Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Cars

Welcome to Cars - check out our Discover page for more

Reliable and economical secondhand car - suggestions please

24 replies

EMGEMG · 01/06/2026 19:34

I'm looking for a secondhand car and I need something reliable reliable, economical and comfy for long drives. And I'm on a tight budget of course!
I'm thinking of a Nissan at the moment - O heard they're pretty reliable at higher mileage. And cost less to buy and run.
Any suggestions are welcome!

OP posts:
DrEmilyCrabtree · 01/06/2026 19:58

Hyundai have a good reputation with me and a number of my friends

Shade17 · 01/06/2026 20:01

I’d probably avoid any Nissan built in the last 10 years or so, Toyota is where I’d be looking.

EMGEMG · 02/06/2026 12:34

DrEmilyCrabtree · 01/06/2026 19:58

Hyundai have a good reputation with me and a number of my friends

These don't seem to appear on 'most reliable' reviews but I'll bear them in mind. Thank you.

OP posts:
DrEmilyCrabtree · 02/06/2026 13:05

I've got an ix20. Its 10yo and i've had it 8 with no issues. I love driving it. 2 good friends have Tucsons, again no issues. For 1 it replaced a previous model (ix35) which was fine, it was just an upgrade. If from new you get a 5 year warranty

JohnofWessex · 02/06/2026 13:09

Kia

If you get one with even a tiny bit of warranty left most dealers seem pretty relaxed about any claims

I got a brand new clutch when they went to fix an oil leak on mine

Littlebitpsycho · 02/06/2026 13:15

My mum has a Honda Jazz and although I don't enjoy it myself (I'm used to my tank of a 4x4) its incredibly economical, reliable as hell and its an absolute tardis inside, it's really quite spacious. Hers was bought for i think 8/9k at 3 years old with less than 10k mileage on it

HughManity · 02/06/2026 13:18

Toyota or Honda Jazz. Also Ford Focus.

Whataflippincircus · 02/06/2026 13:19

Toyota Aygo. They are very reliable.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 06/06/2026 14:21

I’m not a fan of reliability reviews. Most cars are truly ok and often some owners really complain a lot. We have had 6 Land Rovers (Evoque, Discovery, Range Rover) and more than happy with all of them. So - heavy cars are not economical. We had a diesel Porsche Macan - very economical! So would you consider a diesel? Otherwise I’m not convinced any car with loads of mileage is nailed on reliable. You might be better off looking at the cost of spare parts because this is what you will need and will outweigh cost of fuel if you get a big issue!

JohnofWessex · 06/06/2026 19:39

Kia?

herbetta · 06/06/2026 19:58

EMGEMG · 02/06/2026 12:34

These don't seem to appear on 'most reliable' reviews but I'll bear them in mind. Thank you.

I'm currently on my 4th Hyundai i10. I've always done 100k / 5 years. In my current one I'm on 110k in 3 years. I've never had one break down.

Whatever the car, just make sure you service it 6 months post / pre MOT.

Thechateau · 06/06/2026 19:59

Toyota Yaris or Aygo, Honda Jazz, Skoda Fabia.

EMGEMG · 07/06/2026 21:32

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 06/06/2026 14:21

I’m not a fan of reliability reviews. Most cars are truly ok and often some owners really complain a lot. We have had 6 Land Rovers (Evoque, Discovery, Range Rover) and more than happy with all of them. So - heavy cars are not economical. We had a diesel Porsche Macan - very economical! So would you consider a diesel? Otherwise I’m not convinced any car with loads of mileage is nailed on reliable. You might be better off looking at the cost of spare parts because this is what you will need and will outweigh cost of fuel if you get a big issue!

I'm pretending not be hugely envious of your Range Rovers! Love them. However, my budget is a lot smaller. I like your idea about the cost of spare parts though. That's very sensible.

OP posts:
EMGEMG · 07/06/2026 21:33

JohnofWessex · 06/06/2026 19:39

Kia?

Yes, open to a Kia

OP posts:
EMGEMG · 07/06/2026 21:34

Thechateau · 06/06/2026 19:59

Toyota Yaris or Aygo, Honda Jazz, Skoda Fabia.

Apparently Honda is the most reliable car out there so keeping an eye out for the Jazz.

OP posts:
MeetMeOnTheCorner · 11/06/2026 11:39

@EMGEMG How old are you? Anyone holding up traffic by going at a snail’s pace is usually driving a Honda Jazz. They are for seriously slow drivers. I also think an older VW Polo might suit you.

My point about car surveys is they can be flooded by slightly aggrieved people becayse they are voluntary. Some “reliable” cars sell in small numbers and their fans also say they are wonderful but it’s often over stated. There’s also nothing wrong with Fiestas and Toyotas. However I always check for 4 or 5 star ratings when they were new and NCAP ratings for safety. What Car is quite a good source of info.

EMGEMG · 11/06/2026 20:40

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 11/06/2026 11:39

@EMGEMG How old are you? Anyone holding up traffic by going at a snail’s pace is usually driving a Honda Jazz. They are for seriously slow drivers. I also think an older VW Polo might suit you.

