Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Trouble with introducing a bottle

6 replies

ForAquaGuide · 18/02/2025 10:59

Hello all,

My DD will be 12 weeks this Friday and we have had issues with introducing a bottle to them since they were 6 weeks old. They are exclusively breastfed because it made sense at the time despite how demanding it's been. The upside is they have been gaining weight and have been feeding well.

I am both nervous and worried about how I've gone about it. We try to give a bottle in the afternoon when my husband's home to help, I haven't had the time or the confidence to try it my myself. First we tried with nuk bottles with some expressed milk I pumped and stored beforehand. After heating it up and giving it to them. They took 2oz before getting upset and crying. To not taking any at all a few times after that.

Since then we have tried formula and I have tried 2 types of bottle with teat (including nuk) and two types of formula (cow and gate and sma) each time we've tried. DH has been the one to give them the bottle and each time we put the teat in and they taste it, they immediately get upset and scream their heads off. I have even tried giving them the bottle but the same thing happens. Despite repeatedly calming them down and trying again, they would get upset and scream and I would eventually give in and breastfeed them and they instantly calmed down and fed.

These failed attempts have led me to be reluctant to introduce a bottle as I found their distress to be too much and because they haven't taken to it I'm worried they never will. This has also led to me not wanting to attempt it every evening due to having the stress of finding time during the day to clean and sterilise to bottles, boil and store the clean water and finding the whole prep aspect overwhelming, especially if after doing all of that. The baby refuses the bottle and we're right back at square one.

There are a number of reasons to why I wish to do both and eventually have them be bottle fed.

The first reason is - daddy and baby bonding. Ever since I found out I was pregnant, we have both loved the idea of him feeding our little one and to have that connection.

The second reason is - going back to work. I hope that by the time baby is 5 months old at least. I will be able to schedule to go back and do my KIT days at work and be able to leave them at home with either dad or a family member knowing they won't need me for food. I won't be in a position to go home and feed nor will it make sense for whoever is looking after baby to come in all the time for me to feed them, especially if I'm not readily available due to my work schedule. We plan to have them go into nursery when they're 9 months old a few days a week once I've gone back to work part time before eventually going full time.

The third reason is - to have a break from it all. Whether it's going out somewhere with baby and being able to give them a bottle out and about or being able to go somewhere ALONE or out on a nice dinner date with hubby and having someone look after them and feed them would be a dream.

The two types of teat we've tried are nuk and Tommy tippee. I'm convinced they hate the Nuk ones but are okay with the Tommy tippee teat. However they don't appear to like the taste of either cow and gate or sma. So tonight i have put one of my pumped bags from the freezer to defrost in the fridge to try later. Hopefully with the combination of the Tommy tippee teat and my own breast milk heated to the right temp, we'll finally get somewhere.

But am I overthinking this? I think since having my LO I've found being a mum to be both rewarding and quite demanding. I stupidly thought they would take to a bottle easily and yet here I am 6 weeks after our first attempt and we've gotten no where. We have attempt this about 6 times I reckon.

Deep down I hate how this whole experience has been like so far and so any help and advice would be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
CocoPlum · 18/02/2025 11:08

Are you in the house when the bottle is offered? If she knows you're there, she's more likely to refuse.

She does not understand a bottle will make her full. If she's hungry she won't want the weird thing in her mouth, she'll want a boob!

There are cups you can use from 3 months, perhaps try those instead?

Bonding can and will happen regardless of whether or not a dad gives a bottle, especially post 3.months when babies are a little more interactive. Make bathtime their thing, or a storytime in the evening.

IHatePumping88 · 01/03/2025 01:27

I exclusively breastfeed my 6 month old, who takes a bottle of expressed bottle every afternoon.

I wouldn't try formula for now, you are just going to confuse things with different tastes.

We tried a few bottles before we settled on the MAM ones, only one he likes so far.

I cannot be anywhere near. Ideally out the house or in a different room for a while, so he doesn't suspect that I am close.

Also make your DH watch some videos on pace feeding.

IHatePumping88 · 01/03/2025 01:28

Also, try fresh milk instead of defrosted milk first. Defrosted milk can taste a bit different. Pump some extra in the morning to give to him later in the day when you're out.

LegoHouse274 · 01/03/2025 01:41

We are going through this with my 4 month old. We have tried many many many times (many times your 6!). Two different bottles and teats. Expressed breast milk (fresh and defrosted). Formula.

Na. Da.

He is not. Having. It.

We've been trying since 2 weeks. My other two children both happily took the first bottle we offered them at 2 weeks plus formula happily too from 6 weeks (both also mostly breastfed).

Sorry that I don't have any sdvice for you. We will absolutely keep trying a couple of times a week. However I'm resigning myself to the reality that it may not be until weaning is well established say around 9-12 months before I can leave this baby for longer than a couple of hours.

SecretSloth99 · 03/03/2025 16:01

Try another bottle - we tried lanisoh and mam but Philips Avent works for us

Whoarethoseguys · 03/03/2025 16:18

Your husband doesn't need to feed the baby to bond with her. Many fathers never feed their babies and still have a very strong bond.
Going back to work is more of an issue. So I suggest that you use expressed milk rather than formula. Breast milk doesn't taste like formula so often a baby used to breast milk won't take to formula and get your husband to feed her while you are not in the room.
I have to say though that some babies never take to the bottle they go straight from the breast to a cup.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread