My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join in for children's book recommendations.

Children's books

Stig of the Dump .... how scary/emotionally traumatic is it?

11 replies

deepdarkwood · 24/07/2010 09:29

I've got the audio tape from the library for the dcs for trip down to COrnwall.
But ds (6) is a hugely sensitive, sentimental type and it's a while since I read it .
Is he going to be quaking in terror/sobbing himself to sleep?

OP posts:
deepdarkwood · 24/07/2010 11:44

bump

OP posts:
wb · 24/07/2010 12:03

I don't recall finding it scary or traumatic at all, and I enjoyed being frightened as a child. Was more fascinated by the idea of a 'cave boy' living at the end of the garden. I was a bit older when I read it though (7 or 8)

deepdarkwood · 24/07/2010 13:37

Thanks wb - there have been a few things we've read to him that I remembered as safe ... and then discovered were not!

OP posts:
paisleyleaf · 24/07/2010 13:42

I can't remember anything traumatic (but then I've not read it again recently). I think I was junior school age. Would a 6 year old not just find it a bit boring?

bran · 24/07/2010 14:00

DS listened to it on his school bus, all 5 and 6 yr olds, I think everyone was fine with it. They are generally tough nuts though.

Tales of a Killer Cat was very popular on the school bus, and not sentimental or likely to cause sentimentality.

deepdarkwood · 24/07/2010 17:15

Thanks for extra reassurance. Killer cat looks fab ... but too late to get as we're setting off in 10 mins!

Paisley - I was hoping for something that wouldn't bore me

OP posts:
ProfessorLaytonIsMyLoveSlave · 24/07/2010 17:35

I don't remember its being traumatic. The TV adaptation (with Thomas Sangster) is very good but they change the ending in that (they portray Stig as someone who at some point fell through a timewarp, and at the end he goes back and is reunited with his family, which of course means leaving Barney) and that had DS in floods of tears. But I don't think any of that's in the book.

moondog · 18/12/2012 20:39

I've just read this to my children and am pondering the significance of the baby that Lou saves from the rock as it is lowered into place.
Is it Stig?
Did Lou and Barney go back in time to save Stig from being sacrificed?
Any thoughts appreciated.

beatricequimby · 19/12/2012 21:21

My ds is very similar and read it happily age 6.

StellaNova · 20/12/2012 10:13

It was on Jackanory when I was little, I'm not sure what age that was aimed at. I think we had it read to our class when we were 7/8 so it is probably not too traumatic. Then again we were read Animal Farm aged 10, I'm not quite sure whether the teacher thought we would notice the Marxist/ Leninist satire driving the plot.

moondog · 20/12/2012 18:02

Anyone got an angle on the baby under the rock?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.