Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

worried about childminder-should I change?

10 replies

twinklePinkle · 09/05/2014 23:43

Hello. Any advice would be much appreciated.

Ds 2.5yrs has been attending a cm for two years, since six months old. Childminder is rated highly by ofsted, always full and has lots of experience.

I have been very happy with her, though she has very set views on things, ie behaviour, nap times etc and tends to do things her way rather than agreeing a choice with parents. Recently ds has started speaking more and his behaviour tends to be fairly good for his age compared to some of my friends children, he's quite a shy child and doesn't tantrum much.

Last week when I collected him from cm she had told him off for throwing glitter over the floor, I wasn't there when she told him off but he looked nervous and worried and she said she'd been quite cross when she spoke to him. On the way home he said he'd cried, I have a feeling she's quite controlling.

Today when I collected him he was crying as she'd made him sit at the table and eat all his dinner and not given him fruit for pudding as he'd not eaten his food properly. Cm seemed quite pleased that she'd 'made him finish it eventually' Hmm I may be bring soft here but I feel making a generally non fussy 2yo sit at the table until they've eaten all their food whilst the other children play is quite unkind and overly strict. I can appreciate cm has to have rules, she has several children, but I've made clear I don't want her to force him to eat but she takes no notice. Ds kept crying in the evening at home and in the night about not liking the food he'd been made to eat.

He's also told me that cm puts his food on a child fork and makes him open his mouth by pushing the food when he refuses to eat. I feel quite upset by all this, my eldest didn't use childcare so I'm not sure if I'm being precious here or is cm is being unkind? I'm tempted to move him to a nursery, but ds is always pleased to see cm at drop off and happily walks into her house, so maybe I'm worrying about nothing?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
YoureBeingASillyBilly · 09/05/2014 23:46

Yep- definitely change. She isnt up to date with her ideas on food and food issues in children are so hard to fix (i am an adult with food issues from childhood) i would find a better childminder who doesnt have outdated ideas on food.

ColdFeetWarmHeart · 09/05/2014 23:53

I too would be worried here twinkle. I would mainly be concerned that she is doing things her way, and not either doing things as you would like, or at least making a compromise. I used a CM earlier this year, and we worked things out between us. At home I would generally just give DD 3 main meals, no snacks. However, other kids at CM's had snack mid-morning. Obviously I didn't want DD to sit there not having anything while the boys ate, so I agreed that she could eat then, but asked CM to give her half sandwich or something at this point, rather than filling up on something else and not eating her lunch later on.
That is how it should work. CM should ask what you normally do, and where possible, do the same. If she cannot do the same, she should discuss it with you.

I wouldn't be thinking about DS being pleased to see her in the morning, I'd be focusing on the fact that he has spent this evening crying, as he was made to do something that he really didn't want to do. Especially considering you have already told her that you don't want DS to be made to eat anything!

Do you have any other childcare options?

twinklePinkle · 10/05/2014 11:22

Thank you for your replies! I don't have any easy options to change childcare but will have to go and look at nurseries as I think ds is getting to the age where he'll benefit from nursery. I know cm will definitely not change her views on making children eat all food even if they don't like it, I've asked her not to but she doesn't seem to be up to date with her views...

OP posts:
BobTheFly · 10/05/2014 11:59

Is she worried abut sending him home hungry? I've got a parent who texts me in the evening if she's had to give her son something to eat before bed (I give dinner at 5pm so not unreasonable that he might want a quick snack) but it's always quite shirty as if I've not fed him enough during the day.

HSMMaCM · 10/05/2014 12:34

I was going to say that I'm quite strict, but this sounds more like controlling behaviour.

When did you last sit down and have a meeting. This can be useful for discussing different approaches to behaviour, food, etc.

twinklePinkle · 10/05/2014 13:28

Hi thanks for the CM perspective. We haven't had a sit down as I've made it quite clear in conversation that I don't ever force ds to eat food he doesn't like/I let him finish when he's full. I know from previous conversations I've had that CM will only do things her way, eg no snacks, must nap for one hour etc whenever I've asked her to do things like I would, eg give ds a snack she's said no it doesn't work for her.

I accept she has to have some rules and boundaries with multiple children, but forcing a child to eat every last mouthful of a meal or they can't leave the table etc seems a bit unkind. I suppose I'm a bit Hmm that CM is not interested in my views.

OP posts:
hotcrosshunny · 10/05/2014 18:02

Change cm. Not even a question in my mind bloody hell. Maybe this is the wake up call she needs.

Trollsworth · 10/05/2014 18:05

Child minder is a dick. It's supposed to be childcare. Force feeding is unacceptable in every environment. Force feeding doesn't even happen in prison without massive controversy and potential seeing, so why the fuck does she think she has the right to force feed and innocent little boy? Horrible woman.

lightningstrikes · 13/05/2014 16:29

I'm a childminder and I do have routines that I stick to as in when snacks are and when nap time is. Kids soon settle into different routines at home and at mine. However it sounds like your CM and you are not a good fit - the best arrangements are when parents and cm have similar views on raising kids and there is mutual trust and respect. Forcing food is abusive IMO and I would move him based on that alone. Glitter on the floor would earn strong words from me too though (but I hate glitter and don't have it but in glitter glue and special christmas) Grin

markymark19760 · 15/05/2014 14:15

Maybe this is something you need to look at in more detail. You are taking a childs word for it. may be you can set up some form of camera? I know it fairly topical today? www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2628450/Nagging-doubts-A-hidden-camera-Then-horrifying-moment-I-saw-NANNY-attacking-MY-BABY.html

New posts on this thread. Refresh page