Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Urgent help please - son's choice of reading material - what would you do?

30 replies

lisalisa · 23/11/2009 21:37

My ds is 10. He went to the library today with my au pair and I have just seen teh books lying on the cofee table in the lounge.

He has come back with 3 pretty graphic and descritpive upsetting books on the holocaust. When I say graphic I mean that there are descriptions of gassings, of the procedures before and after and in depth accounts of what went on and the antisemitims and burnings alive etc.

2 of the books seems a bit less graphic but overall they are not books I would want a 10 year old to read.

AS some background - we are orthodox jewish and ds has seen a film in the summer - Boy in teh Striped PJs which sparked his interest. He knows scant details about the holocaust - we lost relatives to it and he knows that the Germans hated the Jews and killed millions of them. He does not however know the details and the extent of what went on and the years of persectuion and what actually happened.

He has asked me questions since the summer whihc I have done my best to answer honestly but whilst sparing him the details .

Obviously I have not satsifed his curiosity as he has got books out of hte libraray on it.

ASide from my au pair's appalling lack of judgement ( she is a mother herself so I would expect her to be able to cast her eye over ds' choices to make sure she thought them appropriate and at least call me if she thought they weren't ) I am unsure what to do.

If i tell him I don't want him to read the books this wil only make him more curious and he may try to do this again or get hold of material in secret.

On the oter hand he is a deeply sensitive and intelligent boy and I just know this is far too much too young for him to handle nad the images and pain and stories in those books choked me up never mind a 10 yr old.

What would you do please? I need to know by tomorow morning when ds wakes up as he will probalby reach for the books ( he goes through books like water and always reads before and after school).

OP posts:
pranma · 24/11/2009 17:57

What a thoughtful and intelligent boy-you must be so very proud of him.
Congratulations on your parenting.

JaneiteMightBite · 24/11/2009 20:32

Fab - well done you and well done him - gold stars all round. Am v impressed indeed.

shallishanti · 24/11/2009 20:45

this book by Sandi Toksvig
tells the true story of how the Danish people resisted the German occupiers and managed to evaucuate the danish Jews to safety- her family took part in this rescue. It would be suitable for your son I think and I like it because it shows how it is possible to resist tyranny.

lisalisa · 24/11/2009 21:24

Thank you so very much for all your positive responses and book recommendations too. I shall go through these tomorrow when i am a bit less tired.

Ironically after all this ds came to me tonight and said that he wants me to give the books back. Apparantly all day today he felt uneasy and now does not want to go to sleep. He says when he closes his eyes he sees bad images .

He said he does want to read other books on the subject and feels this need to know but gave the books to me and asked me to keep them in my room tonight. He has also asked me just now to put him to bed ( story song and cuddle) which he hasn't asked for in a long time ( usually just a kiss now) so he definitely feels insecure.

This was certainly one of my biggies when it comes to parenting and took all of my resources and MN to deal with it.

Thanks again and going to reply properly and look at book recommendations to morrow.

xxxx

OP posts:
upsydaisysexstylist · 24/11/2009 21:55

Maybe your son would like to read Primo Levi's book If this is a man about his time in Auschwitz as he never loses his compassion and although it will make you weep there is still hope in it. Obviosly read it yourself first, our copy has his other book about jewish partisans in the same volume, which is a part of the story I had never known .

New posts on this thread. Refresh page