Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Childbirth

Share experiences and get support around labour, birth and recovery.

Participating in clinical trials during childbirth - anyone have any experience?

2 replies

EagleRay · 29/01/2014 22:36

Hi - I gave birth to DD a year ago and in the run-up to the birth I was approached by my local hospital regarding participating in the 35/39 trial. I always felt very uncomfortable with the details of this trial and was fairly vocal about it on related MN threads, and never for a single minute did I consider taking part.

By the way, the 35/39 trial involves induction at 39 weeks in women over 35, in order to see the effect on C-section rates.

Then when I was in labour, I was asked to take part in the Bumpes trial, a different study which looks at the effect of giving birth in different positions when you have an epidural. If you take part, you are assigned a position x or y, and the outcome is recorded.

Now, at the point at which I was approached regarding this trial, I had had virtually no sleep for 2 days thanks to waters breaking and prolonged early labour. All I can recall at the time was that I felt totally out of it and incapable of making sensible decisions. Looking back, I'm actually very surprised I agreed to take part in this study, given my strong feelings on the ethics of the 35/39 study.

Since the birth I've been very busy with DD and the reason this trial has been bothering me a year on is because I've just had a letter through the door asking me to fill in a follow-up survey, and thanking me for taking part. It's really upset me because I suppose they're thanking me for something I would never have agreed to do if I had been capable of making a sensible decision at the time!

I'm also curious as to how many women have taken part in the trial - the cover letter states they are 'well on their way to achieving their target of 3,000 women' but doesn't say how many participants they've recruited so far. I guess it's feasible they won't make their target which would invalidate the whole trial?

Has anyone else been involved in this trial (or the 35/39 one) and how do you feel about it?

Sorry for the long ramble - I still feel surprised that I ended up being in this trial when I didn't feel capable of giving any sort of informed consent. It's also left me with the feeling that being allocated a position to give birth in contributed to the interventions that I ended up with. I may well have had them anyway, but this bloody trial probably didn't help!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
EagleRay · 29/01/2014 22:38

Here's more details on both the trials:

35-39 Trial
Bumpes Trial

OP posts:
Blondie276 · 30/01/2014 04:34

Hi- yes I did although can't really remember much about what the midwife said. I told her I'll give birth how I feel able and if that fits in with trial then fine and then I didn't hear anymore about it. I don't have much thought about it really as I couldn't have cared less by that point and wouldn't have minded anyhow. If it helps people in the future then I guess that's a good thing.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page