Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

My 20 month-old calls his childminder 'mummy'

34 replies

Dairylea · 21/03/2012 14:07

Hi - Go gently on me, fellow mums netters! I've read a lot of (helpful) threads over the last couple of years but this is the first bit of help I've really needed. My 20 month old ds has a fantastic childminder. I work from home so he is only with her from 9.30-12.30 in the mornings, with one day a week until 5.30pm. He's a very affectionate and loving boy, happy and confident and we have a great time together. He's had the childminder for 3 months and I think she's great - very active, very kind, has a dd of her own and never has more than 4 kids at any one time, and often only two. But the children she minds call her 'mummy'. The first time she told me about it I thought it was because one of the girls she looked after, she'd had since she was 4 months old for over a year. And as her own daughter is often around, the other children hear her being called mummy. So I thought I had better just get over it. But just now, I collected my boy and we all walked down the road together. She was telling me that she'd been playing a game with him - what's your name? (And he says his name.) What's the baby's name? (And my ds says the baby's name.) Then she said: "I asked him, 'What's my name? And he said mummy.' And she smiled proudly. I was a bit gobsmacked. Then, to really drive the point home, she did it all again with him, in front of me.

She really is great, and I don't want to rock my son's world by finding someone else. Nor do I want to engage in some sort of competitive game with my son's affections. I'm completely comfortable that he loves me and knows I love him. But I am deeply unsettled by what happened this morning. Do I just need to get over myself? Or should I say something? Help, please!

Thank you.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Dairylea · 22/03/2012 11:10

Hello all - thank you all again so much for your encouraging messages. Helped me not think I was going a bit mad! So I thought you'd like to know that I talked to her about it this morning, when I dropped my ds off. I said: "After our conversation yesterday, I just wanted to say that I would prefer it if he called you X [her name] rather than Mummy." "Oh, yes!" she said, "I've been thinking about it and..." "I just think it's less confusing," I said. And she agreed. Phew! Maybe she saw something in my face yesterday, or maybe she just thought about it. But I'm really happy. I wouldn't have had the courage to face it if it hadn't been for mumsnet but it's also great that she took it well as she really is good (not at all creepy, I promise!) and we have a nice relationship otherwise. So that's another mumsnet solution and I hope this thread helps anyone else in the future.

OP posts:
HolyLentenPromiseBatman · 22/03/2012 12:54

oh good, I like it when it all works out!

redglow · 22/03/2012 17:14

That's great you got it sorted.

EBDteacher · 22/03/2012 19:44

Oh that's good you sorted it with her- a great childminder is worth her weight in gold, you wouldn't want to lose one over something like that.

Just came on to say my DS (now 19mo) went through a phase at about 11/12 months of calling me by his childminder's name. I didn't mind at first but I did get to the point where I felt a bit sad not hearing him call me mummy. He now has a different childminder (because #1 retired sadly). He currently calls his new CM by her dog's name!! So it really is an area that can cause a bit of confusion to a young child!!

kkoo · 23/03/2012 13:06

It is not uncommon at all for children to call their caregiver (mother or not) Mummy especially when so young. I have a mindee who always calls me Mummy, and his last CM too! I always refer to myself by name to discourage but with this lad I am getting nowhere fast!
It does sound like your minder could have been demonstrating how clever your son is to identify different people, rather than to encourage him to call her Mummy.
BUT I wouldn't like it and it shows that she is letting him call her Mummy without correction, so yes if it bothers you have a word with her.

Fillybuster · 23/03/2012 13:13

Haven't read all the responses, but I would have a huuuuuge problem with that. It's one thing that lots of children call their carers 'mummy' by mistake sometimes, its quite another for her to actively encourage that, or to set herself up in competition with you for that 'title'.

Your ds has one mummy, and that's you. No-one else gets to muscle in on that.

Tbh, I'm shocked that none of the others parents have complained, but I would change cms right away. I know he's happy and settled, but he has only been there for 3 months....she's a bunny boiler, and you really don't want her looking after your child....

girliefriend · 23/03/2012 13:14

Glad you said something I wouldn't like that, although my dd went through a phase of calling me the childminders name - that was Blush Grin

Fillybuster · 23/03/2012 13:16

Ah...now I've caught up and realised that a) you've sorted it and b) my response might have been a bit disproportionate.

Sorry, we had a nanny who lost sight of her 'boundaries' with my dcs and I don't think I'll ever quite recover...!

Glad you've got it under control :)

FloweryFun · 27/03/2012 16:49

thats not good.... :/

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread