Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Car seats

Confused about car seat regulations? Find baby car seat advice here. For Mumsnetter-approved essentials, sign up for Mumsnet Swears By emails here.

Recaro Young Profi Plus Infant Carseat - your thoughts please!

8 replies

TheBreadstick · 24/01/2012 16:21

Hi All

Just bought a Maclaren Techno XLR, and now turning my sights to the car seat.

As I only have a three-door hatchback car not sure how practical lugging a carseat in and out of the car to attach to the buggy will be, but as the Recaro Young Profi Plus fits with the Maclaren buggy I just wondered what peoples honest thoughts/experience were of this product?

Thanks in advance! Smile

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
bigpigeon · 24/01/2012 17:21

Supposed to be really good safety wise, but if you get one make sure you get the isofix base because we didn't and it was a complete ballache. The seatbelt of your car has to be really long to accomodate the car seat and it is quite fiddly to fix in and you have to undo the seatbelt to be able to get the baby out of the thing every time. There is no shortcut. If you have a chunky baby then it may feel rather restricted as it is quite narrow inside, especially at shoulder height. My two used to get pretty hot and sweaty in it as well, but then I guess that is a universal problem. I would recommend it but with caution.

justforinfo · 24/01/2012 20:15

Avoid like the plague - Recaro say they have really safe seats and "advanced side impact protection" but they don't actually crash test it >.< EU law doesn't require a side impact test. They ISOfix base is also an absolute ballache to be honest! I'm certainly not saying that it's unsafe, or as crap as a nania infant carrier but there are much better seats out there. What car have you got?

My Opinion - get something else!

TheBreadstick · 25/01/2012 10:17

Thanks Ladies

justforinfo I have a renault clio ('03 reg) it's only a three door so accessing the backseat means pulling the annoying front seats forward and it doesn't give much room for hauling a car seat in and out!

If I go for something else, then not sure it will fit the buggy so something that just stays in situe might be better and leave me more options?!

Jeesh, this is so confusing!

OP posts:
justforinfo · 26/01/2012 00:04

Ok, well you have ISOfix which is a start. Some of the best car seats for newborns that are group 0+ (newborn to 13kg) are:

Britax Babysafe + SHR.

  • There has been some bad reviews on this seat through a problem with the handle sticking, this has now been recognised though so new models won't develop the fault.
  • You can get the ISOfix base which stays in the car and then clip the car seat onto that. (You can also get a 'wedge' for free from Britax to fit under the base to recline the seat more as it is more upright than other baby carriers, this is good though as it gives forces of a crash more room to spread out and reduce the risk to the baby)
  • It is also equipped with D-SIP which is a D-shaped clip that offers superior side impact protection, it basically diverts the forces of the crash around the seat so less force would be on the baby D-SIP
  • The BabySafe+ SHR has also passed i-Size regulations on child seats that are not due to come into force for another 5 years - which means that the side impact protection HAS been tested, and the seat has been crash tested to higher forces, with a dummy that registers the force subjected to the child (Current EU regs only require a 30mph frontal crash test and NO side impact test >.< ) This seat will also last alot longer than the Maxi-cosi for example as it alot taller.

Klippan KISS/Graco DuoLogic

  • This is a seat that is ISOfix or seatbelt fitted from birth through to 18kg. This seat is extra special as it remains rear facing right the way through from birth to the max weight/height of the seat is reached. (other combination seats turn front facing at 9 13kg, front facing seats are nowhere near as safe as rearfacing)

BeSafe iZi Combi/Kid

  • Rearfaces from birth to 18kg
  • the combi can turn front facing although BeSafe do not recommend this until the child is at least 2 1/2 yrs and the best safety experts and doctors recommend rear face to 4 minimum.

Maxi Cosi Cabrio with Easyfix base

  • Newborn to 13kg
  • Fits a majority of buggies and prams (please remember that babies must only be in their car seat for a max of 2 hours, if you intend to make a journey then use the carseat with the pram you'll have to allow for baby being taken out of the seat)
  • A good, solid seat with an easy to use base. Not as good as the Britax safety-wise but a very, very good, practical seat.

Cybex Aton and ISOfix base

  • Good solid seat and also fits alot of travel systems
  • base can fit either seatbelt or isofix

Budget Seats
Seats that may be suitable if you are working within tighter budget

Graco Logico S with base

  • Seatbelt fitted base that stays in the car. When fitted correctly it offers a very sturdy fitment.
  • Graco seat is again quite big, although this may make it a bit harder getting in and out of car it'll last baby longer than the smaller, neater seats.
  • You can normally pick up a base and seat for about £150

Britax First Class

  • Rear facing from newborn to 13kg
  • Then turns front facing till 18kg (can turn front at 9kg but I definately do NOT recommend this! Rear face as long as possible)
  • Passed side impact tests and higher speed crash tests at Britax's testing facility.

Why a base?
70% of car seats are fitted incorrectly, if you get a base for your group 0+ child seat, particuarly making use of an ISOfix base, then you massively reduce the risk of fitting the seat incorrectly. With ISOfix you pretty much can't fit incorrrectly.

It'll also make life a hell of a lot easier for you!

After the baby has outgrown the infant carrier
The baby will only outgrow the infant carrier at the maximum weight of the seat or the top of his/her head being level with the top of the seat. With the above seats this is all 13kg. Apart form the First class, which the baby will most likely outgrow the rear-facing by weight first (I hope or that is one tall baby!) The Klippan/Graco remains rear-facing anyway - you will need to check if the Graco/Klippan will actually fit in your car too as it's quite big!

If you go with a group0+ infant carrier, once the baby has outgrown this I would highly recommend that you keep the child rear-facing in an extended rear-facing seat. Please take a look at the links below for more info on child seats and extended rear facing :)

child seat safety place My website

rearfacing for facts and figures about extended rear facing.

If you need any more help don't hesitate to PM me!

TheBreadstick · 26/01/2012 11:24

WOW! thanks so much justforinfo all this is so helpful.

Very much appreciated! Thanks

OP posts:
justforinfo · 26/01/2012 17:31

No Problem :) glad to be able to help!

indufi · 23/03/2012 22:51

Hi,

I wanted to add to the conversation and ask a question.
I just got my new maclaren techno XLR stroller and the Maclaren by Recaro Young Profi Plus car seat. The problem is that it seeems that they are not compatible as the XLR has tow plasti extensions that do not seem to fit the Recaro adaptors that came with the car seat. i am really disappointed since I thought i made a good choise, ie. ofcourse unless they really are compatible and I can't figure it out.

Anyone can help me with that please?

kasmac · 30/05/2012 17:20

Maclaren changed the techno xlr in 2012, it is no longer compatable with ANY car seat! Seems a strange thing for Maclaren to do!!! I found this out, just before my pram delivery and managed to obtain the shops demo 2011 model instead which does. I am currently researching/looking for a car seat to go with the pram, so cant comment any further as yet.....best get a move on, baby due in 3 weeks!!!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page