009 23:37

Allow him to read them. You can always have a talk with him about attitudes of the time and how we know better now.

mimsum · 22/02/2009 20:00

dh has been reading classic children's books to ds2 for a couple of years now (he's 9) - started with Treasure Island and Kidnapped and surprised us by how much he enjoyed them. He's now read things like King Solomon's Mines, Huckleberry Finn etc all of which have racist/sexist attitudes and words, and he's just read him Around the World in 80 Days. Reading them aloud means they can discuss anything ds finds confusing and also means that they can talk about what was acceptable then and what is acceptable now. And thankfully, ds has never gone into his extremely multi-cultural classroom and called any of the other boys a n..... (phew)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page