Well, I birthed both ways. First time was your standard issue flogging, with the drips and the epidural. I felt very satisfied I had pushed her out. I enjoyed labour once the epi went in.
Second was completely natural, although in hospital. I had a bit of gas and air, but mostly clary sage on a hankie.
Now, I am chuffed to bits that I have a sense of achievement with that 2nd birth. I really am. If I hadn't done that birth, I'd be left with a feeling I had too.
However, in terms of experience. I'll be honest and say the epidural birth was more enjoyable. Once it was in that is. I completely realise that is isn't really meant to be enjoyable, but satisfying maybe. WEll, with dd2 [bit of G&A] I shook, and when dd was handed to me I wanted to just shake. Not meet a baby, not be touched or moved or spoken too. I just felt such pain and intolerance. It lasted a while too. A good half hour, maybe more. It was great to labour natures way - but sheesh. That delivery. Whoah!!
With dd1 [epi] I felt her head crown, I looked and watched myself push her head out. I saw her head rotate and deliver, then raeched down and lifted her up. I had no pain postnataly, no tear [did with dd2] and was up and in the shower after an hour or so.
I feel good about both the births, they were both utterly brilliant in totally different ways.
Just a pov, but I hope you have a great birthing whatever the path you choose, and the path it takes.