Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Is there a problem with Aptimil?

32 replies

millymilly · 19/07/2007 21:17

Hi - my husband seems to think he heard something on the radio yesterday and feels they might have been saying there is a problem with aptimil for some babies and it makes them ill etc. Typically this is all he got but did anyone else hear this or know anything about it? Many thanks.

OP posts:
VeniVidiVickiQV · 23/07/2007 00:05

I'm laughing. But then, that doesnt count, because we are one and the same

moondog · 23/07/2007 00:05

Why are you posting under that mad name then??

tiktok · 23/07/2007 00:07

at hunker

It's a disgrace if any antenatal classes or indeed midwives are recommending specific brands. They have no way of doing this properly.

There are no independent comparisons between different brands of formula in the UK, and indeed, some of them are made by the same companies, who aim to segment as well as expand the market, as with any other consumer product....Aptamil is posh milk, and SMA is chav milk, as far as I can tell, from what I can see of the marketing and pricing strategies. Note this is not what I think of the contents, just what I can infer of the marketing intentions from the commercial activity surrounding them.

All the formula milks highjack the imagery and the marketing 'feel' of breastfeeding and breastmilk in some way, and all of them are promoted very heavily to healthcare professionals....many of whom are easily persuaded to use a diary, a pen, a post-it note, a calendar or some other cheap trinket with branded colours and logos on it. Many of them fall hook line and sinker for the spurious scientific claims as well, as we see on this thread.

It works, too, as the MORI poll showed that over a third of mothers believed that formula milk was the same or very close to breastmilk.

Sazisi · 23/07/2007 00:22

Hunker you just made me laugh lots and I had to read your post to DH

I tell you what, Aptimil stinks, it bloody smells of farts

nappyaddict · 23/07/2007 02:23

i didnt think they were allowed to recommend one?

twentypence · 23/07/2007 06:02

Is this the prebiotics thing?

Cow and Gate have ads in all the papers here saying 10 million babies can't be wrong. Like 10 million babies exerted their free will and chose it themselves.

I did at the "makes the poos closer to those of breastfed babies" though. Since they are not allowed to say the milk is closer to bm they say the poos are!

VeniVidiVickiQV · 23/07/2007 15:29

Do any ffed babies do bright orange watery poos then? I thought they were like unsavoury Mr Whippys?

Hunker

New posts on this thread. Refresh page