Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Childbirth

Share experiences and get support around labour, birth and recovery.

Home birth success stories? (Or disasters)

65 replies

Brooomhilda · 21/01/2025 13:21

I'm considering a home birth. I am not interested in a birthing pool, so am thinking of getting a blow up mattress for the living room floor, some waterproof sheets and use some old bedding.

Any success stories? I'm trying to avoid hospitals if I can as they make me nervous. If it comes to it, then so be it but avoiding would be good!!

OP posts:
DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 21/01/2025 18:59

Living room floor, old bath towels and bed sheets on top of shower curtains. Not a trace of a stain for either birth except a smidge of meconium from first nappy change.

midwifeCath2 · 21/01/2025 19:00

Rowen32 · 21/01/2025 14:27

At least three deaths in the last year in Ireland of the mother so I would be going to the hospital. I'm sure lots of people have success stories but I wouldn't be able to live with myself if something went wrong..

Scare mongering much?
The last one I looked into was asking for midwife attendance at her birth and they refused to send someone. Had she had maternity care it would like have been a very different situation. It's not as black and white as one being safe and the other not.

There is tons of research to support the safety of home birth for well women and babies.

Dryshampoofordays · 21/01/2025 19:05

First birth was a planned home birth but the midwives were with another woman so I ended up going to hospital. We rented a pool at home but never got to use it!

second baby was born at home on our living room floor - we have a memory foam play mat rug from totter and tumble it was perfect! Again we rented a pool but baby came so fast it was only half full!

We bought inco sheets and laid those on the floor but there wasn’t much mess to be honest. You could lay towels on top of a shower curtain too if you’re planning on birthing in bed or on the sofa.

nothing like cuddling your baby on the sofa after every one has left, best feeling in the world! Good luck OP!

I really want to try for a third and actually experience the birth pool!

elliejjtiny · 21/01/2025 19:10

I had a homebirth with ds1, a transfer with ds2, an attempted induction that ended in natural birth with ds3, an elective c-section with ds4 and an attempted induction that ended in an emergency c-section for ds5.

I loved my home birth. Also I know this is anecdata but 4 of my dc have autism and the ones with the traumatic births are the ones who struggle the most.

Nomnomnew · 21/01/2025 19:13

midwifeCath2 · 21/01/2025 19:00

Scare mongering much?
The last one I looked into was asking for midwife attendance at her birth and they refused to send someone. Had she had maternity care it would like have been a very different situation. It's not as black and white as one being safe and the other not.

There is tons of research to support the safety of home birth for well women and babies.

I’m so happy you’re on this thread @midwifeCath2 - I feel like women who are interested in or who choose homebirth are made out to be crazy, risk takers who are a bit ‘woo’ whereas I actually made a really informed, risk based decision for my homebirth and strongly believe that the reason my baby and I had had such a straightforward intervention free birth is because I was at home.

junerella · 21/01/2025 21:36

My baby would have died if I'd had a home birth. There isn't even a shred of a chance she'd have survived. She barely survived with a whole team of neonatologists and cardiologists. Undiagnosed congenital condition - hers was rare but many aren't.

I heard her struggling to breathe but I didn't see her until a day later. Can't imagine that same thing playing out at home and just watching her pass away.

ChocolateTruffleAssortment · 21/01/2025 21:43

when my husband was doing his obstetric job he came home & said he was so pleased we were planning a home birth & would hopefully stay out of hospital, so different strokes for different folks there with the anecdotes.

DC1 was hospital, DC2 and DC3 were homebirths. Would absolutely plan another home birth if I were to do it again.

comoatoupeira · 21/01/2025 21:45

2025willbemytime · 21/01/2025 18:27

It's one or two days for the safety of your child. No one loves being in hospital. Needs must.

While I love reading the stories of the home births that go well, I think I agree with this.

PreferMyAnimals · 21/01/2025 21:46

Regarding the bed issue, you don't need a high bed. I had mine on the floor. Mine were born at home, one had a dangerous complication.

Anotherdayanotherdollar · 21/01/2025 21:46

Rowen32 · 21/01/2025 14:27

At least three deaths in the last year in Ireland of the mother so I would be going to the hospital. I'm sure lots of people have success stories but I wouldn't be able to live with myself if something went wrong..

3 home births??

PreferMyAnimals · 21/01/2025 21:48

junerella · 21/01/2025 21:36

My baby would have died if I'd had a home birth. There isn't even a shred of a chance she'd have survived. She barely survived with a whole team of neonatologists and cardiologists. Undiagnosed congenital condition - hers was rare but many aren't.

I heard her struggling to breathe but I didn't see her until a day later. Can't imagine that same thing playing out at home and just watching her pass away.

I know of a case where the baby didn't breathe at birth. The midwife had all the basic resus gear and baby was stablised and taken to hospital for further treatment. The baby died in the hospital when their staff took over (no chance of survival anywhere).

ohyesherewego · 21/01/2025 23:00

I am wanting a home birth with my third.

I want to hire a birthing pool but how do you feel it with warm water??

Also I have registered with a hospital , should I have registered differently if wanting a home birth? Is there a home birth registry?

Oceangrey · 21/01/2025 23:02

Brooomhilda · 21/01/2025 16:25

Thanks for all your contributions! I picked up some nasty infections with my last baby in hospital and felt like I was held there for no reason for 3 days when I could have been at home with DH to support (it was Covid and visits were restricted). I want to avoid that trauma as much as possible.

All is good with this pregnancy, no complications and I plan on doing it without pain relief (I did with my first too and managed quite well so no reason not to) so there are fewer reasons for me to be in a medical setting. The only thing I found really helpful was the gas and air, which I understand can be brought for a home birth. But mostly I liked it as a thing to focus on and breath into so I have bought myself some birthing combs to hopefully have the same focussing effect this time. There is a MLU 15 mins away and a hospital with MLU and delivery suite 20 mins away (although DH got there in 12 mins during last birth...) so I'm fairly confident about getting there. At the moment I'm booked in for a tour of the MLU 10 mins away so I'll see how that goes and how I feel there.

I felt really overwhelmed being on a ward bay with 5 other women and babies last time. The lights never went off, there was 1 shower between 10 of us and the woman in the bay next to me kept FaceTiming her boyfriend to argue with him. The whole thing did not work out well. After also getting the infections I got when I got home, I found the stay in the hospital way more traumatic than the actual birth and so now am not very relaxed in them.

Yes, in your situation I would have a home birth.
As I said, the only downside for me was the lack of epidural for my massive baby, but if you're ok without then I'd go for it. You have done it once and you have a hospital nearby.

Where2GoNext · 22/01/2025 18:43

ohyesherewego · 21/01/2025 23:00

I am wanting a home birth with my third.

I want to hire a birthing pool but how do you feel it with warm water??

Also I have registered with a hospital , should I have registered differently if wanting a home birth? Is there a home birth registry?

Please contact your community midwife or team so they can support you with this ☺️ they will know the process for arranging it for you. In my local trust the community midwives come and do a home visit ideally 34-36 weeks to discuss it and make sure your home is suitable, make a note of things like parking and identifying landmarks if it's a tricky house to find. Some areas have dedicated home birth teams who will take over your pregnancy care. We then collect a box of equipment from the hospital ready for the big day 😄

To fill the birth pool you need a clean hose pipe with an attachment for your tap. I'd say most women use pools downstairs so use the kitchen tap. You usually have a pump to help empty it after (we put the pipe out the window into the drain). We have a combi boiler so hot water supply wasn't an issue, but if you use a tank you may need to top it up with kettles and pans of water!

SomeOfMyChildrenAreFurry · 23/01/2025 18:25

I attempted a homebirth with DS at 40+5. Sadly, the little sod had other plans - waters didn't break until I was fully dilated, at which point they discovered a lot of meconium, so had to transfer to hospital. Had a very long pushing stage and his HR started dropping so had to have an episiotomy to get him out, at which point it became apparent the duration was probably on account of him being a compound delivery (came out with his hand on his chin). X-ray confirmed signs of meconium aspiration so we had to stay in hospital for 5 days while he completed his course of IV antibiotics. So, yes, things don't always go to plan...

Currently 27 weeks with DD and have stated that homebirth would be my preference, so the experience hasn't deterred me. Like you, I have a strong dislike of hospitals (spent a painful amount of time visiting my best friend who was terminally ill in hospital nearly 20 years ago). And, as far as I am aware, being in an environment that isn't conducive with you feeling at ease can be counterproductive to the progression of labour. So, my advice would be to talk it through with your MW so that you have all the facts and can make an informed choice. It sounds like you're low risk and have previously managed unmedicated, so you know the score (and, yes, they do bring entonox) but just be mentally prepared that you may need to transfer.

And please, ignore the ridiculous comment about needing a high bed. I don't know what century some people are living in, but the person giving birth isn't responsible for ensuring the comfort of healthcare providers and, in my experience, they typically encourage you to birth in whatever position you feel most comfortable.

Wish you a smooth delivery, wherever you choose to have baby. X

New posts on this thread. Refresh page