Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Do you think this behaviour in 3.10 year old is anything to worry about?

8 replies

13lucky · 03/05/2010 14:03

Hi there, I've been having a bit of a worry recently about whether there is anything 'wrong' with my dd (she is 3 years and 10 months) or whether we're just going through a difficult stage.

She has always been a challenging child - as a newborn she screamed for the first 6 months of her life non-stop and has then been a very clingy, nervous child who finds it difficult to join in unless she feels completely comfortable in the situation (although this is starting to improve).

She has always been going through some kind of 'phase' - she did hair pulling, poking random children etc etc.

On play dates, she is very demanding of my attention and cannot seem to play with the other children without me playing as well until 5 or 10 mins before we need to leave somewhere and then she is madly engrossed and throws a wobbly because we need to leave!! If she does go off and play, she will attach herself to one child only and 'idolise' this child. At preschool,I have been told that she only plays with one child and follows him around all session, copying what he does.

She interrupts me all the time if we have company and cannot seem to amuse herself for any amount of time (not even 5 mins) when I am speaking to another adult (although she can and does get on and play if we are home alone so perhaps this is an attention seeking thing).

She is very sensitive and melodramatic and cries (or screams!) if the slightest thing going wrong, eg her tower falls down or she can't do something first time (she has always been like this), and if she so much as scratches her finger even slightly, it is a big trauma for her! She always gets very cross when it's windy and shouts for the wind to stop. These outbursts don't go on for hours, but it is one thing after another.

She craves routine and if we alter from the norm, we need to explain what is going to happen in detail, otherwise she becomes very nervous. She always asks what is going to happen tomorrow, the next day, etc etc.

She is going through a very defiant stage with me at the moment and shouts 'No, no, no' to everything I ask her to do from the minute she wakes up, eg getting washed, dressed, breakfast, getting shoes on etc etc. She whinges and whines about having to do absolutely anything I ask!

Despite all this, she is a very loving, funny girl who can play beautifully at imaginative games and can be so loving to her 19 month old brother...at times! At other times, she cannot bear him to get any attention (even though he hardly gets any in comparison her her anyway!). I absolutely love her to bits and just want her to be happy but I'm scared I'm missing something and perhaps she needs some extra support.

I have always been able to cope with her behaviour as she's always been fairly well behaved when we're out and preschool have always said that she behaves beautifully. However, there was an incident at preschool last week where she got up from the table and went to get a tissue. When she came back, one of the teachers had sat in the chair she was sitting in and my dd apparently got very upset and started shouting at the teacher and hitting her on the arm to get her to move. The teacher in charge told her off and apparently my dd had a tantrum but then calmed down and said sorry...but I'm now paranoid that something's not quite right.

Just wondered if anyone could give me their opinion on whether she sounds like she's just pushing boundaries at the moment - or whether there's something more going on.

Sorry it's so long...well done if you made it this far!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
CarGirl · 03/05/2010 14:09

Have you spoken in depth to the pre-school teachers, they should be able to give you and idea if they think there is something to her behaviour that they would like investigating.

Have you ever heard of/read the book the highly sensitive child, it may just be that she is hyper-sensitive and doesn't cope well with life in general at the moment but as she gets older and she learns more coping strategies she will cope better IYSWIM.

reikizen · 03/05/2010 14:19

I think it sounds like a lot more than just pushing boundaries tbh, especially the hitting the preschool teacher thing. Perhaps as cargirl suggests do some reading around sensitive children. Or could it be something physical? Does she have recurrent ear infections or something which make her very sensitive and irritable? Clutching at straws I know. But it sounds like you are coping admirably with a difficult situation, so bloody well done!

13lucky · 03/05/2010 14:40

Thank you both for your replies. CarGirl - she is highly sensitive and I have read parts of the book which she fitted the descriptions of to a tee...I am also highly sensitive.

Reikizen - on the physical side, she has hypotonia and hypermobility so often complains that her legs are tired if we have to walk anywhere. She is also on medication for consipation and often (almost daily) complains of tummy ache so guess these things aren't helping either.

