anastaisia - hear hear!! I have harped on about having a choice about this before - the childminder should have a choice as to how he/she wants to work, and parents should have a choice as to what type of minder they want. Ofsted can still do inspections to ensure that the basics are still covered (health and safety, etc). If we want to be accredited childminders and do more of an "educational" service, then we can.
As a network childminder, I accept that I must adhere to whatever rules and regulations the network decides we should work to - that means that I do have to follow the EYFS big time. (It does not stop me moaning about it ).
However, it does not stop me thinking that doing a written observation of a 3 month old baby "doing something," photographing the "something," linking it to an area of learning and then devising plans on developing this further is absolutely mental.