Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

my nanny has admitted that she finds it hard looking after dd1...

11 replies

beforesunrise · 26/02/2009 19:47

My dd1 is 3, and she is (of course) a wonderful, bright, sparkly little girl. she is also incredibly strongwilled, prone to monster temper tantrums, and very jealous of her little sister who's 9 months- she's recently started hitting her repeatedly.

I am really working v hard at addressing her behaviour, which i think is normal, but still v challenging and hard work. I, as her mother, sometime find it almost too much- but with the help of dr tanya byron's books i am much more positive.

i have had this nanny since september as a mother's help, and have gone back to work 4 weeks ago. she (the nanny) is a really nice person, a bit more mature than the average nanny (late 40s) and very caring and sensible, she has 2 grown daughters and she has looked after children before in a sole charge capacity, although she is not a career nanny if that makes sense.

anyway, sorry, long preamble, but tonight she told me that dd1 had a megatantrum this am about getting dressed etc, and that it was really extreme and she finds it really hard to deal with this behaviour and it really affects her confidence and although the rest of the week dd1 behaved very well she finds it hard to remain calm and positive in the face of these behaviours. it had clearly upset her, perhaps a bit too much i thought, although she could have been nervous about telling me.

i have observed her dealing with dd1 and by and large i have been quite impressed with her instinct, she does all the things i have had to read about (distraction, ignoring, basic reward charts etc etc), 90% of the time dd1 responds very well to her and i actually do find it a positive thing on the whole that she spoke to me about it rather than pretending everything is fine and hunky dory.

but i guess my questions are.. one, how do i support her and help her deal with this, and two, is this even normal (dd's behaviour AND the fact that nanny finds it so hard) or a sign that it's not working and should i be thinking about someone else?

thanks if you've made it this far!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Blondeshavemorefun · 26/02/2009 19:55

least the nanny was honest

tantrums are hard and tiring

support your nanny by both sitting down and discussing what you would BOTH do in the same situation - so that dd gets the same message from both of you when she is having a strop

i wouldnt get a new nanny if you are happy with everything else

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/02/2009 19:55

least the nanny was honest

tantrums are hard and tiring

support your nanny by both sitting down and discussing what you would BOTH do in the same situation - so that dd gets the same message from both of you when she is having a strop

i wouldnt get a new nanny if you are happy with everything else

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/02/2009 19:55

least the nanny was honest

tantrums are hard and tiring

support your nanny by both sitting down and discussing what you would BOTH do in the same situation - so that dd gets the same message from both of you when she is having a strop

i wouldnt get a new nanny if you are happy with everything else

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/02/2009 19:55

least the nanny was honest

tantrums are hard and tiring

support your nanny by both sitting down and discussing what you would BOTH do in the same situation - so that dd gets the same message from both of you when she is having a strop

i wouldnt get a new nanny if you are happy with everything else

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/02/2009 19:56

oops

bad laptop!!!!

Tiramissu · 26/02/2009 20:09

What Blondes said (and she posted it many times ) about dd getting the same message from both of you.

Sometimes nannies give up when they feel that mum or dad does diferent things and deals in diferent ways with the situation.

I would have a long chat with the nanny and ask her if she feels like this. Or if she disagrees with my way of responding to dd. Would double check that we have the same line of thinking about childcaring. And perhaps draw a plan together of how to deal with the tantrums.
But eventually if the nanny still not coping then yes i would have to re-consider whether she stays.

I m very impressed about her honesty tbh. And of the way you are dealing with this too. Seems like you have a good relationship and mutual respect so its shame to not find a solution.

Is any posibility that she is going through personal problems and she is very stressed?

RachieB · 26/02/2009 23:22

I too am impressed that she broached this with you

heck tantrums are bad enough when they are your own children ! lol
i find them draining enough and i am only 9 she says !) 30 !!

you both need to work together and support each other,which sounds like you already are

keep communicating

xx

AtheneNoctua · 27/02/2009 09:02

I do think your DD's behaviour is normal. I don't know who coined the phrase "terrible twos" but it is very misleading because it does not end when they turn three -- or even four I'm sorry to say. My DD is much like yours. And so is my neice. My DD is almost 6 and as she gets older we can reason more and she is learning to comtrol her "strops". But it is hard for her because she does have a very strong will and that is just who she is. My neice is 13 now and she is lovely, but does still need to work on channeling her strong will in a positive way.

A strong will is not all bad. I believe it will drive my neice to be a great leader one day. And I hope the same is true for my DD. But, when they are young, it does make the job of parenting/nannying a bit more challenging.

I think it is okay for your nanny to be frustrated. I think it's great that she was open and honest with you. And you should definitely encourage she continue that. Perhaps she just needs to know you share her frustration and that you work out an approach to dealing with the tantrums together, and of course execute them together as well (and this includes your DH).

beforesunrise · 27/02/2009 09:53

thanks everyone, i appreciate your words, and they confirm what i feel. i really really like this nanny and i think in a way the fact that she is so upset is because she cares a bit too much- if that makes sense? but i agree that it's good to talk.

and re dd's behaviour... deep breath... it will get better. i try to think about it in terms of helping her to control her behaviour, which upsets her as much as us i think. this morning she had no tantrum and as we were leaving for nursery she said, all proud, "see mummy? i didn't cry today!"

OP posts:
Tiramissu · 27/02/2009 10:44

That's sweet.

There is a book called 'what people feel', written by a phycologist but i cant remember her name now. It is aimed for this age and teaches children to recognise emotions like anger and therefore learn to express it in better ways.

Also the 'faces' are a good idea. You can buy ready ones or you can make them with piece of card paper.

nomoreamover · 27/02/2009 10:55

I say bravo to the nanny for being honest and to you too for wanting to support her.

Ask the nanny what she wants - is she happy working wiht you - in which case say you are willing to support her through this and do whatever you both need to do - but if she says she wants to go then fine - let her go and find someone else who can cope with typical 3 year old behaviour

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread