Half gathering a plan for next year 
I really like the look of Ribeyre in the Auvergne, which I think will be the main site for the holiday. Looking for a second site and a possible stopover in the Loire. Not sure on exact plans, but will hopefully have 3 weeks to play with:
Plan at the moment,something like: St Malo/Caen - Loire stopover for 2 nights, Auvergne 12, Loire 7.
Sites in order of cost:
Coteaux
les alicourts
fierbois
I like a lake! The last two are much more resort like, and more expensive. Which is fine for the facilities they offer, but then I will feel more like staying on site to use them, rather than exploring. Les alicourts is further away from Loire sites, and also has a minimum booking of a week which is a bit of a pain- we could be more flexible on travel dates by doing a 4-12-5 combo.