Hi there fellow tearophobic :-)
i did promise i would come back after giving birth to let you know how i got on. as you remember i was terrified of tearing and stitches after fairly traumatic 2nd degree tear with dd1 which had to be repaired 4 months later etc etc.
anyway- i had a lovely, very quick and very smooth labour this time- first contraction at 1.45 pm, we got to hospital at 4.15, was already 6 cms so went straight into the pool- the pool was absolutely BLISS, even though contractions were 2 mins apart and very intense it was amazing to be able to relax deeply in between them and the warm water really did take the edge off. i hadn't planned to actually give birth in water but my second stage was super quick- i suddenly felt the baby coming out and screamed in panic that i had to push. at this stage horrible memories of the crowning with dd came flooding back... mw and dh were AMAZING, they both very calmly and soothingly told me not to worry, it was going to be fine, i was fantastic and DON"T PUSH!!! although at first it was sooo hard, i manage not to push and to jsut breathe the baby out very slowly and (i know it sounds like a contradiction!) relaxedly... she came out beautifully in just 2 contractions and the water was simply unbelievable in taking the edge off the crowning pain- and panic.
in the event i did have a secind degree tear again- although under pressure from dh the mw did agree to reclassify it as "one and a half" degree (they thought it was hilarious, me less, but still, nice to know it wasn't extensive or severe). she stitched me up right away and although it is too early to tell whether all will be well i am feeling really confident it will. i had no bruising and swelling thanks to the water and fast 2nd stage and i have to say i feel completely different than with dd1.
so- even though i tore, i tore less badly, and without trauma. i am sure the water was a massive help, but other than that- who knows? just wanted to let you know that my worst fears were completely unfounded and i had a much more positive experience this time.
wishing you the same!