Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

When health professionals give advice in newspapers...

17 replies

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:26

You'd kinda hope they had the faintest clue what they're on about, right?

First letter...fgs.

OP posts:
QuootiepiesBetterThanMincePies · 27/11/2006 00:28

what a load of old clap trap.

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:29

And for those of you who can't be arsed opening links (I know I'm not the only one ):

Baby weight worries
by Dr Jane Collins

The Times paediatric consultant solves your problems

My son, now 8 weeks, is a big baby and I am worried that he is overweight. He was 10lb 2oz (4.6kg) at birth, 11lb 2oz by day nine and weighs 15lb 6oz. He was breast-fed for nine days until I could no longer meet his needs and is on a hungry-baby formula. My health visitor advises not to give more than 37oz in 24 hours and not to start solids until he is six months. Do you agree? Nicola Courtiour, by e-mail

Your son is gaining weight consistently between the 98th and 99.6th centiles, which could be perfectly normal provided his length is also growing along a high centile. One baby in every 260 grows between the 98th and 99.6th centiles. It would be good idea for his length to be measured accurately, and if it is close to his weight centile there is unlikely to be anything to be concerned about.

I agree with your health visitor about not giving him more than about 40oz of milk each day. Try cutting out one night feed, which might encourage him to sleep through the night. If he cries in the night, comfort him but don?t give him milk. If he won?t settle, give him water.

The Department of Health?s advice is not to start solids before six months. But it might be worth starting your son on low-calorie weaning foods before then, although no earlier than 17 weeks. From 17 weeks you could try giving him puréed fruits and vegetables to replace a feed.

When you have a very hungry baby it is easy to feel discouraged and concerned that you might not be meeting his needs through breast-feeding. I know it is not possible for you, but an option for some in these particular circumstances is partial breast-feeding, with formula to top up. The milk supply increases with the demands of the baby. Mixed feeding gives some of the protection against infections provided by breast milk.

OP posts:
lockets · 27/11/2006 00:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ghosty · 27/11/2006 00:30

Red rag to a bull hey hunker?

ghosty · 27/11/2006 00:31

'Breastfed for nine days until I could no longer meet his needs' 9 days? Bfing surely not even close to being established is it?

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:31

Pretty much, Ghosty.

This woman is:

Jane Collins is the chief executive and honorary consultant paediatrician at Great Ormond Street Hospital

I'm wondering if she went to the same school as Gillian McKeith for her qualifications.

(I heard a PMSL comment re GM the other day - somebody on the radio said, "Gillian McKeith, or to give her her full medical title...Gillian McKeith" )

OP posts:
ghosty · 27/11/2006 00:32

PMSL

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:33

It's just wrong in pretty much everything it says, this reply.

It's a bloody great shame she didn't get more help with bfeeding though - she made him gain a pound in nine days, which is doing brilliantly I think.

OP posts:
hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:35

And he's only eight weeks old - relactation's one option (obv only if she wanted to) - and all she's done with this reply is perpetuate the myth that women who have big babies will "never bfeed them"

OP posts:
lockets · 27/11/2006 00:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ghosty · 27/11/2006 00:38

I was thinking that - and she certainly WAS meeting his needs by that weight gain ... DD was big (10lbs 10oz) and had that kind of weight gain too - but I had great support for the bfing (DS was another story but I won't drag that up )
Poor lady ... I wonder if her HV advised her to go onto hungry baby milk? Mine did with DS.
The thing is about this Collins woman is that it seems she is about 7 years behind ... I was advised to wean DS early and not give him more than 40oz a day either. It is all different now.

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:44

No, do tell, Lockets! This chap also said she'd had two of her products taken off the market because they were unlicensed meds - one was for Gentleman's Embarrassment, shall we say - Goatstud Leaf or something and it had a picture of her on the front - just the thing you'd want to see if you're already a bit Brewer's in the trouser department, eh?!

Ghosty, yes - totally out of date info with a nod to the "well the guidelines say, but it's all bollocks and do what you like anyway" tone to it.

OP posts:
lockets · 27/11/2006 00:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

AitchTwoOh · 27/11/2006 00:49

well, they are only guidelines, hunker... the mum knows the baby best and will know what to do... [bollocks emoticon]

hunkermunker · 27/11/2006 00:50

Lockets, that's bloody hilarious! How funny! I bet your friend was in stitches!

Aitch...yes, quite - only guidelines...

OP posts:
lockets · 27/11/2006 00:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

AitchTwoOh · 27/11/2006 01:01

lockets i am going to be telling EVERYONE I KNOW that Gillian McKeech story...

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread