Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Please help! It's crunch time - do I make dd (7) go to her swimming lesson (which means tears and tantrums) or let her choose?-

32 replies

merrygoround · 20/09/2009 21:03

DD is 7.5. Frankly she is driving me to despair with some of her behaviour, but one battle that I've had enough of is the weekly swimming lesson. She's been going since she was about 4 or 5 yrs old, and has had a very good but quite strict teacher for about 18 months. The class has other girls her age who she seems to like, and when she is in the lesson she seems to love it. She is average within the group. The teacher has always been pleased with her because she tries hard.

But she has developed a resistance to going to the lesson that is wearing me out. The night before the lesson day she starts by telling me how she's not going. Then in the morning she'll create a drama about it, and by the time for the lesson she is frequently crying. She did this last week, and I offered the choice of staying or going - and she stayed, but was very weepy until she actually got in the pool. Then she was grinning and larking around. The same battle of wits has started again tonight, with her telling me that I can't make her go, and I just want to throw in the towel.

My gut feeling is that she is that she finds swimming hard work and because it doesn't come easy she wants to give up.

I've paid for the whole term, but it's not really about the money. It's just that I don't know whether I should let her choose and therefore lose the opportunity to develop her swimming - or should I keep putting on the pressure? To be honest I do find her behaviour makes me feel angry and that she is somehow letting me down - which is why I'm posting. I need some objective advice, PLEASE! My dp thinks I should let her choose simply because the reality is that I can't force her anyway, and I'm beginning to think that might be the only sane approach.

Sorry this is long. It follows the battles to keep her going to ballet and piano (both of which have bitten the dust) I feel quite upset but am not sure why it is affecting me like this.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Clary · 21/09/2009 00:15

blimey lavendarkate I am not sure that "most" kids get bronze medal by 9yrs!

DS1 no way (he's 10) and DD is 8 and a way off that. In fact her very good swimmer friend is not there yet either. Just don't want you to alarm people.

I agree with those who say swimming, unliek ballet etc, is a life skill you need. I would encourage her to continue to a certain level. Can she swim, say 10 lengths of the pool with a good stroke? My DS1 can and so we have stopped lessons for him.

notimetoshop · 21/09/2009 00:18

Presumably if she can swim, then all she needs to do to get better at swimming is practise. She doesn't need to go to lessons. You could take her, or as you say she'll go at school, but she won't practise if she doesn't like it. So work on the liking it.

She may decide as she gets better that actually she quite liked going and wants to go again.

I don't think there is any worry in the stickability thing. She has stuck at it for almost half her life, probably almost all of her remembered life.

lavenderkate · 21/09/2009 09:53

probably not Clary, just seemed that way when all the kids were way ahead of mine in lessons. Mine were too busy chatting (where do they get that lifeskill from)

francagoestohollywood · 21/09/2009 10:12

If she is confident enough in the water I'd drop the swimming lessons.
But I'd explain to her that since you've paid for this term, she'll have to go. She will then be able to pick another activity.

merrygoround · 21/09/2009 11:35

Just thought I'd post with the results of all your suggestions. It was a bit like getting blood from a stone, but this morning, when dd was relaxed (no school today as closed for Eid), I got her to think about the pros and cons of both swimming and her lessons. The negative was basically that it was hard; the positive was the fun side. I came up with three options- quit altogether; change the lesson day/time/teacher; or keep going (either till Christmas or beyond).

When she was faced with the options she suddenly said "why am I being stupid? I'll keep going!" I wasn't expecting that, but I think it was because, despite her resistance to my rather forced tactic of getting to think about it, she had remembered the better things about swimming.

However, I have agreed to ask her teacher if she can drop down a level - the main advantage of that would be to make it less tiring, as well as slightly easier. I am not convinced the teacher will go with this, so my dd has agreed that she will keep going even if he refuses her request (or can't fit her in).

To finalise things, and taking on some of the posts above, I've also agreed that she will get something from the machine each time if she doesn't cry and moan about going; and that she can play with me in the pool after her lesson.

So thanks all for posting - I was at my wits end last night, and it really helped to get your input.

OP posts:
lavenderkate · 21/09/2009 21:44

Yay !! Well done Merrygoround!

samsysoo · 27/09/2009 20:46

Same exhausting malarcky with DS 7.
You have made some great suggestions for yourself.earlier times with friends.treats after etc. Then a limit.you can drop when you can do ..whatever. No whinging.do not entertain any words of negativity......give a consequence each time she starts.ie: 10 mins less on the DS or something.

I had the same probs with my kid.drove me mad.also a strict teacher.no fun.who can blame them for hating it..............however..persevered and today he has moved to the next level.lane swimming and loves it!!!
Piano.another battle ground.changed teachers.worked great with a nice teacher who wasn't using pressure to drive him forward- engaged with fun instead!
Still, best thing is to get them to prblem solve.ask for any suggestions .explain that you want her safe.so agree what level swimming she thinks would be good. Let her brainstorm suggestions to the problem. Don't comment just write.then discuss the acceptable solutions. I did this with my child over piano.it worked so well it amazed me and we resolved the problem.
Good luck

New posts on this thread. Refresh page