Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Should 4 year old go to Grandpa's wake and funeral and see dead body?

31 replies

JHF · 21/04/2010 04:33

Grandpa passed away early Sunday after a week or so in hospital with end stages lung disease.

4 year old son and 18 month old daughter visited him at hospital before he died when he had fairly heavy oxygen masks on. Son said he was afraid. We didn?t go back in the next day or so but he said twice that he thought the masks were making Grandpa ill not better. Obviously reassured him opposite was true. A day later he spontaneously asked to see Grandpa .... I said he could but asked if he would feel afraid. He said he would be afraid but he wanted to go none the less. We did it was a nice few days. Grandpa was in good form and they communicated well over the equipment and had fun. Then he went on life support and we did not bring kids in as the hospital didn?t allow it and it really was too disturbing visually in my view. Before he died I told my son he likely would and asked if he understood he said he did but 'I don?t want to do what you're saying daddy'. Code for I don?t want to hear this. I dropped it. A day later he died. I told him. He said he understood. We didn?t discuss it further. He hasn?t asked any more. Both grandfather and grandson had a nice relationship ? spoke regularly on the phone and grandparents come three or four times a year and spend a month or more.

Tomorrow is the wake and day after is funeral. I have really no idea how to handle. Books on the market to advise on this are really crap. If he was younger he'd be oblivious. If he was a little older we could rationalise and explain it better. The best advise seems to be to be blunt but short ? don?t sugar coat in abstract stuff about the spirit, the soul and heaven as kids that age have difficulty understanding these abstract things.

So what to do about the arrangements? Should we let him see his Grandpa in the casket so he understands and has closure and possibly even a positive, life affirming understanding of death or is the exposure an unnecessary trauma? Should he go to the funeral? I'm erring on skipping the wake but taking him to funeral.

Any practical advice on how to talk to 4 year olds about this stuff and how to manage small kids and funerals much appreciated.

OP posts:
sallyJayGorce · 23/04/2010 22:11

Mytholmroyd - that's where my in laws lived (they've died now - in fact it was FIL's funeral the children came to - wake at the Dusty Miller.) On Midgely Road. Are you from there or do you just love the name? It is rather splendid.
Sorry to mention on this thread.

Fizzylemonade · 23/04/2010 22:45

I am really sorry for your loss. My Mum died nearly 3 months ago, I have a 6 year old and a 3 year old.

In case anyone else is coming to this after the event we were given this for my oldest son, all about the memories of things everyone does with Badger (who dies)

Also a nice thing is to do a memory book of photos and maybe write something about things they did together.

pranma · 24/04/2010 17:38

My dd saw her daddy in his coffin when she was 11.She insisted and felt I had to take her although ds who was 16 didnt want to.Dd totally freaked out,had nightmares for years and even now [she is 35] has flashbacks and wont talk about it.I have never forgiven myself.She was fine at the funeral though.

meandjoe · 24/04/2010 18:27

pranma I am the same about my mum who I saw when I was 9. It was dreadful the whole experience of it made it so much harder to deal with.... But you can't blame yourself. I insisted to my Dad that I wanted to go with him to see her and the vicar said it might be good for the grieving process etc. My brother who didn't go see her now regrets not going and feels guilty that he let her down. It's just such an awful situation and there is no right or wrong thing really. xx
OP I am glad to hear things went as ell as could be expected and your ds is coping with it.

Thediaryofanobody · 24/04/2010 18:32

No I wouldn't. My DH was taken to his grandfathers funeral at 8 years old, it completely traumatized him. It was very hard for him to see adults upset and frightened him grieving.
Him swears will never attend another funeral as long as he lives, he's missed the funerals of the rest of his grandparents, a close friend and cousin. He says he would attempt to go to mine if I died, he's already informed parents he wont be attending their funerals.

Thediaryofanobody · 24/04/2010 18:36

Meant to say: adults upset and grieving frightened him.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page