Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

age for reward charts?

7 replies

littlelozz · 16/06/2010 22:45

My DD1 is 3 next week and for the last 3 weeks has been nothing short of a nightmare. Looked at a few posts and it seems to be an age thing.
Is she at an ok age to try a reward chart? The naughty step doesnt work as we live in a flat and tried corners but she just moves away. Tried to bribe her with 'well we wont do such and such if you dont behave'
She has started to blank me and her dad when we talk to her - I just ignore it but DH getting more mad.
Just want to know what to do and if a reward chart or such is the right way to go?
Bloody hard this little person lark!
And got it all to go with DD2 too
Thanks

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Again · 16/06/2010 23:36

I know that lots of people will agree with this approach, but I just want to add a dissenting voice. I think naughty steps, bribes and reward charts are not 'real' consequences and it just teaches people to hide how they really feel and to behave just so that their parents with reward them with random unrelated treats.

I do agree that it's a frustrating time (I have a 3 year old), but they are just finding their feet. I think that the less we say no the more seriously they take it when we do say it. In the real world we don't get stickers for being nice to people.

Even though there are ups and downs, I think that the only thing we can do is to help them express how they feel while explaining why what they are doing is not the way to go - sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't. But distraction does still work for us particularly if we catch it on time and if he wants to be upset about something distraction works afterwards to clear the air - bubbles for instance worked today after he had calmed down. Not holding it against him and keeping really calm myself while not completely cut off from him also helps. It's not personal.

I also find that he needs lots of snacks particularly in the afternoon, even though it seems close to dinner and lots of hugs and individual attention. He's big into made-up stories at the moment. He's quite bossy at the moment too and so I let him tell me what to do when I can so that he feels some control - e.g. no your not a monkey you're a buffalo, no you stand there mum. I think that at playschool he is probably having to experience being bossed around himself!

If I put myself in a child's position I would be soooo angry at being put on a naughty step. Yes eventually I would learn to put on a sweet butter wouldn't melt face, but where does that anger go?

Anyway that's just my view.

Octaviapink · 17/06/2010 05:52

I think the naughty step, corner etc was designed as a step away from smacking, which is obviously an improvement. I'll be interested to know what others think. Our dd is just 14 months so too young for this sort of thing yet, but I'll be interested to know what others do.

SaliMali1 · 17/06/2010 08:29

In my work I have only used a calm down chair with one child who needed to go somewhere to calm and needed a calm spot but he has social and emotional needs. I personally think that the average child can be easiliy distracted before they go into a state where they need a space to calm down but if it works for you then that is up to you.

lukewarmcupoftea · 17/06/2010 09:21

I'm not sure a chart would work as a general behaviour management tool - I think it's more for encouraging very specific actions. We've introduced one for my 2.9 yr old for teeth brushing/ helping to get ready in the morning (as she's a huge prevaricator and I'd never get to work otherwise), and it has worked well.

So I think the age is fine, but you probably need to identify one or two very specific behaviours you want to encourage, rather than a range of behaviour you don't want.

lukewarmcupoftea · 17/06/2010 09:23

Ps I would also recommend the toddler taming book if you haven't seen it already. Maybe she's realised that her behaviour is getting lots of attention (from your dh it sounds like), so that encourages her?

littlelozz · 17/06/2010 11:28

thanks for all your replies just had a quick read shall come back later to reply more

OP posts:
NellyTheElephant · 17/06/2010 21:23

With DD1 I found that a sticker chart worked well from about 3 - but only for very specific things that you are working to achieve, not as a general good behaviour type thing. DD2 was much more aware and amenable to the sticker chart from a younger age as she had seen me doing them with DD1 and so I started using for her from around 2 - again for v specific things, e.g. DD2 had a big relapse on potty training after DS was born, she was about 2.4 at the time, the sticker chart worked miracles. She loves cats so i bought a load of cat stickers and each time she did a poo in the loo rather than pants she could choose and stick on a sticker. 5 stickers in a row with no accidents and she got a packet of chocolate buttons. It worked brilliantly to get her back on track.

I'm not a big naughty step fan. If mine start kicking off with tantrums etc or fighting I tend to take them to their bedroom (often kicking and screaming) and give them their comfort blanket and teddy, you'd be surprised how soon they get calm again and ready to apologise.

As a general behaviour management tool I use pasta jars. At teatime everyday we sit down and run through good and bad behaviour. They tell me what they did well (and badly) and we put sta in for the good things and take it our for the bad. reaching certain levels gets treats. This works really well for my 5 yr old and is a big motivator for good behaviour - 3 yr old a bit too young really but I sort of do it for her too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page