You are not mistaken in your observations. I have noticed this many times - not just around birth but also around feeding. Both birth and feeding can share some features -
- they both involve a strong social expectation around "ideal" and "less than ideal" when it comes to choices and practices.
- they both involve a lot of planning, prep and idealising amongst mums as to what they would do or plan to do
- Both experiences can go any which way and end up being less than ideal or traumatic
- Both experiences will come up over and again in conversations here and there as the world continues to multiply.
you are not alone. I have seen many people online and offline feel genuinely hurt, or even attacked - if these topics and alternative choices or experiences come up. Some of this I have noticed recently. Its the result of very complex feelings inside ourselves.
I know I have a similar response when people reminisce about their childhood being idyllic, or family holidays with their parents - nobody is talking about my childhood, mind you - but somewhere something compares, and it jars.
Dont feel you need to do anything for others sake but maybe therapy to resolve these issues for your own peace of mind may work?
As I approach the birth of my first baby (With obvioulsy my own individual prep for birth and feeding) - I have recently made the decision to not discuss these with people, not even online. My sister in law feels very upset if someone mentions breastfeeding - to the extent that a comment along the lines of "I am at my BF group this afternoon" can trigger a reaction thats very emotional and personal about her experiences.
Similarly, my partner and I have decided this week not to mention to anybody at all about our hypnobirthing course, even if we just need some tips. It does trigger strong sentiments among others and we dont know, as first timers, how to respond. We might well be in that position in 2 months time, but that is not a bridge we can cross now.
So for our own benefit we have started keeping completely quiet when any topic of birth plans, hypnobirthing, labour plans, feeding etc comes up. Its really working.
So this is just a perspective from the other side to say - you are absolutely not alone. These are strong, powerdul, emotive issues that stay for a long time. You are not wrong to feel triggered. its one of those things where it is sometimes nobody's fault.