OP posts:
beagle101 · 03/05/2010 14:53

13lucky - we have the same DD! My DD is now 5.5 and started school this year but is also hypermobile and is highly sensitive. Her early years were also spent screaming the place down at - well pretty much everything! She has been on a constipation medication regime for 2.4 years now and we also have the daily tummy issue (she has had an ultrasound and apparently it is all inked to the constipation)

As she has got older - in the last 18 months I think she has started to calm down a lot, I think as she has gained greater understanding about the world around her she is better able to understand why things are perhaps not as she wants them. She is still a slave to routine but is better able to deal with changes. Also being at school has helped a lot in that she now wants to go to friends houses after school and be a big girl so we have a 'routine' that the first 2 or 3 times she goes to play I go too and then she has just started going on her own adn it has been a huge success!

Anyway - just thought I'd post firstly as it is wierd we seem to have the same DD's (albeit mine is a wee bit older!) and also to say that it really does seem to get better as they get that bit older!

Good luck!

suwoo · 03/05/2010 14:56

She sounds just like my DS1 (3.5) and I self diagnosed him as a high needs/sensitive child, with the help of Dr Sears

The main issue I have in addition to all yours is that DS1 doesn't sleepthrough either. He wakes anywhere between once and 4 times.

I have 2 other DC, one younger and one older. DS1 is by far the most demanding and difficult to manage, but he is in general a lovely boy.

You have my sympathies, as these children are very hard work.

13lucky · 03/05/2010 15:03

Thanks beagle101 - I actually cried when I read your post mainly with relief that she's not the only child like this. I'm worrying so much about her starting school and that she won't be able to make friends there...although she does love the idea of children coming to tea etc so it's not like she doesn't want to have friends - it's that she finds it difficult to make friends I think. Did your dd do the copying what other children were doing thing? And did she go through angry, aggressive phases (I don't mean full on hitting or punching etc, just a little slap sometimes at me) And did she go through this defiant stage with you? Thanks again for your reply.

OP posts:
beagle101 · 03/05/2010 15:35

DD did go through a defiant thing definitely - and she also got very angry but only ever at adults - her little brother is 3.6 and she has always been fine with him and she did have friends at nursery BUT she had an absolute-can't-be-separated-from-super-mega-best friend at nursery fro the day they met at 3 years old. Luckily both girls felt the same about each other so rather than one following the other they were sort of all in all to one another. Judging by my DS and watching the little girls in his group at nursery there is nothing like DD and her best friend - I think it may be quite unusual to be so close to the exclusion of others at that age? They are still really close although they go to different schools - luckily we mums get on really well so are happy to make the effort!

I really did think that DD would need extra help at school - not that she isn't bright but that she would find the social aspects of school dififcult but in our case that just hasn't happened - she has blossomed, she has an excellent teacher who I spoke to before she started and also the final year at nursery before school seemed to really calm her down. Nursery started discussing 'going to school' quite early on in the year and did wonders for all the kids but particularly DD. Certainly in our case a bit of planning to ensure she knows what is going on for the week seems now to be all we need to do and the screaming has all but disappeared - DD can still throw the odd wobbly where she absolutely goes to screaming pieces about something or other but those times are now few and far between rather than daily .

Oooh the other thing that made a big difference to DD is horse riding! DD is terrified of all living creatures including rabbits etc but for some reason best known to herself loves great huge horses - we agreed that she could have a riding lessons when she started school and it has really been a Godsend in terms of her development - she knows she can't freak out near the ponies. Maybe when she is a bit older you could find something similar that your DD would like?

Hopefully your DD will follow a similar pattern to ours and as she gets older it WILL hopefully get easier. I know how heart wrenching it can be and you feel so utterly helpless in trying to find something that works or helps them - it is awful watching your precious child just screaming or not being able to just socialse and be happy . It sounds like you are doing a fine job with your DD - just keep going and hopefully things will start to ease as she matures enough to understand how better to understand the world around her and how to ask for the things she needs.

13lucky · 03/05/2010 21:33

Thanks beagle...I'm hoping things will get easier and your posts have given me hope.

Suwoo - sorry didn't see your reply earlier...it is hard work, isn't it? My ds (19 months) is so much easier by comparison.

I love them both to absolute bits but it is bloody hard work some days. Good luck. x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page