My point about car surveys is they can be flooded by slightly aggrieved people becayse they are voluntary. Some “reliable” cars sell in small numbers and their fans also say they are wonderful but it’s often over stated. There’s also nothing wrong with Fiestas and Toyotas. However I always check for 4 or 5 star ratings when they were new and NCAP ratings for safety. What Car is quite a good source of info.

I'm in my 50s! I don't want to drive that slow! 😄

I've asked a few mechanics and they all explain that VWs have run into trouble because of the emissions - they use Ford engines apparently. I've been repeatedly recommended to buy Japanese or Korean cars which outperform others in terms of economic to run and cheaper to repair. I've had no luck with VWs at all, and friends have warned me off Fords and Vauxhalls. But I've reached the conclusion that a lot of a car's condition depends about how careful former owners have been.

OP posts:
Currentquandry · 11/06/2026 20:42

We have had two Skodas and they have been incredibly reliable (we do a lot of miles). But also agree that a lot depends on how well the car has been looked after.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 11/06/2026 23:31

@EMGEMG The emissions was all about diesel engines! Are you buying a diesel? Plus many old diesels weren’t great and you are not being sold it from new so what odds is it to you how VW marketed cars 10 years ago? They aren’t Ford engines as far as I can see if you go for a petrol. Post 2018, What Car gives them 5 stars. They aren’t keen on the diesel engine but not many around, so don’t buy one! They get good reviews on being economic and not very expensive to run. Post 2018 cars are very reliable according to What Car. They are well built and better than many other cars. WC also suggests a Fiesta (nothing wrong with Ford engines!) and a Seat Ibiza -based on more fun to drive.

Daniauto · 07/07/2026 17:07

For a tight budget, I’d look less at the badge and more at the individual car’s history. A well-serviced Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Hyundai or Kia with higher mileage can be a much better buy than a lower-mileage car that has been neglected.

For long drives, I’d prioritise comfort, fuel economy and cheap maintenance. A Toyota Auris, Honda Jazz/Civic, Nissan Note, Hyundai i30 or Kia Ceed could all be worth considering, depending on insurance and running costs.
Before buying, it’s also worth checking how easy and affordable common replacement parts are for that model: things like mirrors, lights, alternators, suspension parts and interior trim.

Looking up used car parts online beforehand can give you a realistic idea of future maintenance costs and help you understand whether keeping the car on the road will be affordable in the long term. Choosing quality used parts can also be a more sustainable option, as it extends the life of existing components, reduces waste and lowers the demand for manufacturing new parts.
I’d avoid anything with no service history, warning lights, clutch issues or signs of poor maintenance, even if the price looks tempting.

JohnofWessex · 07/07/2026 17:20

If you can get a Kia less than 7 years old it will still have some warranty left AND Kia dealers tend to be very 'relaxed' about claims.

I bought a 6 year old Ceed from another garage - I do have a service plan with my local dealer so swapped with my old car

Me 'Please can you give it a once over in case there is any work that neds doing before the warranty expires'
'Sure there is an oil leak between the engine and gearbox which we will do. If you want we can fit a new clutch while we are at it for the price of the kit'
'Please'
Came to pay but was told that they had put in a warranty claim for the clutch so unless Kia rejected it - they didnt I would not have to pay

Daniauto · 08/07/2026 12:03

Daniauto · 07/07/2026 17:07

For a tight budget, I’d look less at the badge and more at the individual car’s history. A well-serviced Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Hyundai or Kia with higher mileage can be a much better buy than a lower-mileage car that has been neglected.

For long drives, I’d prioritise comfort, fuel economy and cheap maintenance. A Toyota Auris, Honda Jazz/Civic, Nissan Note, Hyundai i30 or Kia Ceed could all be worth considering, depending on insurance and running costs.
Before buying, it’s also worth checking how easy and affordable common replacement parts are for that model: things like mirrors, lights, alternators, suspension parts and interior trim.

Looking up used car parts online beforehand can give you a realistic idea of future maintenance costs and help you understand whether keeping the car on the road will be affordable in the long term. Choosing quality used parts can also be a more sustainable option, as it extends the life of existing components, reduces waste and lowers the demand for manufacturing new parts.
I’d avoid anything with no service history, warning lights, clutch issues or signs of poor maintenance, even if the price looks tempting.

I’d also think about parts availability before choosing the car, not just fuel economy or purchase price. On a tight budget, the real cost is often what happens six months later when you need a mirror, headlight, alternator, suspension arm, window regulator or interior trim piece.
Checking used car parts online before buying can give you a better idea of how common and affordable parts are for a specific model. If basic replacement parts are easy to find, the car will usually be much cheaper to keep on the road. It is also a more sustainable approach, because good used parts keep existing components in circulation instead of creating more waste.

Hedjwitch · 25/07/2026 21:09

Just bought my first Suzuki Swift,with 7 year warranty. Sad to have to part with my very trusty Citroen C3 but it has done serious mileage. Hope the Swift is a good choice.

CatVester · 25/07/2026 21:13

I've got a Ford Fiesta. It's 11 years old and has never given me a moment's trouble. Very cheap to run and insure too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page