Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Will a dummy screw everything up?

11 replies

KnitterInTheNW · 26/04/2008 11:48

My DS is 5 weeks old and being fully BF. I'm struggling at night times at the moment, during the day he feeds between 2 1/2 - 3 hours & sometimes longer, cluster feeds in the evening then night times he's a monkey. If DH settles him after a feed he'll sleep for at least 2 1/2 hours, up to 4 hours before he wakes up hungry again. If I put him down after I've fed him, he'll be quiet for a few mins then wakes up shouting again. He'll often fall straight asleep on me and sometimes need topping up again, but as soon as I put him down he'll have his few mins then shout again. He never falls asleep at the breast, he dozes but always sucks on & off. I always have to break him off to put him down. In fact I think he'd actually just suck/drink all night if I let him! I don't think he NEEDS to be sucking all night though as he settles for DH no probs.

He's sleeping in a bedside cot, I don't want to sleep with him lying on me as I won't get sny sleep worrying that he'll roll off or get squished by me or DH. I can't feed lying down, only sitting up rugby ball style because of the enormousness of my boobs and where my niples are, any other position and he can't breathe, and it's uncomfortable for both of us and sore for me because he can't latch on properly.

I have some dummies and was wondering if it would hurt to try settling him with one at night time, as a last resort if everything else fails and I'm certain he's not hungry etc? Thinking if he's sucking he might be distracted from the fact that I'm not holding him.

I think it would help if we could turn his days & nights the other way round, he sleeps soundly on his own during the day between feeds, dozes on me during the cluster feed time in the evenings, then seems to sleep quite lightly at night time. Will he turn himself round when he's a bit older, or should I be doing something to nudge him along a bit?

OP posts:
lilymolly · 26/04/2008 11:50

I bf dd for 5 months and used a dummy at sleep times and she has not been affected in the slightest, now falls asleep on her own with her dummy no problem and I plan to take it off her at xmas when she is 3
I Love the dummy!

isaidno · 26/04/2008 11:52

BF advice is generally not to introduce a dummy before 4 weeks. It sounds like bf is well established so I don't think trying a dummy will hurt. FWIW I gave DS1 a dummy at 6 weeks and DS2 at 4 weeks becuase they were feeding, but sicking the milk back up because they only wanted the comfort. They were both bf and the dummy did not interfere with that.

KnitterInTheNW · 26/04/2008 12:00

Ah yes, I forgot to mention the sicking the milk back up bit!

Thanks for replying, I'll take one up with me tonight and see if it makes any difference.

OP posts:
chipmonkey · 26/04/2008 12:33

Knitter, ds1 and ds2 had dummies for colic and were absolutely fine with them. Ds3 never had a dummy even though he was just as colicky, mainly because he was prem and I didn't want to do anything that might mess up bf. But I have to say that I think it may have been one of the reasons that ds1 and ds2 had no trouble switching between breast and bottle whereas ds3 refused a bottle point-blank when he was a little older.
Your bf is well established by now, so I wouldn't think it would have any adverse effect.

Gangle · 28/04/2008 21:34

Knitter, my DS is just over 4 weeks old and we're having exactly the same problems as you. The only thing that has been working slightly for us is feeding him as much as possible, i.e ensuring he has both breasts rather than one and so can't possiby be hungry, or taking him in bed with us when he refuses to settle but, like you, I don't sleep well for fear of rolling on him. Let me know how the dummy goes as we may need to try one!

katierocket · 28/04/2008 21:35

No I don't think it will screw things up. I think if it helps him settle then don't worry about it.

Tommy · 28/04/2008 21:38

My DS3 is 14 months - still breastfed and has a dummy! I think I gave it to him at about 5-6 weeks as he was always wanting to be fed but I had to go out to collect the older DSs! I put the dummy in while he was in the pram and he was fine. Obviously idn't affect the feeding but not sure how I'll get it off him now - come back in a couple of years and I'll let you know

madamy · 28/04/2008 21:42

All of mine have had a dummy and have been breastfed. I was planning not to give ds one (now 11 mths) as it was hell getting dd1's off her but gave in at 6 weeks!
Can't say it's interfered with breastfeeding though.

notnowbernard · 28/04/2008 21:43

I don't think it will screw things up at 5w

It sounds like feeding is established and you are aware of when he is hungry

FWIW dd1 had a dummy between 3-4w (IIRC)

I do remember DD2 had one at about a week old, but I was confident she was feeding really well and had gained lots of weight etc (and hadn't lost any, either)

Both were excl. bf for 5m (dd1 4m, I think)

The dummy didn't interfere with feeding

I reckon they're marvellous things!

FairyMum · 28/04/2008 21:45

No. All mine had dummies or my nipples would have fallen off a long time ago. Did not interfere with bf at all.

serant · 29/04/2008 15:31

I have given my fbf baby a dummy from 4wks old, now 8wks & much more settled, goes 4hrs between feeds and will also take ebm in a bottle.

I do try to see if he will settle on his own first though & only give it when he's fighting the sleep!!

Good luck.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page